Michael’s Deli Menu with Prices is exactly what you need before you walk in the door. Locals know that the portions at Michael’s are massive, which means the menu prices often represent two meals instead of one. You are not just paying for a sandwich; you are paying for today’s lunch and tomorrow’s leftover dinner.
This guide breaks down the full menu, real prices, and the best ways to order. We will cover the hot sandwiches, cold cuts, classic sides, and the catering options that make this spot a neighborhood staple. No guesswork, just the facts so you can order with confidence.
Michael’s Deli Menu With Prices
Below is the most current breakdown of the standard menu items. Keep in mind that prices can shift slightly with supplier costs, but this gives you a solid ballpark figure for budgeting your meal. The menu is huge, so we have organized it into logical sections for easy scanning.
Hot Heroes And Grinders
These are the heavy hitters. The bread is baked fresh daily, and they toast the roll until it is crispy on the outside but still chewy inside. If you are hungry, this is the section to focus on.
- Meatball Parm Hero – $12.99 (Serves 2 easily)
- Chicken Parm Hero – $13.49
- Eggplant Parm Hero – $11.99
- Sausage and Peppers Hero – $12.49
- Philly Cheesesteak – $14.99 (Add mushrooms for $1.50)
- Chicken Cheesesteak – $13.99
- Italian Combo Hero (Hot) – $14.49
- Meatloaf Hero with Gravy – $12.99
The meatball parm is the crowd favorite. They use a blend of beef and pork, and the sauce is sweet, not acidic. You will get three large meatballs sliced in half to lay flat on the roll.
Cold Subs And Wraps
Cold subs are stacked high with fresh deli meat cut to order. You can choose white, wheat, rye, or a wrap for no extra charge. Ask for it “dressed” to get the oil, vinegar, salt, pepper, and oregano.
- Turkey Breast Sub – $11.49
- Roast Beef Sub – $12.99
- Ham and Swiss Sub – $10.99
- Turkey and Roast Beef Combo – $13.49
- Tuna Salad Sub – $10.49
- Chicken Salad Sub – $10.99
- BLT – $9.99
- Club Sandwich (Triple Decker) – $13.99
- Italian Cold Cut Sub – $12.49
You can upgrade any cold sub to a wrap for free. The wraps are large flour tortillas that hold up well even with extra wet ingredients like tomatoes and pickles.
Specialty Sandwiches
These are signature creations that you cannot find at chain delis. They have unique names and specific ingredient lists that have been perfected over the years.
- The Michael’s Special – $14.99 (Turkey, pastrami, coleslaw, Russian dressing on rye)
- The Brooklyn Bridge – $13.49 (Corned beef, swiss, sauerkraut, thousand island)
- The Park Slope – $12.99 (Grilled chicken, bacon, avocado, chipotle mayo)
- The Fireman – $14.49 (Spicy cajun chicken, pepper jack, jalapenos, ranch)
- The Greenpoint – $13.99 (Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, basil, balsamic)
These specialty items come with lettuce, tomato, and onion by default unless you say otherwise. The Fireman is genuinely spicy, so do not order it if you have a low tolerance for heat.
Build Your Own Sandwich
If you want to customize, you can build from scratch. This is a good option for picky eaters or those with dietary restrictions.
- Choose your bread: Roll, hero, rye, wheat, white, or wrap.
- Choose your protein: Any deli meat, tuna, chicken salad, or grilled chicken.
- Choose your cheese: American, provolone, swiss, cheddar, mozzarella, or pepper jack.
- Add veggies: Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, banana peppers, hot peppers, or avocado ($1.00 extra).
- Choose your condiments: Mayo, mustard, oil, vinegar, Russian dressing, honey mustard, or chipotle mayo.
A single meat sandwich starts at $9.49. Double meat adds about $4.00 to the total price. The build-your-own option is often cheaper than the specialty items if you keep it simple.
Salads And Wraps
Not everyone wants bread. The salad options are generous and come with grilled chicken or deli meat on top. They are not diet portions; they are meal-sized bowls.
- Garden Salad – $8.99
- Caesar Salad – $9.49 (Add grilled chicken for $3.00)
- Chef Salad – $12.99 (Ham, turkey, swiss, american, egg)
- Antipasto Salad – $13.49 (Salami, pepperoni, provolone, olives, peppers)
- Cobb Salad – $13.99 (Turkey, bacon, egg, blue cheese, avocado)
All salads come with two packets of dressing or one side of fresh dressing. Ask for the house Italian; it is made in-house and is tangier than the bottled stuff.
Sides And Extras
You can order sides individually or upgrade any combo meal. The fries are hand-cut and crispy. The coleslaw is creamy, not vinegary.
- Hand-Cut Fries – $3.99
- Sweet Potato Fries – $4.49
- Onion Rings – $5.49
- Macaroni Salad – $3.49
- Coleslaw – $2.99
- Potato Salad – $3.49
- Pickle Spear – $1.25
- Side of Gravy or Sauce – $1.00
If you order a hero, you can make it a combo for an additional $4.50. That gets you a side and a canned drink. The combo is worth it if you plan to share or eat a lot.
Breakfast Menu
Breakfast is served until 11:00 AM on weekdays and until noon on weekends. They use fresh eggs and quality meats, not the frozen patties you find elsewhere.
- Bacon, Egg, and Cheese on a Roll – $6.99
- Sausage, Egg, and Cheese on a Roll – $7.49
- Ham, Egg, and Cheese on a Roll – $7.49
- Western Omelet Sandwich – $8.99
- Breakfast Burrito – $9.49 (Eggs, home fries, cheese, choice of meat)
- Bagel with Cream Cheese – $2.99
- Avocado Toast – $8.49
The breakfast burrito is massive. It is wrapped in foil and can easily feed two people. You can add hot sauce at the counter for free.
Desserts And Drinks
Do not skip dessert. They get their pastries from a local bakery, and the cookies are soft-baked all day.
- Canoli (One Piece) – $3.49
- Chocolate Chip Cookie – $1.99
- Brownie – $2.79
- Cheesecake Slice – $5.49
- Tiramisu – $5.99
- Canned Soda – $1.79
- Bottled Water – $1.49
- Fresh Brewed Iced Tea – $2.49
They also have a small selection of Italian sodas and sparkling waters in the cooler. These are a bit more expensive, around $3.00 per bottle.
Pricing Tiers And Value Meals
Michael’s offers a few ways to save money if you are a regular or ordering for a group. The prices listed above are for single sandwiches. Here is how the value options work.
Lunch Specials
Monday through Friday, from 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM, they run a lunch special. You get a half sandwich, a cup of soup, and a small side salad for $11.99. This is the best deal on the menu if you have a smaller appetite.
The soup rotates daily. Expect chicken noodle on Monday, tomato basil on Tuesday, and minestrone on Friday. The special is not available on holidays.
Family Meal Deals
For feeding four or more people, the family deal is the way to go. You get a full tray of heroes (about 4 feet of sandwiches), a large salad, and a quart of coleslaw for $59.99. This serves about 6 to 8 people comfortably.
You can mix and match the hero types on the tray. The price does not change based on the fillings, which is great if you have picky eaters in the group.
Frequent Eater Card
Ask for a punch card at the register. Buy ten sandwiches and get the eleventh one free (up to a $13 value). The card is physical, so do not lose it. They do not track purchases digitally.
This is a simple loyalty program. No app, no points system, just a paper card and a free sandwich after ten visits.
How To Order Efficiently
Ordering at Michael’s can be overwhelming because the menu is huge. Follow these steps to make the process smooth and fast.
- Decide if you want hot or cold before you reach the counter.
- Know your bread choice ahead of time.
- Specify if you want it “dressed” or “plain”.
- Ask for the sauce or gravy on the side if you are taking it to go.
- Check if the lunch special is still available.
- Mention if you have a punch card before they ring you up.
The staff is friendly but busy during peak hours. Being ready to order when it is your turn speeds up the line for everyone. They will ask you “for here or to go” first, so have that answer ready.
Catering And Party Trays
If you have an event, Michael’s does catering. They offer party platters that are not listed on the regular menu board. You have to ask for the catering menu at the counter or call ahead.
- Cold Cut Platter (Serves 10-15) – $89.99
- Hero Party Tray (Serves 15-20) – $129.99
- Side Salad Platter (Serves 10) – $39.99
- Dessert Platter (Assorted) – $34.99
You need at least 24 hours notice for catering orders. They do not accept same-day catering orders because they need time to prepare the fresh bread and slice the meats properly.
Pickup And Delivery Options
You can call in your order for pickup to skip the line. They will give you a time and your food will be ready at the counter in a labeled bag.
Delivery is available through third-party apps, but the prices are marked up about 15% to cover the service fees. If you want the best price, always order directly for pickup.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are the common questions people ask about the menu and pricing at Michael’s Deli.
What is the most popular item on the menu?
The Meatball Parm Hero is the best seller. It is $12.99 and comes with a generous amount of sauce and cheese. Most people say it is the reason they come back.
Are the portion sizes really that big?
Yes, the portions are very large. A full hero is usually enough for two meals. If you have a smaller appetite, consider ordering a half portion, which is available for most sandwiches at about 60% of the full price.
Do they offer gluten-free bread options?
Yes, they have gluten-free rolls available for an additional $2.00. However, they do not have a dedicated gluten-free prep area, so there is a risk of cross-contamination.
Can I order a half sandwich?
Yes, you can order a half sandwich on any cold sub or hot hero. The price is roughly 60% of the full price, not exactly half. This is a good option if you want to try two different things.
Is there a discount for cash payments?
No, the price is the same whether you pay with cash or card. There is no minimum for card payments, so you can use plastic even for a small purchase like a cookie.
Final Thoughts On Visiting Michael’s
Bring cash or a card, but bring a big appetite. The prices are fair for the quality and the quantity you receive. You are unlikely to leave hungry or disappointed.
Check the specials board when you walk in because there is often a rotating sandwich that is not on the printed menu. These specials are usually priced around $12.00 and feature seasonal ingredients.
If you are new to the deli, start with the classic Italian Cold Cut Sub or the Meatball Parm. These are the benchmarks for quality. Once you have tried those, you can branch out to the specialty items with confidence.
Remember to grab a punch card before you pay. It takes two seconds and saves you money on your tenth visit. The staff will not remind you, so it is on you to ask for it.
Michael’s Deli Menu with Prices is straightforward once you understand the layout. Hot heroes, cold subs, and salads are the main categories. Sides and drinks are add-ons. The lunch special is the best value during the week.
Go during off-peak hours if you can. Between 2:00 PM and 4:00 PM, the line is short and you can take your time reading the menu board. The staff is more patient and can answer questions about the ingredients.
One last tip: the pickles are on the counter in a big jar. They are free to take with your meal. Do not be shy about grabbing an extra one. That is part of the experience.
Plan your order before you go, stick to your budget, and enjoy one of the best deli meals in the area. The combination of fresh bread, quality meat, and fair pricing is hard to beat.