Planning a visit to PJ Whelihan for wings and beer requires knowing how the pricing works for their famous sauces by the pound versus the dozen. You also need a clear look at the PJ Whelihan Menu with Prices before you walk in, so you are not guessing at the register. This guide breaks down the real costs, the best deals, and the items worth your cash.
PJ Whelihan’s is a local legend in New Jersey and Pennsylvania, known for its buffalo wings and cold beer. But the menu is bigger than just wings, and the prices can vary slightly by location. We pulled together the standard pricing structure so you can plan your order without any surprises.
PJ Whelihan Menu With Prices
Below is a detailed breakdown of the current standard menu pricing. Remember that franchise locations might adjust prices by a dollar or two depending on their operating costs. Always check your local store for the final number, but this gives you a solid baseline.
Appetizers And Starters
You will not leave hungry if you start with the apps. They are generous portions, often enough for two people to share before the main event.
- Buffalo Chicken Dip – $11.99
- Mozzarella Sticks (8 pieces) – $9.49
- Loaded Potato Skins – $10.99
- Soft Pretzel Sticks with Beer Cheese – $8.99
- Nachos Grande – $12.49
- Chicken Quesadilla – $11.29
- Fried Pickles – $8.79
The wings are the star, but the pretzel sticks are a sleeper hit. The beer cheese is thick and has a sharp cheddar bite. If you are sharing, get the nachos, they pile on the toppings.
Wings And Sauces Pricing
This is the section you care about. PJ Whelihan’s sells wings by the pound or by the dozen. The pricing structure is designed to reward larger orders, so do the math before you order.
- Single Pound (approx. 6-7 wings) – $12.99
- Two Pounds (approx. 13-14 wings) – $23.99
- Three Pounds (approx. 20-21 wings) – $33.99
- Five Pounds (approx. 34-35 wings) – $52.99
- Single Dozen (12 wings) – $15.99
- Double Dozen (24 wings) – $28.99
You will notice that buying by the pound is actually cheaper per wing than buying by the dozen. A pound gives you roughly 6-7 wings for $12.99, while a dozen gives you 12 for $15.99. If you are feeding a crowd, go with the five-pound bucket.
Signature Sauce List
The sauce selection is where PJs shines. They do not charge extra for the classic sauces, but they do charge a small upcharge for the premium dry rubs.
- Mild, Medium, Hot, and Suicide – No extra charge
- Garlic Parmesan – No extra charge
- BBQ and Honey BBQ – No extra charge
- Lemon Pepper (Dry Rub) – +$1.50 per pound
- Old Bay (Dry Rub) – +$1.50 per pound
- Cajun (Dry Rub) – +$1.50 per pound
Do not sleep on the Suicide sauce if you like heat. It is not just cayenne; it has a vinegar bite that cuts through the grease. The Garlic Parmesan is more of a wet garlic butter with shredded parm, it is messy but worth it.
Burgers And Sandwiches
If you are not in the mood for wings, the burger game is strong. They use fresh, never frozen beef, and the buns are toasted in butter.
- Classic Cheeseburger – $11.99
- Bacon Cheeseburger – $13.49
- Mushroom Swiss Burger – $12.99
- BBQ Bacon Burger – $13.99
- Chicken Philly – $11.79
- Buffalo Chicken Sandwich – $11.99
- Reuben Sandwich – $12.49
- Fish Sandwich (Fried or Grilled) – $11.29
All burgers come with lettuce, tomato, and onion on the side. You can add a fried egg to any burger for $1.50. The Chicken Philly is a solid choice, it has real chopped chicken, not the processed stuff.
Entrees And Dinners
For a sit-down dinner, the entree section offers heartier plates. These come with a side of fries, coleslaw, or a salad.
- Fish and Chips – $14.99
- Chicken Parmigiana – $15.49
- Steak and Cheese (12 inch) – $13.99
- Grilled Salmon – $17.99
- Baby Back Ribs (Half Rack) – $14.99
- Baby Back Ribs (Full Rack) – $19.99
The full rack of ribs is a monster. It takes up the whole plate and comes with extra BBQ sauce on the side. The salmon is grilled well, not dry, and has a lemon butter drizzle.
Salads And Wraps
Looking for something lighter? The salads are not an afterthought. They are large enough to be a full meal.
- Crispy Chicken Salad – $11.99
- Grilled Chicken Caesar – $11.49
- Buffalo Chicken Salad – $12.29
- Garden Salad – $8.99
- Chicken Wrap – $10.99
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap – $11.49
Ask for the ranch dressing on the side. The house ranch is thick and herbaceous, it is one of the best things on the menu. The Buffalo Chicken Salad uses whole chunks of fried chicken tossed in sauce, not shredded bits.
Sides And Extras
You can mix and match sides to build your perfect plate. These prices are for individual side orders.
- French Fries – $4.29
- Sweet Potato Fries – $5.29
- Onion Rings – $5.99
- Coleslaw – $3.49
- Mac and Cheese – $4.99
- Side Salad – $4.79
- Cup of Soup (varies daily) – $4.29
The sweet potato fries come with a honey dipping sauce that is addictive. The mac and cheese is baked with a breadcrumb topping, not the creamy stovetop kind.
Desserts
If you have room, the desserts are simple but satisfying.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae – $6.99
- Cheesecake (seasonal) – $6.49
- Brownie Sundae – $6.99
The cookie sundae is served warm with vanilla ice cream on top. It is huge, share it with the table.
Drinks And Beer List
PJ Whelihan’s is a bar first, so the drink menu is extensive. Prices vary by brand, but here are the standard ranges.
- Domestic Drafts (Pint) – $5.50 – $6.50
- Import Drafts (Pint) – $6.50 – $7.50
- Craft Drafts (Pint) – $7.00 – $9.00
- Bottled Beer – $4.50 – $6.00
- House Wine (Glass) – $7.00
- Well Liquor (Shot) – $5.50
- Soft Drinks (Refillable) – $2.99
Happy hour is Monday through Friday from 4 PM to 7 PM. During that time, domestic drafts are often $2 off and appetizers are half price. That is the best time to go if you are on a budget.
Kids Menu
Bringing the family? The kids menu is affordable and includes a drink.
- Chicken Tenders (3 pieces) – $6.99
- Mini Cheeseburger – $6.99
- Pasta with Butter or Marinara – $5.99
- Grilled Cheese – $5.49
Kids meals come with fries or applesauce and a small drink. The tenders are real chicken breast, not processed nuggets.
Lunch Specials And Deals
Weekday lunches are where you save the most money. They offer a smaller portion at a lower price, but the quality stays the same.
- Lunch Wings (8 pieces) – $9.99
- Lunch Burger – $9.49
- Lunch Wrap – $8.99
- Soup and Half Sandwich – $8.49
These specials run from 11 AM to 3 PM, Monday through Friday. You get the same sauces and toppings, just a smaller portion. The lunch wings are the smart play if you want the flavor without the full pound price.
How To Order For Takeout Or Delivery
Ordering online is straightforward, but there are a few tips to keep your food hot and your wallet happy.
- Go to the official PJ Whelihan’s website and select your local store.
- Check the “Specials” tab for any location-specific deals.
- Order wings “sauce on the side” if you are driving more than 15 minutes.
- Add extra ranch or blue cheese, they charge $0.75 per container.
- Pick up your order at the bar to skip the wait at the host stand.
Delivery through third-party apps like DoorDash or UberEats will have inflated prices. The restaurant’s own website usually offers the best price and sometimes has a “10% off online order” code.
Tips For Getting The Best Value
You can save a significant amount of money if you know how the system works. Here are the insider tricks.
- Always order by the pound, not the dozen, for the best price per wing.
- Go during happy hour for half-priced apps.
- Join the PJs email list, they send out a $5 off coupon for your birthday.
- Ask for your sauces on the side if you are taking food home. It keeps the wings crispy.
- Split a full rack of ribs with a friend, the portion is massive.
The five-pound wing bucket is the best deal on the menu if you are feeding three or more people. It comes out to roughly $1.50 per wing, which is hard to beat for restaurant quality.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are the common questions people ask about the pricing and menu at PJ Whelihan’s.
Are PJ Whelihan’s wings cheaper by the dozen or by the pound?
By the pound is cheaper. A pound is around $12.99 and gives you 6-7 wings. A dozen is $15.99. If you order two pounds, you get more food for less money than a double dozen.
Do they charge extra for flavored sauces on the wings?
No, the standard wet sauces like Medium, Hot, BBQ, and Garlic Parmesan are included in the wing price. Only the specialty dry rubs like Lemon Pepper and Old Bay have a $1.50 upcharge per pound.
Is there a difference in price between dine-in and takeout?
Generally, no. The menu prices are the same for dine-in and takeout. However, if you use a third-party delivery app, the prices will be marked up by about 15-20% to cover the app fees.
What is the cheapest item on the menu?
The kids grilled cheese at $5.49 is the lowest price, but for adults, the cup of soup at $4.29 is the cheapest side. During lunch, the soup and half sandwich at $8.49 is the best budget meal.
Do they have any gluten-free options?
Yes, they offer gluten-free buns for burgers for an extra $1.00. The wings are gluten-free if you order them naked (no breading) with a gluten-free sauce like the Medium or Hot. Always tell your server about the allergy so they can change gloves.
Final Thoughts On Pricing
PJ Whelihan’s is not the cheapest bar food in town, but the quality justifies the cost. The wings are always fresh, never frozen, and the sauces are made in-house. You are paying for consistency and flavor.
Bring cash if you want to avoid the ATM fee at the bar, and always double check your receipt for the correct happy hour pricing. The staff is usually good about applying discounts, but it never hurts to ask.
Now you know the menu and the prices. Go in with a plan, order the five-pound bucket if you are with friends, and do not forget the extra blue cheese. Your wallet and your stomach will both be happy you did the research.