Comparing Paisano’s Pizza prices against their portion sizes tells you exactly where the best deals are hiding. When you look at the full Paisano’s Pizza Menu with Prices, you will notice that not every large pizza gives you the same value for your dollar. Some specialty pies carry a heavy premium, while others are priced to move quickly.
This guide breaks down the entire menu, item by item. We will look at the classic pizzas, the specialty options, the sides, and the desserts. You will also learn how to order smart so you get the most food for your money. Let us start with the main event, which is the pizza itself.
Pizza Size Options And Base Pricing
Paisano’s keeps the sizing simple. You generally have three choices for a standard round pizza. The price difference between a medium and a large is often smaller than you think.
- Small (10-inch): Best for one person or a light meal for two.
- Medium (12-inch): Good for two people, or one hungry person with leftovers.
- Large (16-inch): The best value per square inch. Feeds three to four people.
- X-Large (18-inch): Available at select locations. Great for parties.
You should always check the square inches, not just the diameter. A 16-inch pizza is not just 33% bigger than a 12-inch. It is actually about 78% more pizza. If the price difference between a medium and a large is less than six dollars, the large is always the better deal.
Classic Cheese And Pepperoni Pricing
The base cheese pizza is your benchmark. This is the price you use to compare everything else on the menu. A plain cheese usually costs between $9.99 and $12.99 depending on the size.
Pepperoni is the most popular topping. It typically adds a flat charge, not a percentage. Expect to pay around $2.00 to $3.00 extra for pepperoni on a large. This flat rate means that loading up a large pizza with toppings is often cheaper per topping than adding them to a small.
Paisano’s Pizza Menu With Prices For Specialty Pies
This is where the menu gets interesting. The specialty pizzas are pre-designed combinations. They often sound amazing, but they also carry the highest profit margins for the restaurant. You need to check the price per topping here.
For example, a “Meat Lovers” pizza might cost $19.99 for a large. If you were to order a plain cheese and add pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon, you might only pay $16.50. The difference is convenience. You pay extra for them to choose the toppings for you.
Signature Meat Pizzas
These pies are heavy and filling. They are designed for people who want protein with every bite.
- The Carnivore: Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, and bacon. Usually $18.99 for a large.
- BBQ Chicken: Grilled chicken, red onion, and BBQ sauce base. Usually $17.49 for a large.
- Buffalo Chicken: Spicy buffalo sauce, chicken, and a ranch drizzle. Usually $17.49 for a large.
- Supreme: Pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, and mushrooms. Usually $18.49 for a large.
Check if the chicken is pre-cooked or raw. If it is pre-cooked, it will be drier. If it is raw, it will cook in the oven and stay juicier. This affects the quality of your meal.
Veggie And White Pizzas
Do not assume the veggie pizzas are cheaper. They often cost the same as the meat ones because the vegetables require prep work. However, they are lighter and you can eat more slices without feeling heavy.
- Garden Veggie: Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, and olives. Usually $16.99 for a large.
- White Pizza: Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, and olive oil. No red sauce. Usually $15.99 for a large.
- Spinach Alfredo: Creamy alfredo sauce, spinach, and garlic. Usually $16.49 for a large.
The White Pizza is often the sleeper hit on the menu. It has fewer ingredients, but the quality of the cheese matters more. If the ricotta is creamy, this is a top-tier choice.
Build Your Own Pizza Pricing Strategy
Building your own pizza is the best way to control costs. You start with the cheese pizza price and then add toppings. The key is to know the topping price tiers.
- Start with a plain large cheese pizza.
- Add your first topping. This is usually the most expensive single addition.
- Add a second topping. This is often cheaper than the first.
- Check if there is a “3-topping special” running. Many locations offer a fixed price for any three toppings.
If you see a “special” for a 3-topping large for $14.99, that is the best value on the board. It beats almost every specialty pizza price. You get to choose what you want, and you pay less than the signature combos.
Topping Price Breakdown
Here is a general guide to what you will pay for extra toppings. These prices are per pizza, not per topping.
- Standard Veggies: Onions, peppers, mushrooms. Usually $1.50 each.
- Premium Veggies: Sun-dried tomatoes, artichokes, fresh garlic. Usually $2.00 each.
- Standard Meats: Pepperoni, sausage, ham. Usually $2.00 each.
- Premium Meats: Chicken, bacon, meatball. Usually $2.50 each.
- Cheese Add-ons: Extra mozzarella, feta, parmesan. Usually $2.00 each.
Premium meats are the biggest cost drivers. If you want a meaty pizza, stick to pepperoni and sausage. They give you the most flavor for the lowest cost. Bacon and chicken are tasty, but they will inflate your bill quickly.
Appetizers And Sides Pricing
The sides are where you can accidentally blow your budget. They seem cheap, but they add up fast. A $6.99 appetizer plus a $5.99 side can turn a $15 pizza into a $28 meal.
Wings And Boneless Options
Wings are a staple at Paisano’s. They are sold by the piece or by the dozen. The per-piece price drops significantly when you buy more.
- 6 Pieces: $7.99
- 12 Pieces: $13.99
- 24 Pieces: $24.99
- Boneless 8 Pieces: $8.99
- Boneless 16 Pieces: $15.99
The 24-piece order is the best value if you are feeding a crowd. You save about $3.00 compared to buying two 12-piece orders. Always ask for extra sauce on the side. The wings can be dry if they sit under a heat lamp.
Breadsticks, Garlic Knots, And Dips
These are high-carb, high-profit items for the restaurant. They are cheap to make, so the price is usually low. But they fill you up before the pizza arrives.
- Garlic Knots (8): $5.49
- Breadsticks (6): $5.99
- Cheesy Bread: $7.99
- Marinara Dip: $0.99
- Ranch Dip: $0.99
- Garlic Butter Dip: $1.29
If you are ordering for two people, skip the breadsticks. They will make you too full to enjoy the pizza. If you are ordering for a group, get the garlic knots. They are smaller and easier to share than the large breadsticks.
Salads And Pasta Pricing
Paisano’s is not just pizza. They offer a range of Italian-American classics. These dishes are often overlooked, but they can be a great lunch option.
Fresh Salads
The salads are large. They are meant to be a meal, not a side dish. You can usually get a side salad for around $4.99, but the full-size salads are $8.99 to $10.99.
- Garden Salad: $8.99
- Caesar Salad: $8.99
- Chicken Caesar: $10.99
- Antipasto Salad: $11.99
The Antipasto salad is the most expensive, but it contains ham, salami, and provolone. It is essentially a cold cut platter on top of lettuce. If you want protein without pizza, this is a solid pick.
Baked Pastas
These are heavy dishes. They come out of the oven bubbling hot. They are good for cold days.
- Baked Ziti: $10.99
- Lasagna: $11.99
- Chicken Parmigiana: $13.99
- Eggplant Parmigiana: $12.49
Check if the pasta comes with garlic bread. Some locations include it, others do not. If it does not, you might want to add a side of knots to round out the meal.
Desserts And Drinks Pricing
Desserts are small and overpriced compared to the pizza. However, they are good for a sweet ending. The drinks are standard fountain prices.
Sweet Treats
- Cinnamon Knots: $5.99
- Chocolate Chip Cookie: $2.99
- Cannoli (1): $3.49
- Cheesecake Slice: $4.99
The cannoli is the best dessert value. It is freshly filled and has a good crunch. The cheesecake is likely frozen and thawed, so it is not worth the premium price.
Beverages
- 2-Liter Soda: $3.49
- 20oz Bottle: $2.79
- Fountain Drink: $2.49
- Bottled Water: $1.99
If you are feeding a family, buy the 2-liter bottle. It is cheaper than buying four individual fountain drinks. You save about $6.00 by making this one switch.
Deals, Coupons, And Combo Specials
Never pay full price at Paisano’s. The menu prices are the “suggested retail” price. There is almost always a coupon or a daily special available.
Check their website or app before you order. Many locations offer a “Large 2-Topping Pizza” for a set price, usually around $11.99 for pickup. This is significantly cheaper than the regular menu price.
Lunch Specials
If you are ordering during the week, look for the lunch menu. This usually runs from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM. You can get a personal pizza or a slice with a drink for a reduced price.
- Lunch Slice + Drink: $6.99
- Personal Pizza + Drink: $8.99
- Small Salad + Drink: $7.49
These lunch deals are the cheapest way to eat at Paisano’s. You get a controlled portion and a drink. It is much better than buying a full large pizza and eating too much.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the cheapest item on the Paisano’s menu?
The cheapest item is usually the garlic knots or a side of marinara. The single slices of cheese pizza are also very affordable if you are eating alone.
Q: Is it cheaper to buy a large or two mediums?
It is almost always cheaper to buy one large pizza. Two medium 12-inch pizzas give you less total food than one 16-inch large, and they usually cost more combined.
Q: Does Paisano’s charge extra for extra sauce?
Yes, if you ask for extra sauce on the side, there is often a small charge of about $0.75. However, if you ask for “light sauce” or “well done,” there is usually no charge.
Q: Are the delivery prices higher than pickup prices?
Yes. Delivery prices are often 10-15% higher than the in-store menu prices. You also have to factor in a delivery fee and tip. Pickup is always the cheapest option.
Q: Do they offer a gluten-free crust?
Most locations do offer a gluten-free crust. It is usually a small size only and carries a premium of about $3.00 to $4.00 over the regular crust price.
Final Ordering Strategy
To get the best value, you should always order a large pizza. The size difference is the biggest price jump, but it is also the biggest value jump. Stick to pepperoni and sausage if you want meat. These are the lowest cost toppings.
Look for the daily specials before you add anything to your cart. If you are feeding a family of four, one large pizza with a side salad is usually enough. You do not need breadsticks and wings unless you are very hungry.
Paisano’s is a solid choice for casual Italian food. The key is to avoid the premium specialty pizzas and the expensive add-ons. Build your own pizza, use a coupon, and choose pickup over delivery. This way, you get a great meal without overspending.