Mama’s Pizza Menu with Prices: Comparing the cost of a single slice to a whole pie at Mama’s is the first decision you will make when you walk through the door. It is a good problem to have, but it helps to know what you are getting into before you order. This guide breaks down the full menu, what things cost, and how to get the best deal for your group.
You are probably here because you want the facts. Not just the fancy descriptions, but the real numbers. So, let’s get straight to the point and look at what Mama’s is charging these days. We will cover everything from the classic cheese to the specialty pies and the sides that go with them.
Mama’s Pizza Menu With Prices
The menu at Mama’s is pretty straight forward, which is part of its charm. They focus on pizza, but they do have a few other things like salads and wings. The prices below are based on the standard menu, but you should always check the board at the counter for daily specials or seasonal items.
Here is the core breakdown of the pizza menu. You will see that the price difference between a slice and a whole pie is not always what you expect. Sometimes, buying a whole pie is a much better value if you are planning to eat more than two slices.
- Single Cheese Slice: $3.50
- Single Pepperoni Slice: $4.00
- Whole Cheese Pie (Large 18″): $18.99
- Whole Pepperoni Pie (Large 18″): $21.49
- Whole Cheese Pie (Medium 14″): $15.49
- Whole Pepperoni Pie (Medium 14″): $17.99
If you do the math, a single slice of cheese is $3.50. A large pie has 8 slices. That means if you buy the whole pie, you are paying roughly $2.37 per slice. That is a savings of over a dollar per slice. It makes sense to buy the whole pie if you are with friends or if you want leftovers for lunch tomorrow.
Specialty Pies And Their Costs
Mama’s is not just about plain cheese. They have a few specialty pies that are very popular. These are the ones that have the toppings already on them, so you do not have to build your own. They are a bit pricier, but they save you the hassle of ordering multiple toppings.
- The Meat Lovers: Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and ham. Large is $24.99.
- The Veggie Delight: Peppers, onions, mushrooms, and black olives. Large is $22.49.
- The BBQ Chicken: Grilled chicken with BBQ sauce instead of red sauce. Large is $23.99.
- The White Pizza: Ricotta, mozzarella, and garlic with no red sauce. Large is $21.99.
These specialty pies are usually the best sellers on the weekend. If you are trying one for the first time, I would suggest the BBQ Chicken. It has a sweet and smoky flavor that is different from the regular pies. Just be aware that these are large only, so you cannot get a small version of them.
Build Your Own Toppings
If you like to customize, you can build your own pizza. You start with a cheese pie and then add toppings. The price goes up based on how many toppings you add. This is where you can really make the pizza your own, but it is also where the bill can get high if you are not careful.
- Standard Toppings: Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers, olives. $1.75 each.
- Premium Toppings: Bacon, ham, grilled chicken, extra cheese. $2.50 each.
- Specialty Toppings: Meatballs, artichokes, fresh mozzarella. $3.00 each.
Here is a quick tip. If you want three or more toppings, it is often cheaper to just buy one of the specialty pies. For example, if you add three standard toppings to a large cheese pie, you are paying $18.99 plus $5.25, which is $24.24. That is almost the same price as the Meat Lovers, which has four toppings.
Sides And Appetizers
You are not going to survive on pizza alone, right? Mama’s has a selection of sides that pair well with the main event. These are great for sharing, or for getting your veggies in if you need a break from all that cheese.
The sides are pretty simple, but they are made fresh. The wings are a favorite, especially during game days. The salad is a good option if you want something lighter to start with.
- Garlic Knots (8 pieces): $6.99. Served with a side of marinara.
- Buffalo Wings (10 pieces): $11.99. Choose your sauce: mild, hot, or BBQ.
- House Salad: $7.49. Includes lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and peppers.
- Chicken Tenders (5 pieces): $9.99. Comes with fries.
- French Fries: $4.49. A large basket is enough for two people.
The garlic knots are a must-try. They are buttery and soft, and the marinara sauce that comes with them is the same sauce they use on the pizza. It is a good way to start your meal while you wait for the main pie to come out of the oven.
Drinks And Desserts
You need something to wash it all down. Mama’s has a standard soda fountain, plus a few bottled options. They also have a small dessert case near the register, but the selection changes daily. You might find cannoli or tiramisu, but it is not guaranteed.
- Fountain Soda (Medium): $2.29. Free refills while you are in the store.
- Bottled Water: $1.99.
- Cannoli (1 piece): $3.50. Filled fresh when you order.
- Tiramisu (1 slice): $4.99. Only available on weekends.
If you are eating in the restaurant, the fountain soda is the best value because of the free refills. If you are taking out, you might want to grab a bottle instead so it does not get flat on the drive home.
Deals And Combos
Everybody likes a good deal. Mama’s has a few combos that are designed to feed a group or a family. These are not always advertised on the main menu, so you have to ask for them or look at the small board near the cash register.
The most popular deal is the “Family Special.” It is designed for four people, but honestly, it can feed more if you have light eaters. It is a good way to get a variety of food without ordering everything separately.
- Family Special: One large 2-topping pizza, 8 garlic knots, and a 2-liter of soda. $29.99.
- Lunch Combo (Mon-Fri, 11am-2pm): Two slices and a drink. $7.99.
- Wing & Pizza Combo: One medium cheese pizza and 10 wings. $24.99.
The Lunch Combo is the best deal in the house. If you are working nearby, it is hard to beat that price for a full meal. The Family Special is also great for a Friday night when you do not want to cook.
How To Order For A Group
If you are ordering for a big group, like a birthday party or a work event, you need to plan ahead. The good news is that Mama’s does catering trays. The bad news is that you need to call at least 24 hours in advance for those big orders.
Here is a step-by-step guide to ordering for a group of 10 or more people:
- Call the store directly. Do not use the third-party delivery apps for large orders, because they might mess it up.
- Ask for the catering menu. They have sheet pizzas that are larger than the regular large pies.
- Decide on your toppings. A sheet pizza is usually 24″ by 18″ and feeds about 8-10 people.
- Confirm the price. A cheese sheet pizza is around $35.00, and each topping adds about $5.00.
- Set a pickup time. They will have it ready for you, hot and boxed.
Ordering a sheet pizza is usually cheaper than ordering three or four large pies. It is also easier to serve because it comes in a single box. Just make sure you have a big enough table to put it on.
Comparing Slices To Whole Pies
Let us go back to the original question. Should you get a slice or a whole pie? It really depends on how hungry you are. If you are just stopping in for a quick snack, a slice is fine. But if you are having a meal, you might need two or three slices.
If you need three slices, that is $10.50 for cheese slices. But a whole medium pie is $15.49 and has six slices. So, if you eat three slices now, you have three slices left for later. That is a better deal, and you get a second meal out of it.
Here is a quick comparison to help you decide:
- One Slice: Good for a snack. Cost is low, but you will be hungry in an hour.
- Two Slices: A decent lunch. Cost is about $7.00, which is similar to a fast food meal.
- Whole Medium Pie: Good for two people, or one person with leftovers. Better value per slice.
- Whole Large Pie: Good for 3-4 people. Best value per slice on the regular menu.
I usually go for the whole medium pie if I am eating alone. I have dinner, and then I have breakfast the next morning. Cold pizza is a great breakfast, in my opinion. You save money and you get two meals for the price of one.
Payment And Delivery Options
Mama’s takes all the major credit cards, and they also accept cash. They have a minimum for credit card purchases, which is usually around $5.00. If you are just buying a single slice, you might want to have cash on hand to avoid the minimum.
For delivery, they use their own drivers, not the third-party apps. This is actually better because the food stays hotter and the delivery fee is lower. The delivery fee is $2.99 within a 5-mile radius. If you live further out, they might not deliver to you.
If you want to save money, pick up your order. They offer a 10% discount on pick-up orders over $20.00. That can save you a few dollars, which is always a good thing. Just call in your order and they will have it ready at the counter when you arrive.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people have about the menu and the prices. These should help you avoid any surprises when you get to the register.
Does Mama’s Pizza offer a student discount?
Yes, they do. If you show a valid student ID, you get 10% off your order. This is valid every day of the week, not just on weekdays. It applies to dine-in and pick-up orders, but not delivery.
Are there any gluten-free options on the menu?
They have a gluten-free crust, but it is only available for the medium size. It costs an extra $3.00 to swap the regular crust for the gluten-free one. Please note that they cook it in the same oven, so it is not safe for people with severe celiac disease.
What is the price for extra sauce or dipping cups?
A side of marinara sauce is $0.75. A side of ranch or blue cheese dressing is $1.00. These are small cups, so if you need a lot of sauce, you might want to order two.
Can I order a half and half pizza?
Yes, you can. You can split a large pie into two different halves. However, if you do a half and half, you have to pay for the toppings on both sides. So, if you get pepperoni on one side and sausage on the other, you pay for two toppings.
Do prices change for delivery through apps like Uber Eats?
Yes, they do. The prices on third-party apps are usually 15-20% higher than the in-store prices. This is because the apps charge the restaurant a fee. If you want the best price, call the store directly and pick it up yourself.
So, there you have it. The full breakdown of Mama’s Pizza Menu with Prices. You now know what to expect when you walk in. You know the cost of a slice versus a whole pie, and you know which combos are worth the money. The next time you are hungry for pizza, you can go in with confidence and order exactly what you want without any guesswork.
Remember, the prices listed here are accurate as of the last update, but things change. The cost of ingredients goes up, so the menu might change too. It is always a good idea to check the board at the counter or ask the cashier if there are any specials running today. They are usually pretty friendly about telling you what is new.
Now, go get yourself a slice or a whole pie. You have all the information you need to make the right call for your hunger level and your wallet. Enjoy your meal at Mama’s, and do not forget to try the garlic knots if you have not had them yet. They are a hidden gem on the menu.