Before you order that large pepperoni, here’s what a quick scan of the price list actually tells you about the portion sizes. Checking the Milano’s Pizza Menu with Prices first is the smartest way to avoid sticker shock at the register. You will find that a “large” here is not the same as a large from the chain down the street, so knowing the exact dollar amount per inch matters.
Most people walk in, look up at the board, and guess. That is a mistake. The menu is laid out in a specific way, and if you do not read the fine print, you might pay for toppings you thought were included. Let’s break down the real costs, the hidden deals, and the items worth your cash.
Milano’s Pizza Menu With Prices
This guide covers the current standard pricing for dine-in and takeout. Keep in mind that delivery apps add a 15-20% markup on every single item. If you are on a budget, call the store directly and pick it up yourself.
Classic Cheese And Specialty Pizzas
The base price for a plain cheese pizza is your starting point. Everything else is an addition. Here is the exact breakdown for hand-tossed crust.
- Small 10″ Cheese – $9.99 (Feeds 1-2 people)
- Medium 12″ Cheese – $12.99 (Feeds 2-3 people)
- Large 14″ Cheese – $15.49 (Feeds 3-4 people)
- X-Large 16″ Cheese – $18.99 (Feeds 4-5 people)
Specialty pizzas like the Meat Lovers or Veggie Supreme start at a higher base. You are paying for the convenience of pre-selected toppings.
- Small Specialty – $12.49
- Medium Specialty – $15.99
- Large Specialty – $18.99
- X-Large Specialty – $22.49
Do not assume the X-Large is the best value. Calculate the price per square inch. The Large 14″ is often the sweet spot because the crust thickness changes on the bigger pan, meaning you get more dough and less sauce ratio.
Build Your Own Pizza Pricing Structure
If you want to customize, the price is calculated by base size plus per-topping cost. The menu lists this clearly, but many people miss the “premium topping” section.
- Choose your crust: Hand-tossed, Thin, or Pan (Pan adds $2.00)
- Choose your sauce: Marinara, BBQ, Alfredo, or Pesto (Pesto adds $1.50)
- Choose your cheese: Regular, Extra ($2.00), or Vegan ($3.50)
- Add standard toppings: Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, olives – $1.25 each
- Add premium toppings: Grilled chicken, bacon, shrimp, or prosciutto – $2.75 each
Here is the trick. A large cheese is $15.49. If you add three standard toppings, the price jumps to $19.24. However, if you order the “Large Specialty” at $18.99, it comes with three toppings already included. You save money by picking a specialty and swapping out one ingredient you do not like, rather than building from scratch.
Thin Crust Vs Deep Dish Pricing
The thin crust option is not cheaper. It is the same price as hand-tossed. The deep dish or Sicilian style is sold by the slice or as a whole tray.
- Sicilian Slice – $4.25
- Sicilian Whole Tray (16″ x 16″) – $24.99
- Gluten-Free Crust (12″ only) – +$4.00 upcharge
Do not order a gluten-free large. They do not make it. The kitchen only has one size for that crust, and the cashier will not always tell you until after you pay.
Appetizers And Sides With Exact Costs
Appetizers are where the restaurant makes their real profit. The food cost is low, but the menu prices look reasonable. You can feed a table of four with two appetizers and skip the extra pizza.
- Garlic Knots (8 pieces) – $6.49
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces) – $7.99
- Chicken Wings (10 pieces) – $11.99 (Bone-in or boneless)
- Garlic Bread with Cheese – $5.99
- French Fries – $3.99
- Onion Rings – $5.49
Wings are priced per order, not per pound. If you ask for “extra crispy,” they do not charge more, but they do cook them longer. The sauce flavors are free, but a side of extra blue cheese costs $0.75.
Salads And Soup Options
Salads are a decent option if you want something green, but the portion sizes are smaller than you expect. The dinner salad is barely enough for one person.
- House Salad (Side) – $4.99
- Caesar Salad (Side) – $5.49
- Chicken Caesar (Entree) – $10.99
- Antipasto Salad – $11.49
- Soup of the Day (Cup) – $3.49
- Soup of the Day (Bowl) – $4.99
Ask for the dressing on the side. They are heavy-handed with the pour, and it makes the lettuce soggy by the time you get home. Also, the croutons are not free. If you want extra, that is a $0.50 add-on.
Pasta Dishes And Baked Entrees
Pasta is served with garlic bread, but not the cheese version. You get two plain slices of bread. The menu does not state this clearly.
- Spaghetti with Marinara – $8.99
- Spaghetti with Meatballs – $11.99
- Fettuccine Alfredo – $10.49
- Chicken Parmesan (with spaghetti) – $13.99
- Eggplant Parmesan – $11.99
- Baked Ziti – $10.99
- Lasagna – $12.49
You can add chicken to any pasta for $3.00. Shrimp adds $4.50. The portions are large enough for two meals, so factor that into the price. A $13.99 entree that feeds you twice is actually cheaper than a fast-food combo meal.
Calzones And Stromboli
These are folded pizzas, and they are massive. A small calzone is bigger than a medium pizza.
- Small Calzone – $8.99
- Large Calzone – $12.99
- Small Stromboli – $9.49
- Large Stromboli – $13.99
The difference between a calzone and a stromboli is the sauce. Calzones have ricotta inside. Strombolis do not. If you want marinara for dipping, that is an extra $0.75 per container. They do not include it automatically.
Sandwiches, Subs, And Burgers
The hot sub section is popular for lunch. Prices are lower than dinner items, but the quality is consistent.
- Meatball Sub – $8.99
- Chicken Parm Sub – $9.49
- Italian Sub (Cold) – $8.49
- Turkey Club – $8.99
- Philly Cheesesteak – $10.99
- Hamburger – $6.99
- Cheeseburger – $7.49
All subs come with lettuce, tomato, and onion. You can add banana peppers or jalapenos for free. Extra meat on any sub is $2.50. Do not ask for a “double meat” combo because they will charge you twice for the premium.
Kid’s Menu Portions And Prices
Kids meals are only for children under 10. The cashier might ask for an age if you order it. They are strict about this at some locations.
- Kid’s Cheese Pizza (personal size) – $5.99
- Kid’s Spaghetti – $4.99
- Kid’s Chicken Fingers (2 pieces) – $5.49
- Kid’s Mac and Cheese – $4.49
Each kids meal includes a small drink or a tiny ice cream cup. You cannot substitute both. The personal pizza is about 6 inches, which is enough for a small child but not for a teenager.
Desserts And Beverage Prices
Desserts are pre-made and brought in from a supplier. They are not baked on site.
- Cannoli (1 piece) – $3.49
- Tiramisu – $5.99
- Chocolate Lava Cake – $4.99
- Cheesecake (plain) – $4.49
Drinks are standard pricing. A canned soda is $2.00. A 2-liter bottle is $3.49. They do not offer free refills on canned drinks, but if you dine in and order a fountain drink, refills are $0.50 each.
Coupons, Deals, And Lunch Specials
The lunch special is the best value on the entire menu. It runs Monday through Friday from 11:00 AM to 2:00 PM.
- Lunch Slice + Small Salad + Drink – $8.99
- Lunch Pasta (half portion) + Garlic Knot – $7.99
- Two Slices + Drink – $6.49
You cannot use the lunch special on weekends. Also, the coupon in the local mailer for “Large Cheese $10.99” is only valid for pickup, not delivery. If you try to use it on a delivery order, the system will reject it.
Hidden Fees And Charges
There is a $0.50 charge for splitting a dish. If two people share a pasta entree, the kitchen charges a plate fee. This is not listed on the menu board. Also, takeout orders over $50 get a free 2-liter of soda, but you have to ask for it. They do not offer it automatically.
Comparing Value: Large Pizza Vs Two Mediums
Let us do the math. A large 14″ cheese is $15.49. Two medium 12″ cheeses are $25.98. The large is a better deal if you want the same topping on everything. But if you have picky eaters, two mediums give you variety.
Here is the area calculation:
- Large 14″ area = 153.94 square inches
- Medium 12″ area = 113.10 square inches
- Two mediums = 226.20 square inches
You get 72 more square inches with two mediums, but you pay $10.49 more. If you are feeding a crowd, order one large and one small instead. That gives you 153.94 + 78.55 = 232.49 square inches for $25.48, which is cheaper than two mediums and gives you more total pizza.
Final Tips Before You Order
Check the receipt before you leave the counter. The staff is trained to upsell you on “premium toppings” without always asking. If you ordered a standard pepperoni, make sure you were not charged for the “imported” version.
Also, ask for the pizza well-done. It comes out crispier, and you get a better ratio of crust to cheese. There is no charge for this request, but it adds 3-4 minutes to the cook time.
If you are paying with a card, there is no surcharge. If you pay with cash, some locations give a 5% discount. Ask about it. The cashier will not mention it unless you bring it up.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Milano’s Pizza Offer A Student Discount?
Yes, but only at specific locations near colleges. You need a valid student ID. The discount is 10% off your total order, but it does not apply to delivery or third-party apps. You must show the ID at the counter.
Are The Prices On The Milano’s Pizza Menu With Prices The Same For Delivery?
No. Delivery prices are higher. The in-store menu is the baseline. Delivery adds a service fee of $1.99 plus a 10% markup on food items. If you order through DoorDash or Uber Eats, expect a 20-30% increase per item.
Can I Get A Refund If My Pizza Is Cold Or Wrong?
Yes, if you call within 30 minutes of receiving the order. They will offer a remake or a credit. They rarely give cash refunds. If you paid by card, the credit goes back to the card within 3-5 business days.
Is The Gluten-free Crust Worth The Extra Money?
It is a personal choice. The crust is thin and cracks easily. It does not hold up well for heavy toppings. If you want a gluten-free option, stick to a simple cheese or one topping. The texture is more like a cracker than a traditional pizza crust.
Why Is The Price Different From The Online Menu?
The online menu is often outdated. The store updates prices quarterly. The physical menu board is always the most accurate. If you see a discrepancy, the cashier will honor the online price only if you show them the screen at the time of ordering.
Now you have the full picture of the cost structure. You know what to order, what to skip, and how to get the best deal. Next time you walk in, you can order with confidence and not worry about paying too much for too little.