El Siboney’s menu highlights Cuban-inspired flavors that have defined the restaurant since its early days. If you want to plan your meal and your budget, this guide to the El Siboney Menu with Prices covers the main dishes, sides, and drinks you will find at the popular Key West location.
The restaurant keeps things simple. You get generous plates, fair prices, and a cozy setting that feels like a family kitchen. Below is a breakdown of what most guests order and what it costs.
El Siboney Menu With Prices
Prices can shift a little over time, and the two locations may differ slightly. The numbers below reflect typical menu pricing, so use them as a close guide before you go.
Starters And Small Plates
These are good for sharing or for a light lunch. Most come out fast.
- Ham Croquettes (Croquetas de Jamon) – $4.50
- Stuffed Potato Balls – $4.75
- Fried Yuca with Garlic Sauce – $5.25
- Empanadas (beef or chicken) – $5.50
- Tostones (fried green plantains) – $4.95
- Black Bean Soup (cup) – $3.95
Classic Cuban Sandwiches
The Cuban sandwich is the reason many people visit. It is pressed, warm, and filling.
- Traditional Cuban Sandwich – $9.50
- Media Noche – $9.75
- Palomilla Steak Sandwich – $11.95
- Chicken Sandwich – $9.25
Each sandwich comes with plantain chips. You can swap them for fries for about $1 more.
Main Dishes And Platters
This is where the menu shines. Portions are large, and most plates include rice, beans, and plantains.
- Roast Pork (Lechon Asado) – $15.95
- Ropa Vieja (shredded beef) – $16.50
- Picadillo (seasoned ground beef) – $14.95
- Grilled Chicken Breast – $14.75
- Palomilla Steak – $17.95
- Fried Fish Fillet – $15.50
- Shrimp in Garlic Sauce – $18.25
- Bistec Empanizado (breaded steak) – $17.25
If you are hungry, the roast pork and the ropa vieja are the two safest bets. Both have been on the menu for years.
Side Dishes
You can order sides on their own or add them to a platter.
- White Rice – $2.50
- Black Beans – $3.25
- Sweet Plantains (Maduros) – $3.50
- Fried Cassava – $4.25
- House Salad – $4.50
- French Fries – $3.75
Drinks And Desserts
Save room for coffee and flan. They finish the meal the right way.
- Cuban Coffee (Cafecito) – $2.75
- Cafe con Leche – $3.50
- Malted Milkshake – $5.50
- Soft Drinks – $2.50
- Flan – $4.95
- Rice Pudding – $4.50
- Tres Leches Cake – $5.25
How To Order Without Overspending
You do not need to buy a full platter to eat well here. A few smart choices keep the bill low.
- Split a Cuban sandwich and add a side of black beans.
- Order the roast pork plate and share it with one other person.
- Skip the soft drinks and get a cafecito instead.
- Go at lunch if you want smaller portions at lower prices.
- Ask for extra plantains instead of fries to save a bit.
What Most Regulars Order
Regulars tend to stick with a few favorites. The lechon asado, the ropa vieja, and the Cuban sandwich show up on almost every table.
The garlic sauce that comes with the yuca and the shrimp is also a big part of the appeal. If you like strong flavors, ask for it on the side.
Tips Before You Visit
- Come early or late to avoid the lunch rush.
- Bring cash as a backup, even though cards work fine.
- Check the daily specials board for lower prices.
- Expect a short wait on weekends.
- Takeout is a good option if the dining room is full.
Overall, the El Siboney menu with prices stays reasonable for the portion sizes you get. A full meal with a drink and dessert usually lands between $20 and $28 per person. That makes it one of the better values in Key West for a sit-down Cuban meal.