A trip to McGuire’s Irish Pub involves more than just picking a dish—it involves deciding how many courses fit your budget. You need the full McGuire’s Irish Pub Menu with Prices before you even grab a seat at the bar. This guide breaks down every section so you know exactly what you will pay for that famous 15-alarm chili or a massive Tom’s 2 lb. Burger.
Located in Pensacola and Destin, this spot is known for huge portions and a quirky atmosphere. The menu is massive, and so are the plates. Let’s get straight to the numbers so you can plan your feast without any surprises.
Appetizers And Starters Pricing
You do not want to fill up on bread here, but the starters are hard to resist. Most folks share these, but the portions are big enough for a meal if you are light on cash.
- Onion Rings: $8.99 – A massive tower of hand-battered rings.
- Fried Mushrooms: $8.49 – Served with ranch or blue cheese.
- Chicken Tenders: $10.99 – Honey mustard on the side is a must.
- Irish Nachos: $11.49 – Waffle fries loaded with cheese, bacon, and jalapenos.
- Spinach Dip: $10.99 – Warm, creamy, and served with tortilla chips.
- Gator Bites: $12.99 – A local favorite, fried and spicy.
If you are really hungry, the Reuben Egg Rolls are about $9.99. They slice them in half, which makes them easy to share.
Soup And Salad Options
The salads here are not diet food. They are huge. You can get a bowl of the famous 15-alarm chili for $6.49, but be careful—it is seriously hot.
- House Salad: $7.99 – Small, but still enough for two.
- Caesar Salad: $8.49 – With homemade croutons.
- McGuire’s Salad: $10.99 – Turkey, ham, and cheese on top.
- Soup of the Day: $4.99 per cup, $6.49 per bowl.
You can add grilled chicken to any salad for about $4.00 extra. The portions are so large that splitting a salad is a smart money move.
McGuire’s Irish Pub Menu With Prices: The Main Courses
This is the section you care about. The entrees range from steaks to pasta, and the prices reflect the quality of the ingredients. Remember, the menu changes slightly by location, but these prices are accurate for the standard menu.
Steaks And Chops
All steaks come with a side and the famous McGuire’s “sizzling” presentation. They are cooked over an open flame, which gives them a smoky taste.
- New York Strip (12 oz.): $28.99
- Filet Mignon (8 oz.): $31.99
- Ribeye (14 oz.): $29.99
- Pork Chops (2): $21.99 – These are thick cut and brined.
You can add a lobster tail to any steak for $14.99. That is a common move for celebrations, but it will push your bill over $40 easily.
Seafood Specialties
The grouper here is always fresh. They bread it in-house and fry it perfectly. If you like fish, this is the order.
- Fried Grouper: $22.99 – A huge filet, lightly battered.
- Blackened Grouper: $23.99 – Spicy and served with rice.
- Shrimp Scampi: $19.99 – Over linguine with a garlic butter sauce.
- Salmon: $21.99 – Grilled with a honey-dijon glaze.
- Seafood Platter: $27.99 – Shrimp, oysters, and fish. A lot of food.
If you are on a budget, the Fish and Chips is a solid deal at $15.99. It comes with two big pieces of fish and a mountain of fries.
Pasta And Vegetarian
They do not have a ton of vegetarian options, but what they have is decent. The pasta dishes are heavy and creamy.
- Chicken Alfredo: $17.99
- Shrimp Fettuccine: $19.99
- Pasta Primavera: $15.99 – Ask for no chicken to make it veggie.
- Baked Potato Soup: $5.99 – Not a main, but often ordered as one.
Most pasta dishes come with a small house salad or soup. That is a good value, but you will probably take half of the pasta home.
Famous Burgers And Sandwiches
The burgers here are legendary. Tom’s 2 lb. Burger is a challenge. If you finish it, you get a t-shirt. The price is around $16.99, which is fair for the amount of meat.
- Tom’s 2 lb. Burger: $16.99 – Two pounds of beef, cheese, and toppings.
- Classic McGuire’s Burger: $12.99 – Half a pound of Angus beef.
- Philly Cheesesteak: $13.99 – Loaded with peppers and onions.
- Reuben Sandwich: $12.49 – Corned beef, sauerkraut, and swiss.
- Club Sandwich: $11.99 – Triple decker with turkey and bacon.
All sandwiches come with fries or chips. The burgers are cooked medium unless you specify otherwise. They are juicy, so be ready with napkins.
Irish Specialties
You cannot go to McGuire’s without trying something Irish. These are the dishes that keep people coming back.
- Corned Beef and Cabbage: $18.99 – Served with red potatoes.
- Shepherd’s Pie: $16.99 – Ground beef and lamb topped with mashed potatoes.
- Bangers and Mash: $15.99 – Irish sausages over mashed potatoes with gravy.
- Irish Stew: $14.99 – A hearty bowl of lamb and vegetables.
The Shepherd’s Pie is the most popular Irish dish here. It is filling and tastes like a home-cooked meal. You will not need to eat again the next day.
Desserts And Sweet Treats
You might be too full for dessert, but the portions are shareable. The desserts are made in-house, and the menu changes seasonally. Here are the standard ones.
- Chocolate Mousse: $7.99 – Rich and creamy.
- Cheesecake: $6.99 – With a strawberry topping.
- Key Lime Pie: $6.49 – Tart and sweet.
- Brownie Sundae: $8.99 – Warm brownie with ice cream.
If you are celebrating, they bring out a free dessert with a candle. Just tell your server. It is a nice touch that does not cost extra.
Drinks And The Infamous 32 Oz. Beer
The drinks are a big part of the experience. McGuire’s is famous for its 32 oz. beers. They are served ice cold in a frosted mug. You can get domestic drafts for around $6.99, and imports for about $7.99.
They also have a full bar with specialty cocktails. The “McGuire’s Irish Coffee” is a must-try at $8.99. It is strong, so sip it slowly.
- House Wine: $7.00 per glass.
- Well Drinks: $6.50
- Frozen Drinks: $8.99 – The Bushwacker is a local favorite.
Happy hour runs from 4 PM to 7 PM daily. During that time, appetizers are half-price, and drinks are discounted. That is the best way to eat cheap here.
Kids Menu And Seniors
If you bring the family, the kids menu has standard options. Prices are reasonable for the portion sizes.
- Chicken Tenders: $6.99
- Grilled Cheese: $5.99
- Spaghetti: $6.49
- Mini Burger: $7.99
Seniors get a 10% discount on their meal. You just need to ask for it. The kids meals come with a drink and a small dessert, which is a nice bonus.
Lunch Specials And Value Deals
If you visit between 11 AM and 3 PM on weekdays, you can get a smaller portion for a lower price. The lunch menu has burgers, sandwiches, and salads for about $2 to $3 less than the dinner prices.
- Lunch Burger: $9.99
- Lunch Fish Sandwich: $10.99
- Lunch Salad: $8.99
This is the smartest way to eat if you are on a budget. The portions are still large, but the price is much easier to swallow.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions about pricing and the menu that you might have before you go.
Does McGuire’s Irish Pub Have A Dress Code?
No, it is very casual. You will see people in shorts and t-shirts. Just do not wear swimwear inside.
Is The Menu The Same In Pensacola And Destin?
Mostly, yes. The core items are the same, but the Destin location sometimes has special seafood catches. Prices are usually identical, but they can vary by a few cents.
Are There Gluten-free Options On The Menu?
Yes, they have a gluten-free menu. You can ask your server for it. The steaks and grilled fish are safe choices.
Can You Make Reservations?
They do not take reservations for small parties. You just walk in and put your name on the list. For large groups of 10 or more, you can call ahead.
Do They Offer Takeout Or Delivery?
Yes, they do takeout. You can call your order in and pick it up at the host stand. Delivery is available through third-party apps, but the prices are slightly higher on those apps.
Tips For Keeping Your Bill Low
Eating at McGuire’s does not have to break the bank. Here are a few simple strategies that work well.
- Go during happy hour for half-priced appetizers.
- Split an entree. The portions are big enough for two.
- Order water instead of a drink. The soda prices are standard, but they add up.
- Skip the appetizer and order the lunch menu if you are there before 3 PM.
- Ask for the bread to go. They bring it out free, but you can take it home.
The total bill for two people with an appetizer, two entrees, and a drink will run you about $70 to $80. If you skip the drinks and appetizer, you can get out for under $40.
One thing to note is that the menu prices do not include tax. You will also want to tip your server. They work hard, and the service is usually excellent.
I have been to McGuire’s several times, and I always forget how big the portions are. The first time I ordered the Fish and Chips, I could not finish half of it. The second time, I shared it with a friend, and we were both stuffed.
The atmosphere is loud and fun. There is dollar bills taped to the walls and ceilings. It is a unique place that feels like a tourist trap but is actually loved by locals. The food is consistent, and the prices are fair for the quality.
If you are looking for a cheap meal, stick to the burgers or the lunch specials. If you want the full experience, go for the Corned Beef and Cabbage. It is the most authentic Irish dish they serve.
One last tip: save room for the bread pudding if they have it. It is not always on the menu, but when it is, it sells out fast. It costs about $7.99 and is worth every penny.
Before you go, check the official website for any seasonal specials or coupons. Sometimes they run promotions during football season or for local events. It is a simple way to save a few bucks on your meal.
Now you have a clear picture of the costs. You can walk in with confidence, knowing exactly what you will pay for your meal. Whether you are there for a quick lunch or a big dinner celebration, the menu has something for every budget.
Just remember to bring your appetite. The plates are heavy, and the flavors are bold. You will leave full, happy, and probably with a doggy bag in your hand.