Cold Stone Creamery turns ice cream into a performance art, with mix-ins folded right into your choice of premium flavors on a frozen granite stone. If you are looking for the Cold Stone Creamery Menu with Prices, you have come to the right place because we have broken down every category so you know exactly what to expect before you walk up to the counter.
Prices can shift slightly depending on your location and local franchise taxes, but the numbers below reflect the current national averages. This guide covers signature creations, custom built ice cream, cakes, and even the secret menu items that regulars swear by.
Understanding The Pricing Structure
Cold Stone does not price every scoop the same way. They use a tiered system based on the size of the cup or cone you choose, and then they add a cost for the mix-ins you select. This is important because a “small” with three add-ins will cost more than a “small” with just one.
You will always pay for the base ice cream first. Then, you pay for the number of mix-ins you want folded into the stone. Most locations charge per mix-in, but some franchise owners bundle the price into the size. Always ask for a breakdown if the total seems high.
Ice Cream Cup And Cone Sizes
Here are the standard sizes and their average prices for a plain scoop with no mix-ins. These are the base prices you will see on the menu board.
- Like It (Small) – $5.49
- Love It (Medium) – $6.49
- Gotta Have It (Large) – $7.49
These prices include the ice cream and the cone if you choose a waffle cone. If you want a chocolate dipped waffle cone, you will pay an extra $1.29 on top of the base price. A cake cone is always free, but the waffle cone upgrade is worth the money because it is baked fresh in store.
Cold Stone Creamery Menu With Prices
Now we get into the real meat of the menu. The signature creations are pre-designed combinations that come with specific ice cream flavors and mix-ins. They are priced by size only, which means you do not pay extra for the number of ingredients inside.
Signature Creations Pricing
These are the famous recipes that Cold Stone built their name on. Each one has a specific flavor base and a set list of mix-ins that the crew member folds together on the cold stone.
- Birthday Cake Remix – $6.29 (Like It), $7.29 (Love It), $8.29 (Gotta Have It)
- Coffee Lovers Only – $6.29 (Like It), $7.29 (Love It), $8.29 (Gotta Have It)
- Cookie Doughn’t You Want Some – $6.49 (Like It), $7.49 (Love It), $8.49 (Gotta Have It)
- Peanut Butter Cup Perfection – $6.49 (Like It), $7.49 (Love It), $8.49 (Gotta Have It)
- Strawberry Banana Rendezvous – $6.29 (Like It), $7.29 (Love It), $8.29 (Gotta Have It)
- Chocolate Devotion – $6.49 (Like It), $7.49 (Love It), $8.49 (Gotta Have It)
The signature creations are the best value if you want a complex flavor profile. If you tried to order a custom cup with the same ingredients, you would end up paying roughly $1.50 more per serving. Stick to the signatures when you want a reliable treat.
Custom Creation Pricing
When you build your own ice cream, you start with a base size price and then add the cost of each mix-in. The base prices are the same as the plain scoops listed above, but the mix-ins change the final total.
- 1 Mix-In – $0.99
- 2 Mix-Ins – $1.89
- 3 Mix-Ins – $2.69
- 4 Mix-Ins – $3.49
Most people stop at three mix-ins because the fourth one tends to overwhelm the ice cream flavor. The crew will ask you to choose your ice cream base first, then your mix-ins. You can pick from over 30 different mix-ins including fruits, candies, nuts, and baked goods.
Popular Mix-In Options
Here is a quick list of the most requested mix-ins and their average price per serving. Some premium items like macadamia nuts or imported chocolate cost a little more.
- Brownie Bites – $0.99
- Cookie Dough – $0.99
- Oreo Crunch – $0.99
- M&Ms – $0.99
- Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups – $1.29
- Fresh Strawberries – $1.29
- Banana – $0.99
- Walnuts – $1.29
- Pecans – $1.29
- Caramel Sauce – $0.99
- Fudge Sauce – $0.99
- Marshmallows – $0.99
Do not forget that you can also add a second ice cream flavor to your cup. That is called a “split” and it costs an additional $0.79. This is a great way to get two different tastes in one serving without paying for a full second scoop.
Ice Cream Cakes And Pies
Cold Stone is not just about the immediate cup. They make custom ice cream cakes for birthdays, anniversaries, and office parties. These cakes are assembled on the stone with layers of ice cream, fudge, and your choice of mix-ins.
Round Cake Prices
The round cakes come in three standard sizes. You can pick any ice cream flavor and any mix-ins for the middle layer. The price includes the decorative frosting and the message written on top.
- 6-Inch Round Cake (Serves 4-6) – $29.99
- 8-Inch Round Cake (Serves 8-10) – $39.99
- 10-Inch Round Cake (Serves 12-14) – $49.99
These cakes are not pre-made in a factory. The store assembles them when you place your order, which is why you need to give at least 24 hours notice. If you walk in and ask for a cake immediately, they might have a few basic designs ready, but the custom ones require the lead time.
Sheet Cake Prices
For larger groups, the sheet cakes are the most economical option. They feed more people per dollar than the round cakes.
- Quarter Sheet (Serves 8-12) – $44.99
- Half Sheet (Serves 16-20) – $59.99
- Full Sheet (Serves 32-40) – $89.99
Keep in mind that the sheet cakes only come in a few standard flavor combinations. You cannot fully customize the middle layer like you can with the round cakes. The most common sheet cake flavor is the Birthday Cake Remix with rainbow sprinkles.
Shakes And Smoothies
Cold Stone also serves hand-spun shakes that use their premium ice cream as the base. These are thicker than fast food shakes because they do not use a soft serve machine. The shake prices are lower than the cup prices because the serving size is smaller.
Shake Flavors And Prices
- Chocolate Shake – $5.99
- Vanilla Shake – $5.99
- Strawberry Shake – $5.99
- Birthday Cake Shake – $6.49
- Coffee Shake – $6.49
- Peanut Butter Shake – $6.49
You can add a whipped cream topping and a cherry for free. If you want to add a brownie or cookie pieces into the shake, that is an extra $0.99. The shakes come in one size only, which is about 16 ounces.
Fruit Smoothies
The smoothies are made with real fruit puree and a scoop of sherbet. They are dairy-free if you ask for the non-dairy version, but the standard recipe includes the sherbet.
- Strawberry Banana Smoothie – $5.49
- Mango Smoothie – $5.49
- Peach Smoothie – $5.49
- Mixed Berry Smoothie – $5.49
These smoothies are not as thick as the shakes. They are meant to be sipped through a straw and are a lighter option if you want something cold but not as heavy as the ice cream.
Toppings And Extras
Beyond the mix-ins that go into the ice cream, you can add toppings on top of the finished creation. These are different from mix-ins because they are not folded into the ice cream. They sit on top of the scoop.
- Whipped Cream – Free
- Hot Fudge – $0.99
- Caramel Drizzle – $0.99
- Chocolate Shavings – $0.79
- Chopped Nuts – $0.79
- Rainbow Sprinkles – $0.49
- Cherry – Free
If you are ordering a sundae, the toppings are included in the sundae price. Sundaes start at $6.99 and come with three scoops of ice cream, two toppings, and whipped cream. That is a better deal than ordering a cup and adding toppings separately.
Secret Menu Items
Cold Stone has an unofficial secret menu that is not printed on the board. You can order these items by name and the crew will know what you are talking about if they have been trained well. The prices are the same as the signature creations because they use the same base pricing structure.
- Pink Cadillac – Strawberry ice cream with graham cracker crust, pie crust, and strawberries
- Banana Split In A Cup – Banana ice cream with pineapple, strawberry, and chocolate fudge
- Churro – Cinnamon ice cream with churro pieces and caramel
- Peanut Butter Brownie – Chocolate ice cream with peanut butter and brownie bites
- Apple Pie – French toast ice cream with apple pie filling and cinnamon
These secret items are not guaranteed at every location. If the store does not carry the specific ice cream flavor needed, they will tell you and offer a substitution. The price matches the Love It size at around $7.29.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why Is Cold Stone So Expensive Compared To Other Ice Cream Shops?
Cold Stone charges more because they use a higher butterfat ice cream base and they fold in fresh mix-ins at the point of sale. The theatrics of the stone also add labor cost. You are paying for the experience and the premium ingredients.
Can I Get A Discount On The Cold Stone Creamery Menu With Prices If I Order Online?
Sometimes. The app occasionally offers buy one get one free deals or a $2 off coupon for new users. The in-store prices are usually the same as the app prices, but the app has exclusive digital coupons that you cannot use at the register.
Does Cold Stone Have A Rewards Program?
Yes, it is called My Cold Stone Rewards. You earn points for every dollar you spend. Once you reach 150 points, you get a free Like It size creation. The points expire after 90 days of inactivity, so use them regularly.
Are There Any Vegan Or Dairy-free Options On The Menu?
Cold Stone offers a sorbet that is dairy-free, and they have a vegan chocolate ice cream made with coconut milk. The mix-ins like fresh fruit and nuts are also vegan. You just need to tell the crew to use a clean scoop and a clean stone to avoid cross contamination.
What Is The Cheapest Thing I Can Buy At Cold Stone?
The cheapest item is the kid’s size cup with no mix-ins, which costs about $3.99. You can also get a plain cake cone with a single scoop of ice cream for around $4.49. The smoothies are also a lower price point if you skip the shake.
Now you have the full picture of the Cold Stone Creamery menu with prices. The total for your visit will depend on the size, the number of mix-ins, and whether you upgrade to a waffle cone. A typical custom creation with two mix-ins in a Love It size will land around $8.38 before tax. That is a fair price for a treat that is made fresh right in front of you, and the portion sizes are generous enough to share if you are not feeling greedy.
Before you go, check the Cold Stone website for local franchise pricing because some states have higher dairy costs. The menu items stay the same across the country, but the numbers on the register can differ by a few cents or even a full dollar in expensive cities. Ask the crew about the daily special or the “creation of the month” because those are often priced slightly lower than the regular signature items to encourage you to try something new.
One last tip: if you bring a friend on a Tuesday, some locations run a two-for-one special on the Like It size cups. It is not advertised nationally, but it is worth asking about when you walk in. The staff will usually honor the deal if they have it running that day, and it is the best way to try two different flavors without spending double.