Ordering at Bennys Pizza comes down to crust style, topping combos, and how much you will actually pay for a pie. This guide breaks down the Bennys Pizza Menu with Prices so you can plan your order before you call or walk in.
Bennys Pizza keeps things simple. You pick a size, choose a crust, then load on toppings. Prices shift a little by location, but the ranges below give you a solid idea of what to expect.
Bennys Pizza Menu With Prices
Most Bennys locations follow a similar price sheet. A plain cheese pie starts around $10.99 for a small and climbs to about $19.99 for an extra large. Each extra topping usualy adds $1.50 to $2.50 depending on size.
Classic Pizzas And What They Cost
- Cheese Pizza: $10.99 small, $14.99 medium, $17.99 large, $19.99 extra large
- Pepperoni Pizza: $12.49 small, $16.49 medium, $19.49 large, $21.99 extra large
- Sausage Pizza: $12.49 small, $16.49 medium, $19.49 large, $21.99 extra large
- Mushroom Pizza: $12.49 small, $16.49 medium, $19.49 large, $21.99 extra large
- Veggie Supreme: $14.99 small, $18.99 medium, $22.49 large, $24.99 extra large
- Meat Lovers: $15.99 small, $19.99 medium, $23.49 large, $25.99 extra large
Specialty Pies And Their Price Points
Specialty pies cost more becuase they come with several toppings already built in. Expect to pay between $15 and $26 depending on size.
- BBQ Chicken: $15.49 small, $19.49 medium, $22.99 large
- Buffalo Chicken: $15.49 small, $19.49 medium, $22.99 large
- Hawaiian: $14.49 small, $18.49 medium, $21.99 large
- White Pizza: $13.99 small, $17.99 medium, $20.99 large
- Philly Steak: $15.99 small, $19.99 medium, $23.49 large
Sides, Drinks, And Extras
Sides are where you can stretch your dollar. A single order of garlic knots feeds two people for under five bucks.
- Garlic Knots (6): $4.99
- Mozzarella Sticks (6): $6.99
- Chicken Wings (8): $9.99
- French Fries: $3.99
- Caesar Salad: $7.49
- Garden Salad: $6.99
- 2-Liter Soda: $2.99
- Canned Soda: $1.49
Crust Options And How They Change The Price
Crust choice matters more than most people think. Thin crust is the base price. Thick or pan crust adds $1 to $2. Stuffed crust adds $3 to $4.
- Thin Crust: no extra charge
- Hand Tossed: no extra charge
- Pan Crust: add $1.50
- Stuffed Crust: add $3.50
- Gluten Free: add $2.00
How To Order And Save
You can order online, by phone, or in person. Online orders often show the exact local price, which beats guessing. Here is a simple way to keep your total low.
- Pick up instead of delivery to skip the $3 to $5 fee.
- Order a large instead of two mediums. You get more pizza for less money.
- Watch for the Tuesday two-for-one deal at many shops.
- Ask about the family combo. It bundles a large pie, wings, and a 2-liter.
- Skip extra toppings on half the pie if only one person wants them.
Combo Deals Worth Knowing
- Family Combo: large pizza, 8 wings, 2-liter soda for $29.99
- Lunch Special: two slices and a drink for $6.99
- Date Night Deal: two medium pizzas and garlic knots for $24.99
- Party Pack: three large pizzas for $44.99
What Affects Your Final Total
Taxes and delivery fees push the total up. A $17.99 large pizza can turn into $24 after tax, tip, and delivery. Always check the checkout screen before you confirm.
Prices also vary by city. A Bennys in a big metro area charges more than a small town shop. Call your local store or check the website for the exact numbers.
Quick Tips Before You Order
- Check the store hours. Some locations close at 9 p.m. on weekdays.
- Ask if the shop charges for extra sauce or dipping cups.
- Confirm the wait time on busy nights like Friday and Saturday.
- Keep your receipt if you plan to use a reward code later.
Now you know the full Bennys Pizza menu with prices. Pick your size, choose your crust, and add the toppings you actually want. A little planning keeps the bill low and the pizza hot.