Bakery menus tell you everything about what’s baked fresh daily and what deserves a spot in your takeout box. The Brown Sugar Bakery Menu with Prices is a sweet lineup of cakes, cupcakes, pies, and pastries made from scratch. This guide breaks down the menu so you know exactly what to order.
Brown Sugar Bakery is a Chicago favorite, known best for its caramel cake and Southern-style desserts. Prices stay fair for the size and quality you get. Below you’ll find the full menu, grouped by category, with prices and a few ordering tips.
Brown Sugar Bakery Menu With Prices
Prices can change by location and season, so treat these as close estimates. Most single slices run between $5 and $8, while whole cakes start around $30.
Cakes And Whole Desserts
- Caramel Cake (slice) — $6.50
- Caramel Cake (whole, 8-inch) — $42.00
- German Chocolate Cake (slice) — $6.75
- Red Velvet Cake (slice) — $6.50
- Sweet Potato Cake (slice) — $6.75
- Strawberry Cake (slice) — $6.50
- Lemon Cake (slice) — $6.25
- Whole 7-Inch Cake (any flavor) — $32.00
Cupcakes And Small Treats
- Caramel Cupcake — $4.25
- Red Velvet Cupcake — $4.00
- Vanilla Buttercream Cupcake — $3.75
- Chocolate Fudge Cupcake — $4.00
- Sweet Potato Cupcake — $4.25
- Cupcake Half-Dozen Box — $22.00
Pies And Cobblers
- Sweet Potato Pie (slice) — $5.75
- Sweet Potato Pie (whole) — $28.00
- Peach Cobbler (single serve) — $6.00
- Apple Cobbler (single serve) — $5.75
- Pecan Pie (slice) — $6.25
Cookies, Brownies, And Bars
- Chocolate Chip Cookie — $2.75
- Oatmeal Raisin Cookie — $2.75
- Fudge Brownie — $3.50
- Lemon Bar — $3.75
- Cookie Six-Pack — $15.00
Drinks
- Sweet Tea (16 oz) — $3.00
- Lemonade (16 oz) — $3.25
- Coffee (12 oz) — $2.75
- Hot Chocolate — $3.50
- Bottled Water — $2.00
How To Order Without Overspending
A few smart moves keep your total low while still getting the good stuff.
- Buy slices first. Try two or three flavors before commiting to a whole cake.
- Split a whole cake with friends. At $42, it feeds 10 to 12 people for about $4 each.
- Watch for day-old deals. Some locations mark down slices late in the day.
- Skip drinks if you’re on a budget. Water is the cheapest add-on at $2.
- Order ahead for holidays. Sweet potato pie and caramel cake sell out fast.
What Regulars Say To Skip Or Try
The caramel cake is the signature item, and most reviews call it the best seller on the menu. Sweet potato pie comes in a close second. If you like lighter desserts, the lemon cake and lemon bars are solid picks.
A few customers say the vanilla cupcake is plain compared to the rest. The brownie also gets mixed feedback for being a bit dense. Still, both are fine if you want something simple.
Best Value Items On The Menu
- Cookie Six-Pack — $15.00 (about $2.50 per cookie)
- Cupcake Half-Dozen Box — $22.00 (about $3.65 each)
- Whole 7-Inch Cake — $32.00 (serves 6 to 8)
Tips Before You Visit
Call ahead if you need a specific flavor. Stock changes daily and popular cakes go quick on weekends. Most shops open around 9 a.m. and close by 7 p.m., but hours vary by location.
You can also order online at some stores for pickup. That saves time on busy days like Mother’s Day and Thanksgiving week. Bring a cooler bag if you’re driving far with a whole cake.
Now you have the full Brown Sugar Bakery menu with prices in one place. Pick your favorites, set a budget, and order with confidence.