Starting your morning at Big Apple Bagels means choosing between à la carte options and meal deals, each with its own price point. Knowing the full Big Apple Bagels Menu with Prices before you walk in helps you order faster and save money where it counts. Whether you are a regular or a first-timer, this guide breaks down every category so you know exactly what to expect at the counter.
Prices do shift slightly by location, but the ranges below reflect the current national averages. You will find that most items sit in the $2 to $12 bracket, making it a solid middle-ground for breakfast and lunch. Let us walk through the bagels, spreads, sandwiches, and drinks so you can plan your next order with confidence.
Bagel Varieties And Single Pricing
The core of the menu is, of course, the bagel itself. You will usually find 12 to 15 varieties available daily, baked fresh in-house. The classic plain and everything bagels are always ready, but the rotation often includes seasonal options like pumpkin or cinnamon raisin.
- Plain, Everything, Sesame, Poppy, Onion – $1.29 each
- Garlic, Salt, Cinnamon Raisin, Blueberry – $1.39 each
- Asiago, Jalapeño Cheddar, Sun-Dried Tomato – $1.59 each
- Specialty or limited-time bagels – $1.79 each
You can buy a dozen for around $13.99, which brings the per-unit cost down significantly. A half-dozen runs about $7.49. If you are feeding a family or meal-prepping for the week, the dozen is the smart play. They freeze well, so do not be afraid to stock up.
Bagel Toast And Prep Options
Toasting is always free, but you can ask for it “well done” if you like extra crunch. Slicing is also complimentary. Some locations offer a “scooped” bagel, where the inside dough is removed to save calories. That service is free too, but it does make the bagel less sturdy for heavy fillings.
Signature Cream Cheese Spreads
No bagel is complete without a schmear, and Big Apple Bagels takes this seriously. The standard plain cream cheese is the baseline, but the flavored options are where the menu gets fun. You can order a small tub for $1.49 or a large for $2.79. On a bagel, the spread is included in the sandwich price, but à la carte it costs extra.
- Plain, Lite Plain, Vegetable, Chive – $1.49 small
- Strawberry, Blueberry, Honey Walnut – $1.69 small
- Bacon Scallion, Jalapeño, Cheddar – $1.89 small
- Seasonal flavors (Pumpkin Spice in fall) – $1.99 small
If you are buying a tub to take home, the 8-ounce container is around $4.99. The 12-ounce party tub is $7.49. These prices are slightly higher than grocery store brands, but the freshness and the unique flavor combinations justify the upcharge for most customers.
Breakfast Sandwiches And Meal Deals
This is where the menu gets interesting. You can build your own breakfast sandwich or pick from the signature list. The base price for any egg-and-cheese bagel sandwich is $4.29. Adding meat like bacon, sausage, or ham costs an extra $1.50 to $2.00. A full breakfast sandwich with meat, egg, and cheese lands between $5.79 and $6.49.
Popular Breakfast Combinations
- Bacon, Egg & Cheese on Everything – $6.29
- Sausage, Egg & Cheese on Asiago – $6.49
- Turkey Sausage, Egg White & Cheese on Plain – $6.79
- Veggie Egg White Sandwich on Sun-Dried Tomato – $5.99
The meal deal is where you save real money. For around $8.99, you get a breakfast sandwich, a small coffee, and a side of hash browns or a small fruit cup. Compare that to buying each item separately, which would total roughly $10.50. That is a $1.50 savings every time you bundle.
One note: the meal deal prices vary by region. In high-cost urban areas, you might see $9.49. In suburban locations, it often drops to $8.49. Always check the board above the register for the daily special, as some stores run a Tuesday breakfast bundle for under $8.
Big Apple Bagels Menu With Prices: Lunch And Deli Sandwiches
After 11 a.m., the menu shifts toward heartier fare. The deli sandwiches are served on your choice of bagel, but you can also request a wrap or a sub roll for no extra charge. The lunch menu is divided into cold and hot sandwiches, each with its own price structure.
Cold Sandwiches
Turkey, ham, roast beef, and tuna salad are the staples. A single-meat cold sandwich costs $7.99. Double meat or a combo (like turkey and ham) runs $9.49. These come with lettuce, tomato, onion, and your choice of cheese. Premium cheeses like swiss or provolone do not add a surcharge, but imported options might.
Hot Sandwiches And Melts
Hot options include the classic Reuben, a chicken salad melt, and a pastrami special. These are priced slightly higher due to the preparation time. Expect to pay $8.99 for a standard hot sandwich and $10.49 for a double-meat version. The Reuben, which comes with sauerkraut and thousand island dressing on rye, is usually the most expensive at $10.99.
All lunch sandwiches come with a pickle spear and a small bag of chips. You can upgrade to a side salad or a cup of soup for an additional $1.99. That upgrade is worth it if you are particularly hungry, as the soup portions are generous.
Salads And Soups
For lighter fare, the salad menu offers four or five standard options. The garden salad is $6.49, and the chicken Caesar is $8.29. You can add grilled chicken to any salad for $2.00. The soups rotate daily, with a cup costing $3.29 and a bowl at $4.49. Soup and a half-sandwich combo is a popular lunch choice at $8.49.
The broccoli cheddar and the chicken noodle are the two constants on the soup rotation. Other varieties like tomato basil or loaded baked potato appear based on the day of the week. Call ahead if you have a specific soup in mind, as the schedule is not always published online.
Beverages And Coffee Program
The drink menu is straightforward, but the coffee is a point of pride. Regular brewed coffee is $2.19 for a small, $2.49 for a medium, and $2.79 for a large. Specialty drinks like lattes and mochas start at $3.99. Cold brew is slightly more expensive at $4.29 for a medium.
If you are a frequent visitor, the refill policy matters. In-store refills on regular coffee are free while you are dining in. Takeout refills are not offered at most locations. Bottled drinks, juices, and milk are priced between $1.99 and $3.49, which is standard for the industry.
Kids Menu And Sides
Families with young children will appreciate the smaller portions. A kids’ meal includes a half bagel with cream cheese, a small fruit cup, and a juice box for $5.49. The kids’ grilled cheese on a bagel is $4.99. These meals are designed for children under 10, but the staff rarely enforces that age limit strictly.
Side items include hash browns ($2.49), a single bagel bite ($1.99), and a fruit cup ($2.99). The bagel bites are essentially mini versions of the regular bagels, perfect for dipping in cream cheese. They come in a six-piece order for $4.49.
Seasonal And Limited-Time Offerings
Big Apple Bagels does not keep a static menu year-round. In the fall, you will see pumpkin bagels and pumpkin cream cheese. Summer brings a strawberry shortcake bagel and a lemonade special. These seasonal items are typically priced 10 to 15 percent higher than the standard menu. A seasonal bagel costs $1.89, and the matching cream cheese is $2.29.
The holiday season often features an eggnog bagel and a peppermint mocha coffee. These limited-time offerings sell out quickly, so if you see one you like, order it early in the day. The staff does not hold inventory for late-afternoon customers.
Online Ordering And Catering Prices
If you order through the app or the website, the prices are identical to in-store. However, there is often a small processing fee of about $0.50 per order. The benefit is that you can skip the line and pick up from a designated shelf. Catering trays are where you can save significantly per person.
- Bagel platter for 10 people – $24.99
- Deli sandwich tray for 8 people – $39.99
- Pastry assortment (12 pieces) – $18.99
- Coffee dispenser (serves 10) – $14.99
Catering orders require 24 hours notice. You can order as late as 48 hours in advance for large events, but same-day catering is rarely available. The platters come with plastic serving tongs and napkins at no extra charge.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Big Apple Bagels offer a student discount?
Yes, many corporate-owned locations offer a 10 percent discount to students with a valid ID. Franchise locations set their own policy, so it is best to ask at the register. The discount applies to in-store purchases only, not online orders.
Can I get a gluten-free bagel on the menu?
Most locations carry a gluten-free bagel option, but it is not always listed on the main menu board. You have to ask for it specifically. The price is higher at $2.49 per bagel. Availability is limited, and the gluten-free bagels are stored separately to avoid cross-contamination.
Are there any vegetarian options with enough protein?
The veggie egg white sandwich is a good start, but you can also order the hummus and vegetable wrap for $7.49. The Mediterranean salad with feta and chickpeas is another solid choice at $7.99. These options provide between 15 and 20 grams of protein per serving.
What is the cheapest way to eat at Big Apple Bagels?
The most budget-friendly approach is to order a plain bagel with a small tub of plain cream cheese. That totals around $2.78. If you want a sandwich, skip the meal deal and order just the sandwich without the drink or sides. That saves you roughly $3.00 compared to the bundle.
Do prices vary between locations in the same city?
Yes, they can. Franchise owners have some latitude in setting prices, typically within a range of 5 to 10 percent. A store in a downtown business district will often charge more than a suburban location just a few miles away. The online menu shows the base prices, but the physical store board is the final authority.
Final Tips For Ordering
Check the loyalty program if you visit more than once a month. The app rewards you with a free bagel after every ten purchases. That effectively gives you a 10 percent rebate on your spending. Also, ask about the “day-old” bagel basket, which is often available at a 50 percent discount for cash purchases only.
Timing matters for the best selection. Bagels come out of the oven in batches throughout the morning. If you arrive after 10 a.m., the popular varieties like everything and asiago might be sold out. The staff will usually offer to toast a less popular option, but the texture is not the same as a fresh one.
The menu is straightforward once you understand the pricing structure. Bagels are cheap, spreads are moderate, and sandwiches are where the margin lies. Bundle your order when you want value, and go à la carte when you only need a quick bite. With these prices in mind, you can walk in, order with confidence, and get exactly what you payed for.