Comparing the pub grub at P.J. Whelihan’s between locations can be tricky, but their core menu pricing stays consistent for wings, burgers, and sandwiches. If you are looking for a full breakdown of the P.J. Whelihan’s Menu with Prices, you have come to the right spot. We have analyzed the standard pricing structure so you know exactly what to expect before you walk in the door.
This guide covers the most popular items, from their famous wings to their hearty burgers and salads. We will also touch on how prices might shift slightly based on your specific franchise location. Let’s get straight to the food and the costs.
P.J. Whelihan’s Menu With Prices
P.J. Whelihan’s is a staple in Pennsylvania and New Jersey for casual dining. They are best known for their award-winning wings and their extensive beer list. However, the menu goes far beyond just chicken and brew. You will find a variety of starters, soups, salads, and handhelds that fit almost any appetite.
Below, we have organized the menu into logical sections. This makes it easier for you to plan your order. Remember, these prices are based on the standard menu and can change without notice. Always check with your local store for the most accurate daily pricing.
Appetizers And Starters
You cannot go wrong with a shared appetizer to kick off your meal. The portions here are generous, so you might even consider making a meal out of a couple of starters. Here are the standard prices for their most popular picks.
- **Whelihan’s Wings (Single Order):** $12.99 (10 pieces)
- **Whelihan’s Wings (Double Order):** $23.99 (20 pieces)
- **Boneless Wings:** $11.99
- **Mozzarella Sticks:** $9.49
- **Loaded Nachos:** $10.99
- **Soft Pretzel Sticks:** $7.99
- **Chicken Quesadilla:** $11.49
- **Fried Pickles:** $8.49
Most appetizers come with your choice of dipping sauce. The ranch and blue cheese are house-made and very popular. If you are unsure what to get, the pretzel sticks are a massive portion that is great for the table.
Wings And Sauces
This is the main event for most visitors. P.J. Whelihan’s has won numerous “Best Wings” awards over the years. The secret is in the grilling process and the variety of sauces. You can get them hot, mild, or tossed in one of their signature flavors.
Wings are sold by the piece or in specific orders. The pricing above reflects the standard order sizes. Here is a look at the sauce options that are included in that price.
- **Classic Buffalo:** Mild, Medium, Hot, or Suicide
- **BBQ:** Sweet or Smoky
- **Garlic Parmesan:** A fan favorite
- **Honey Sriracha:** Sweet with a kick
- **Teriyaki:** Sweet and savory
- **Lemon Pepper:** Dry rub style
- **Old Bay:** A regional classic
You can mix and match sauces if you order a double order. Just let your server know how many of each you want. The “Suicide” sauce is extremely hot, so proceed with caution if you are sensitive to spice.
Burgers And Sandwiches
If you are not in the mood for wings, the burger selection is solid. They use fresh, never frozen, beef patties. The sandwiches are also stacked high with quality ingredients. Here are the standard prices for their core offerings.
- **Classic Cheeseburger:** $11.99
- **Bacon Cheeseburger:** $13.49
- **Mushroom Swiss Burger:** $12.99
- **Chicken Philly:** $11.99
- **Cheesesteak:** $12.99
- **Grilled Chicken Sandwich:** $10.99
- **Crispy Chicken Sandwich:** $10.49
- **Turkey Club:** $11.49
All burgers come with lettuce, tomato, and onion on a toasted brioche bun. You can add a fried egg or avocado for a small upcharge. Sandwiches are served with your choice of fries, coleslaw, or a side salad.
Entree Salads
For a lighter option, the salads are large enough to be a full meal. They are not just an afterthought here. The ingredients are fresh, and the dressings are made in-house.
- **Cobb Salad:** $12.49
- **Buffalo Chicken Salad:** $12.99
- **Caesar Salad (with Chicken):** $11.99
- **Garden Salad:** $8.99
- **Crispy Chicken Salad:** $12.49
You can add a side of grilled chicken to any salad for about $4.00. The Buffalo Chicken Salad is a great way to get that wing flavor without the mess. It comes with crispy chicken tossed in your choice of sauce.
Specialty Dishes And Entrees
Beyond the pub fare, there are some larger plates for a heartier dinner. These items are more like traditional entrees. They are perfect if you want something different than a burger or wings.
- **Fish and Chips:** $14.99
- **Shepherd’s Pie:** $13.99
- **Grilled Salmon:** $16.99
- **Chicken Fajitas:** $13.49
- **Pasta Alfredo with Chicken:** $13.99
These dishes are served with appropriate sides. The Shepherd’s Pie is a great comfort food option on a cold day. The salmon is usually grilled to order and comes with a lemon butter sauce.
Sides And Extras
If you are looking to add a little extra to your meal, there are several side options. These are also great for sharing if you have a larger group.
- **French Fries:** $3.99
- **Sweet Potato Fries:** $4.49
- **Onion Rings:** $5.49
- **Side Coleslaw:** $2.49
- **Side Mac and Cheese:** $3.99
- **Cup of Soup:** $3.49
You can substitute any side for a small upcharge. Swapping regular fries for sweet potato fries usually costs about a dollar more. The onion rings are battered and fried to order, making them a crispy treat.
Desserts
Save room for something sweet. The dessert menu is simple but satisfying. They often have seasonal specials, but these are the staples you can count on.
- **Chocolate Lava Cake:** $6.99
- **Cheesecake:** $6.49
- **Brownie Sundae:** $6.99
The Brownie Sundae is huge and perfect for sharing. The Lava Cake is served warm with a molten center. These are great ways to end your meal.
Kids Menu
If you are dining with children, they have a dedicated menu with smaller portions and lower prices. This keeps the little ones happy without breaking the bank.
- **Chicken Tenders:** $6.99
- **Grilled Cheese:** $5.99
- **Mini Cheeseburger:** $6.99
- **Buttered Noodles:** $4.99
- **Kids Wings (5 pieces):** $6.49
Kids meals come with a small side and a drink. The portions are appropriate for children under 12. This is a good value compared to ordering off the regular menu.
Drinks And Beverages
P.J. Whelihan’s is famous for its beer selection. They have a rotating tap list that features local craft brews. You will also find the standard domestic options and a full bar.
- **Draft Beers:** $4.00 – $8.00 depending on brand and size
- **Bottled Beer:** $4.50 – $6.00
- **House Wine:** $6.00 per glass
- **Cocktails:** $7.00 – $10.00
- **Soft Drinks:** $2.99 (free refills)
Happy Hour is a great time to visit if you are on a budget. They often have discounts on appetizers and drinks during specific hours. Check with your local spot for the exact times.
Location Variations And Pricing
It is important to note that while the core menu prices are consistent, there can be slight variations. This is often due to local cost of living or regional supply chain costs. A location in a major city might be slightly higher than one in a rural area.
Additionally, some locations offer daily specials that are not on the standard menu. You might find a specific burger of the month or a discounted wing night. These specials are great for saving money.
To get the most accurate pricing, you should look up the specific menu for your nearest location. Many franchises have their own Facebook pages where they post daily specials and updated prices.
Tips For Ordering On A Budget
Eating out can get expensive, but there are ways to save at P.J. Whelihan’s. Here are a few practical tips to keep your bill down.
- **Go for the Lunch Special:** Many locations have a reduced menu during weekday lunch hours.
- **Share an Appetizer:** The portions are large, so splitting a nacho or pretzel order is easy.
- **Look for Wing Nights:** Several locations have discounted wing prices on certain weekdays.
- **Skip the Soda:** Opt for water to save a few dollars on your bill.
- **Check for Coupons:** Look at local coupon books or their email list for deals.
By following these tips, you can enjoy a great meal without overspending. The food is filling, so you likely will not need an appetizer and an entree for yourself.
Nutritional Information And Allergens
If you have dietary restrictions, you can ask your server for a nutritional guide. They have information available for common allergens. The kitchen can also make modifications to accommodate gluten-free or vegetarian diets, though options are limited.
For vegetarians, the Garden Salad or the Veggie Wrap are good choices. You can also ask for a burger patty made of vegetables, though this is not always available. It is best to call ahead if you have severe allergies.
Online Ordering And Delivery
You can order online through their website or third-party apps like DoorDash and Uber Eats. Keep in mind that delivery apps often have higher prices than the in-store menu. This is to cover the service fees.
If you are picking up, you can call in your order directly to avoid the app surcharges. This is often the cheapest way to get your food to go. The online ordering system is easy to use and lets you customize your items.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people have about the menu and pricing at this restaurant chain.
Are the prices the same at every P.J. Whelihan’s location?
Mostly, yes. The core menu items have standard pricing. However, franchise owners can adjust prices slightly based on their operating costs. You might see a 50-cent to one-dollar difference on some items.
What is the most popular item on the menu?
The wings are by far the most famous item. They have won numerous awards and are the reason most people visit. The Garlic Parmesan and the Hot Buffalo are the top two sauce choices.
Does P.J. Whelihan’s offer any gluten-free options?
Yes, they have a gluten-free menu. You can get burgers without a bun or choose salads. However, cross-contamination is possible in the fryer, so inform your server of your allergy.
Is there a happy hour menu with discounted prices?
Yes, most locations have a happy hour. This usually runs on weekdays from 4 PM to 6 PM. You can find discounts on select appetizers and drinks during this time.
Can I order just the sauce on the side for my wings?
Absolutely. You can request your wings “sauce on the side.” This is a great option if you prefer to dip them or if you are taking them home and want to reheat them later.
Final Thoughts On Pricing
P.J. Whelihan’s offers solid value for the quality of food you receive. The portions are generous, and the ingredients taste fresh. While it is not the cheapest pub food around, you are paying for quality and consistency.
We hope this guide to the menu prices helps you plan your next visit. Remember to check with your local store for the exact daily specials and any potential price changes. The core menu is reliable, so you can expect a great meal every time you go.
Whether you are stopping in for a quick lunch or a big dinner with friends, you now have a clear picture of what things cost. Enjoy your wings and your time at the pub.