Carmelas Pizza keeps locals coming back for thick-crust pies and hearty subs, with menu prices that fit comfortably into a weeknight budget. If you want to plan your order before you arrive, this guide to the Carmelas Pizza Menu with Prices breaks down the pies, sides, and drinks so you know exactly what to expect.
The shop is a neighborhood spot, not a fancy chain. That means simple food, fair prices, and portions that fill you up.
What To Know Before You Order
Carmelas focuses on classic pizza parlor food. The kitchen stays busy on Friday and Saturday nights, so call ahead if you can.
A few things worth knowing:
- Prices can vary a little by location, so treat the numbers below as a close guide.
- Most pies come in small, medium, and large sizes.
- Cash and card are both accepted at most shops.
- Delivery usually adds a small fee plus a tip.
Carmelas Pizza Menu With Prices
Here is a general look at what you will pay. Your local store may run slightly higher or lower.
Classic Pizzas
- Cheese Pizza, small: $10.99
- Cheese Pizza, medium: $13.99
- Cheese Pizza, large: $16.99
- Pepperoni Pizza, medium: $15.49
- Pepperoni Pizza, large: $18.49
- Supreme Pizza, large: $21.99
- Meat Lovers Pizza, large: $22.99
- Veggie Pizza, large: $20.99
Specialty Pies
- White Pizza, medium: $15.99
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza, large: $21.49
- BBQ Chicken Pizza, large: $21.49
- Margherita Pizza, medium: $15.99
You can add extra toppings for about $1.50 to $2.50 each, depending on the size.
Subs And Sandwiches
- Italian Sub: $9.99
- Chicken Parm Sub: $10.49
- Meatball Sub: $9.99
- Turkey Sub: $9.49
- Ham And Cheese Sub: $8.99
Every sub comes on a soft roll with lettuce, tomato, and onion if you want them.
Sides And Starters
- Garlic Bread: $4.99
- Garlic Bread With Cheese: $6.49
- Mozzarella Sticks, 6 pieces: $7.99
- Chicken Wings, 8 pieces: $10.99
- French Fries: $3.99
- Onion Rings: $5.49
- Side Salad: $4.49
Drinks And Desserts
- Fountain Soda: $2.49
- Bottled Water: $1.99
- Canned Soda: $1.79
- Cannoli: $3.99
- Cheesecake Slice: $4.99
How To Save Money On Your Order
You do not need a coupon to eat well here. A few small moves keep the bill low.
- Order a large pie instead of two mediums. The price per slice is lower.
- Skip delivery and pick up your food. You avoid the fee and the tip.
- Check for a weekly special. Many shops run a two-pie deal midweek.
- Split a sub and a side with someone. It is plenty of food for two.
- Ask about the lunch slice deal if you visit before 3 p.m.
Best Times To Visit
Weeknights are calm. You can walk in, order, and sit down without a wait.
Friday and Saturday evenings get packed after 6 p.m. If you want a table, arrive early or call your order in ahead of time.
Sunday afternoons are hit or miss. Big game days bring a rush, so plan around them.
Final Thoughts On Ordering
The menu here is simple and the prices stay reasonable. A family of four can eat for around $40 if you share a large pie and a couple of sides.
Prices do change from time to time, so it never hurts to call your local Carmelas and confirm before you go. Now you can walk in knowing what you want and what it costs.