A slice of Polly’s famous pie is tempting, but the full menu shows you that the pot pies and dinner plates offer more substantial value. Before you order, you need a clear look at the Polly’s Pies Menu with Prices so you can plan your meal without any surprises at the register.
Polly’s Pies has been a Southern California staple for decades. People know it for the bakery case, but the diner-style kitchen serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner all day. The portions are generous, and the prices are fair for the amount of food you recieve.
This guide breaks down the current costs for every major category. We will cover breakfast items, burgers, sandwiches, salads, and the famous pot pies. You will also see the pie prices, because you came for that dessert first.
Polly’s Pies Menu With Prices
The menu is extensive, which can feel overwhelming when you are hungry. We have organized the main sections below so you can find what you need fast. Remember that prices can shift slightly by location, but these figures are accurate for most stores in 2024.
Breakfast Favorites And Costs
Breakfast is served all day, which is a huge win for late risers. You can get classic eggs, pancakes, or a hearty skillet any time.
- Two Eggs Any Style: $9.99 (includes toast and hash browns)
- Buttermilk Pancake Stack: $8.49 (add blueberries for $1.50)
- Polly’s Country Breakfast: $13.29 (eggs, bacon, sausage, and pancake)
- Denver Omelette: $12.79 (served with salsa and sour cream)
- Huevos Rancheros: $12.49 (corn tortillas, refried beans, over-easy eggs)
- French Toast Combo: $11.99 (thick cut, dusted with powder sugar)
Most breakfast plates come with a side of fruit or cottage cheese. You can swap hash browns for a fresh tomato slice if you want a lighter option. Coffee refills are free, and the server will keep your mug full.
Handcrafted Burgers And Sandwiches
Lunch time brings out the burger crowd. The patties are never frozen, and the buns are baked in-house. You will taste the difference immediately.
- Classic Cheeseburger: $11.99 (served with fries or side salad)
- Bacon Avocado Burger: $13.49 (swiss cheese and garlic aioli)
- Turkey Avocado Club: $12.79 (triple decker on sourdough)
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich: $11.49 (marinated breast, lettuce, tomato)
- Philly Cheesesteak: $12.99 (shaved beef, peppers, onions, provolone)
All sandwiches include a pickle spear and your choice of side. Upgrade to onion rings for $1.99, or get a cup of soup for an extra $2.50. The burgers are messy in the best way, so grab extra napkins.
Fresh Salads And Light Bites
If you want something green, the salad selection is better than most diners. The dressings are made in-house, and the greens are crisp.
- Grilled Chicken Caesar: $11.99 (parmesan crisps, creamy dressing)
- Cobb Salad: $12.49 (turkey, bacon, egg, blue cheese crumbles)
- Strawberry Pecan Salad: $11.79 (candied nuts, balsamic glaze)
- Chinese Chicken Salad: $12.29 (crispy wontons, sesame dressing)
You can add a scoop of tuna or chicken salad to any green salad for $3.00. The salads are large enough to share, but you might not want to. The house vinaigrette is a customer favorite, and you can buy bottles of it at the counter.
The Famous Pot Pies
This is the item that made Polly’s a legend. The pot pies are baked in a flaky crust and filled with real chunks of meat and vegetables. They come to your table bubbling hot.
- Chicken Pot Pie (Individual): $13.99
- Turkey Pot Pie (Individual): $14.29
- Beef Pot Pie (Individual): $14.99
- Vegetarian Pot Pie (Individual): $12.99
- Chicken Pot Pie (Family Size): $29.99 (feeds 4-6 people)
Each pot pie is served with a small side salad or a cup of soup. The crust is buttery and golden, and the filling is thick, not watery. You will need to let it cool for a few minutes before digging in, because the steam is intense.
Pro tip: Order the family size pot pie to take home. It reheats beautifully in the oven, and it makes an easy dinner for a busy weeknight. The individual pies are filling enough for one person, but you might not have room for dessert after.
Dinner Plates And Entrees
Dinner service starts at 4 PM, but the menu items are available all day at some locations. The dinner plates come with two sides and fresh bread.
- Roasted Turkey Dinner: $14.99 (mashed potatoes, gravy, cranberry sauce)
- Meatloaf With Brown Gravy: $13.79 (caramelized onion topping)
- Grilled Salmon: $16.49 (lemon butter sauce, seasonal veggies)
- Chicken Fried Steak: $14.29 (country gravy, mashed potatoes)
- Baked Ham With Pineapple: $13.99 (brown sugar glaze)
Side choices include mashed potatoes, steamed broccoli, corn, green beans, mac and cheese, or a baked potato. You can mix and match, but you cannot double up on the same side. The meatloaf is a top seller, and it sells out on weekends.
Soup And Chili Options
Every day brings a different soup selection. The menu boards near the register list the daily options, but you can always count on a few classics.
- Cup Of Soup Of The Day: $4.29
- Bowl Of Soup Of The Day: $5.79
- Chili With Beans: $5.99 (bowl) or $4.49 (cup)
- Sourdough Bread Bowl With Soup: $7.99
The soup and a half sandwich combo is a smart lunch choice. You get a cup of soup, half a sandwich, and a small side salad for $10.99. It is a lighter meal that still feels satisfying.
Kids Menu And Senior Portions
Families are welcome here, and the kids menu keeps little ones happy. Senior citizens also get a discount on certain items, so ask your server.
- Kids Chicken Tenders: $6.99 (with fries or fruit)
- Kids Mac And Cheese: $5.99
- Kids Mini Pot Pie: $7.49
- Kids Grilled Cheese: $5.79
Senior portions are available for select entrees. These are smaller plates at a reduced price, usually about $2.00 less than the full portion. You must be 62 or older to qualify, and no ID is required at most locations.
Pies, Cakes, And Desserts
Here is the main event. The pie case is the first thing you see when you walk in, and it is hard to resist. The prices below are for a single slice or a whole pie.
- Single Slice Of Pie: $5.49
- Whole Pie (9-inch): $21.99
- Apple Crumb Pie: $22.99 (whole)
- Banana Cream Pie: $23.49 (whole)
- Chocolate Silk Pie: $22.49 (whole)
- Coconut Cream Pie: $23.49 (whole)
- Lemon Meringue Pie: $22.99 (whole)
You can add a scoop of vanilla ice cream to any slice for $1.29. Whipped cream is free, and you can ask for it on the side. The pies are baked fresh every morning, and the seasonal flavors change with the holidays.
During Thanksgiving and Christmas, you need to pre-order whole pies at least 48 hours in advance. The holiday rush is real, and they sell out fast. Call your local store to reserve your pumpkin or pecan pie.
Beverages And Drinks
Drinks are standard diner fare, but the fresh-squeezed orange juice is worth the extra cost.
- Soft Drinks (Refillable): $2.99
- Fresh Orange Juice: $3.79
- Coffee Or Hot Tea: $2.49
- Iced Tea (Unsweetened): $2.79
- Milkshake Or Malt: $5.99
The milkshakes are thick and made with real ice cream. You can get chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, or seasonal flavors. They are big enough to share, but you will probably want it all to yourself.
Daily Specials And Deals
If you want to save money, visit on the right day. The specials rotate, but the schedule is consistent across most locations.
- Monday: Meatloaf Special, $11.99
- Tuesday: Taco Salad Day, $10.49
- Wednesday: Chicken Pot Pie Special, $11.99
- Thursday: Turkey Dinner Special, $12.49
- Friday: Fish And Chips, $12.99
These specials include the entree and one side. They are only available during lunch hours, from 11 AM to 4 PM. Check with your local store because some locations run different promotions.
How To Order And Save Money
You can order at the counter for takeout, or you can sit down and have a server. Both options work, but the dine-in experience is more relaxed.
- Check the daily specials board before you look at the full menu.
- Ask about the senior discount if it applies to you.
- Sign up for the email club to get a free slice of pie on your birthday.
- Order the family pot pie for takeout to feed a crowd on a budget.
- Split a whole pie with friends to get the best price per slice.
The email club also sends out coupons for buy-one-get-one-free slices. These coupons appear about once a month, and they are worth waiting for. You can sign up at the register or on the website.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Polly’s Pies have a gluten-free menu?
They offer a gluten-free pie crust option for some pies, but the regular menu is limited. You can order salads and grilled proteins without bread. Ask your server for the current gluten-free options.
Are the prices the same at every location?
Prices are very similar, but franchise locations may adjust slightly for local costs. The differences are usually less than 50 cents per item. Call ahead if you need exact pricing.
Can I order a whole pie online?
Yes, you can order whole pies through the website for pickup. The online system lets you choose your pickup time and pay in advance. This is the best way to guarantee your pie is ready.
Is there a military discount?
Yes, Polly’s offers a 10% discount to active military and veterans. You need to show a valid military ID. This discount applies to dine-in and takeout orders.
What is the most popular pie flavor?
The apple crumb pie is the bestseller year-round. The banana cream pie is a close second. If you visit in the fall, the pumpkin pie with a pecan topping is a seasonal favorite.
Final Thoughts On Pricing
Polly’s Pies is not the cheapest diner in town, but the quality justifies the cost. You are paying for scratch-made crusts, fresh ingredients, and generous portions. A full meal with a drink and dessert will run you about $25 to $30 per person.
The best value is the pot pie special on Wednesday or the family size pie for sharing. If you are on a budget, skip the appetizers and save room for the dessert. The portions are large enough that you might not need an appetizer anyway.
Next time you visit, you will know exactly what to expect at the register. The menu is big, but now you have the price breakdown in your pocket. Go hungry, bring friends, and leave with a box of leftovers.
One last tip: the parking lots can get crowded on Sunday mornings after church. Go early or late to avoid the rush. The wait is worth it, but nobody likes standing around when you can smell the bacon.
Polly’s Pies has been serving these recipes for over 50 years, and the prices remain reasonable for the quality. You can trust that your meal will be consistent, hot, and filling. That is the kind of reliability that keeps families coming back generation after generation.