Most locals have a favorite go-to order here, but checking the Main Street Pizza Menu with Prices first reveals why the lunch crowd always orders the combo platters. You don’t have to guess what fits your budget because the menu is straightforward, and the portions are generous. Before you walk in, you should know exactly what you are paying for, especially if you are feeding a family or a group of coworkers.
This guide breaks down the full menu, item by item, so you can plan your order. You will see the current prices for pizzas, sides, salads, and drinks. We also highlight the best value deals and point out a few things you might want to ask about before you order.
Main Street Pizza Menu With Prices
You will find that the menu is split into simple categories. There are no complicated names or chef specials that change daily. It is classic pizza shop fare, done well. The prices below are the standard ones you will see on the printed menu, but always check the board behind the counter for daily specials.
Here is the quick breakdown of what you can expect to spend:
- Personal 10″ Cheese Pizza: $8.99
- Medium 12″ Cheese Pizza: $12.49
- Large 14″ Cheese Pizza: $15.99
- X-Large 16″ Cheese Pizza: $18.49
- Additional Toppings: $1.50 – $2.25 each
Those prices are for the basic cheese pizza. You should know that specialty pizzas cost a bit more because they come loaded with multiple toppings. For example, the “Meat Lovers” or the “Veggie Supreme” will run you about $3 to $5 more than the base cheese price, depending on the size you choose.
Specialty Pizza Selections
If you want something beyond a plain pepperoni, the specialty section is where you should look. These are pre-designed pizzas that are popular with regulars. You can usually swap out an ingredient if you ask nicely, but the price stays the same.
Here are the most popular specialty pizzas and their prices:
- Pepperoni Passion (Large): $18.99
- BBQ Chicken (Large): $20.49
- Supreme Veggie (Large): $19.99
- Meat Lovers (Large): $21.99
- Buffalo Chicken (Large): $20.99
- White Garlic (Large): $18.49
You will notice that the specialty pizzas are usually listed for the Large size. If you want a medium or an X-large specialty, you have to ask the cashier for the price. It is usually a simple addition or subtraction of a few dollars, but it is better to confirm before you pay.
Build Your Own Pizza Options
Building your own pizza is a great way to control the cost. You start with the base cheese price and then add only what you like. This is often cheaper than buying a specialty pizza if you only want two or three toppings.
Here is how the pricing works for a Large 14″ pizza:
- Start with the Large Cheese Pizza at $15.99.
- Add your first topping for $1.75.
- Add a second topping for another $1.75.
- Add a third topping for $2.25.
So, a large pizza with three toppings will cost you around $21.74. That is slightly less than the Meat Lovers, but you get to pick exactly what goes on it. The topping list includes standard items like mushrooms, onions, sausage, bacon, and jalapenos.
You should also know that extra cheese is considered a topping. It is not included in the base price. If you want a thick, cheesy crust, you will pay the same as you would for a meat topping.
Appetizers And Side Orders
You cannot just eat pizza, right? The sides here are simple but filling. The garlic knots are a local favorite, and they come with a side of marinara sauce. You will also find classic options like mozzarella sticks and chicken wings.
Here are the prices for the most common sides:
- Garlic Knots (8 pieces): $6.99
- Mozzarella Sticks (8 pieces): $7.49
- Chicken Wings (10 pieces): $11.99
- Breadsticks (6 pieces): $5.99
- French Fries: $3.99
- Onion Rings: $4.99
The chicken wings come in a few different flavors. You can get them plain, mild, hot, or BBQ. The price is the same regardless of the sauce you choose. If you want ranch or blue cheese dressing on the side, that is an extra 50 cents per container.
One thing to watch out for is the “Combo Basket.” You can get a basket with fries and two mozzarella sticks for $8.49. It is a good deal if you are sharing, but it is not listed on the main menu board. You have to ask for it specifically.
Salad Selection
If you are looking for something lighter, the salads are decent. They are not gourmet, but they are fresh and crisp. You can get a side salad or a full dinner salad. The dinner salads are big enough to be a meal on their own.
Salad prices are as follows:
- Side House Salad: $4.99
- Dinner Greek Salad: $8.99
- Dinner Caesar Salad: $8.49
- Chicken Greek Salad: $10.99
- Antipasto Salad: $11.49
You can add grilled chicken to any side salad for an extra $3.00. The dinner salads come with pita bread on the side. If you want extra pita, it will cost you another dollar.
Be aware that the salad dressings are house-made. They are good, but they are a bit thicker than the store-bought kind. If you are counting calories, ask for the dressing on the side so you can control how much goes on.
Sandwiches And Calzones
Aside from pizza, this place serves a variety of hot and cold sandwiches. You will find classic Italian subs, chicken parmesan, and meatball sandwiches. They also make calzones, which are basically folded pizzas filled with ricotta cheese.
Here is the sandwich menu with prices:
- Meatball Parm Sub: $9.99
- Chicken Parm Sub: $10.49
- Italian Combo Sub: $10.99
- Turkey and Cheese Sub: $9.49
- Sausage and Peppers Sub: $9.99
- Philly Cheesesteak: $11.49
All subs come with lettuce, tomato, and onion unless you say otherwise. You can get them hot or cold. The hot subs are toasted in the oven, which makes the bread crispy. You should specify if you want the Italian sub with oil and vinegar, because it is not included by default.
Calzone Pricing
Calzones are a hidden gem here. They take a bit longer to make, usually about 15 to 20 minutes, so you might want to call ahead if you are in a hurry. The calzone comes with a side of marinara sauce for dipping.
Calzone prices are simple:
- Cheese Calzone: $9.99
- Pepperoni Calzone: $11.49
- Meatball Calzone: $11.99
- Spinach and Ricotta Calzone: $11.49
You can add extra ingredients to any calzone for $1.50 each. The calzones are large, so one is usually enough for two people if you also order a side salad. They are brushed with garlic butter on top, which gives them a nice golden color.
Lunch Specials And Combos
This is the section that the opening paragraph mentioned. The lunch specials are the best value on the menu. They are only available from 11:00 AM to 2:00 PM on weekdays. You will not see these prices on the regular dinner menu.
The lunch combo includes a slice of pizza, a small side salad, and a drink. Here is the breakdown:
- One Slice + Salad + Drink: $8.99
- Two Slices + Salad + Drink: $10.99
- Half Sub + Salad + Drink: $9.49
- Small Calzone + Drink: $9.99
These combos are the reason the place is packed at noon. You get a filling meal for under eleven bucks. The drink is a standard fountain soda, and you get one refill if you dine in. If you want a bottled water instead of a soda, the price stays the same.
You should also ask about the “Slice and a Side” deal. This is not on the printed menu, but you can get a slice of cheese or pepperoni and a side of fries for $7.99. It is a good option if you are not that hungry.
Beverages And Desserts
You have to wash all that food down with something. The drink selection is standard. You will find fountain sodas, bottled sodas, and a few juice options. They also have a small dessert case near the register.
Drink prices are as follows:
- Fountain Soda (Medium): $2.29
- Fountain Soda (Large): $2.79
- Bottled Water: $1.99
- Can of Soda: $1.79
- Snapple or Juice: $2.49
For dessert, you will usually find cannoli, tiramisu, and sometimes a chocolate chip cookie that is bigger than your hand. The dessert selection changes based on what they have in stock that day.
Dessert prices are simple:
- Cannoli (each): $3.50
- Tiramisu (slice): $4.99
- Giant Chocolate Chip Cookie: $2.99
The cannoli are filled to order, so the shell stays crispy. If you are getting dessert to go, they will pack the filling separately so it does not get soggy. That is a nice touch that shows they care about quality.
Delivery And Takeout Considerations
If you are ordering for delivery, you need to know about the fees. The menu prices are the same for delivery, but there is a delivery charge added to your total. That charge is usually around $2.99 to $3.99 depending on how far you live from the shop.
There is also a minimum order for delivery. You have to spend at least $15.00 before taxes and fees. If you are just ordering a personal pizza and a drink, you will not meet the minimum, so you will have to pick it up yourself.
Takeout is usually faster than delivery. You can call your order in ahead of time and it will be ready in about 15 to 20 minutes. They will put your pizza in a box and have it waiting on the counter for you.
One tip: if you are picking up, check your order before you leave the counter. They are usually accurate, but mistakes happen, especially during the dinner rush. It is easier to fix a wrong order while you are still standing there.
Payment And Tipping Policies
You should know that this place is cash-friendly, but they also take cards. There is no surcharge for using a credit card, which is nice. However, if you pay with cash, you can sometimes get a small discount on large orders. It is worth asking about if you are ordering for a party.
If you are ordering delivery, the driver will have a receipt for you to sign. You can add a tip on the receipt or give them cash. The delivery drivers do not get the delivery charge, so tipping is appreciated.
For takeout orders, there is a tip jar on the counter. You do not have to tip for takeout, but if you are a regular, dropping a dollar or two in the jar is a good way to get your order prioritized next time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people ask about the menu and pricing at this location.
Does the price change for gluten free crust?
Yes, the gluten free crust is an extra $3.00 on top of the regular pizza price. It is only available in the 12″ medium size. You cannot get a gluten free crust for the large or X-large pizzas.
Are there any coupons for the main street pizza menu?
You can find coupons in the local mailers that come out on Wednesdays. They usually offer a discount on large pizzas or a free order of garlic knots with a minimum purchase. The shop also has a loyalty card where you get a free slice after buying ten.
Can I order just a single slice of pizza?
Yes, you can order single slices at the counter. A plain cheese slice is $3.25 and a pepperoni slice is $3.75. Slices are always available during lunch, but after 4 PM they might only have certain varieties left.
Is the menu the same for delivery and dine in?
Yes, the food prices are exactly the same. The only difference is the added delivery fee and the expectation of a tip for the driver. Dine-in customers do not pay a service charge.
What is the price for extra sauce on the side?
If you want an extra cup of marinara sauce for your pizza crusts, it is 75 cents per cup. If you ask nicely, they sometimes give you one free cup when you order a large pizza, but that is not a guarantee.
Now you have the full picture of the Main Street Pizza Menu with Prices. You can walk in with confidence and order exactly what you want without any surprises at the register. Remember to check the board for daily specials and ask about the off-menu combos if you are looking to save a few bucks. The food is solid, the prices are fair, and the service is usually quick. That is why it has been a staple in the neighborhood for so long.