Barraco’s Pizza operates several locations with slightly different pricing structures worth comparing before ordering. If you’re searching for the Barraco’s Pizza Menu with Prices, you’ve come to the right place. This guide breaks down the costs across their most popular locations so you know exactly what to expect when you call or walk in.
Barraco’s has been a Chicago-area staple since 1976, known for their thin crust and tavern-style pies. Their menu is straightforward, but the prices can vary by a dollar or two depending on whether you visit the Blue Island, Tinley Park, or Orland Park store. Below, we’ve done the legwork so you don’t have to guess.
Barraco’s Pizza Menu With Prices
Let’s get straight to the numbers. The menu is built around three main pizza types: thin crust, stuffed, and pan. You’ll also find appetizers, sandwiches, pasta, and salads. Prices below reflect the most current data from their official locations, though you should always confirm at your local store.
Thin Crust Pizza Pricing
Thin crust is the signature here. It’s crispy, buttery, and cut into squares. You order by size, and then you pick your toppings. The base cheese pizza is the starting point for all pricing.
- Small (10-inch) Cheese: $10.75
- Medium (12-inch) Cheese: $13.25
- Large (14-inch) Cheese: $15.75
- Extra Large (16-inch) Cheese: $18.50
Toppings are extra. Each additional topping costs between $1.50 and $2.50 depending on the size. Specialty pizzas, like the “Barraco’s Special” or “BBQ Chicken,” run about $3 to $5 more than a plain cheese pie. For example, a large specialty thin crust will land around $19.95 to $21.50.
Stuffed Pizza Costs
Stuffed pizza is a heavy, deep-dish style with a top crust and lots of cheese. It takes longer to bake, so expect a 45-minute wait. The prices reflect the extra ingredients and prep time.
- Small (10-inch) Cheese Stuffed: $14.25
- Medium (12-inch) Cheese Stuffed: $17.50
- Large (14-inch) Cheese Stuffed: $21.75
Adding meat to a stuffed pizza increases the price by roughly $2.00 per topping. A large stuffed with sausage and pepperoni will run you about $25.75. That’s a filling meal for two or three people, so the cost per person is reasonable.
Pan Pizza Price Points
The pan pizza is a thicker, doughier option compared to thin crust. It’s baked in a deep pan with a crispy bottom. Prices sit between thin crust and stuffed.
- Medium (12-inch) Pan Cheese: $15.25
- Large (14-inch) Pan Cheese: $18.75
Specialty pan pizzas are limited. Most customers stick to building their own. A large pan with two toppings will likely cost you around $22.00. It’s a good middle-ground option if you want something more filling than thin crust but not as heavy as stuffed.
Appetizers And Sides
Before the pizza arrives, you might want some starters. The sides menu is simple and reasonably priced. These are great for sharing or for feeding kids while you wait.
- Garlic Bread (6 pieces): $5.25
- Garlic Bread with Cheese: $6.75
- Breaded Mushrooms (8 pieces): $6.50
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces): $7.25
- Onion Rings: $5.95
- Chicken Wings (6 pieces): $8.50
- Chicken Wings (12 pieces): $15.95
Wings come in mild, medium, hot, or BBQ. The sauces are made in-house, and they’re not shy with the heat. If you’re getting wings, order them with extra napkins. The blue cheese dressing for dipping is an extra $0.75, which feels a bit steep, but it’s thick and chunky.
Salads And Soups
Salads are fresh and come in two sizes. A small salad feeds one person, while a large can serve three or four as a side.
- House Salad (Small): $6.25
- House Salad (Large): $9.75
- Caesar Salad (Small): $6.75
- Caesar Salad (Large): $10.25
- Antipasto Salad (Small): $7.50
- Antipasto Salad (Large): $12.00
Soup of the day is available for $4.25 a cup. It’s usually minestrone or Italian wedding. The soup is decent, but most regulars skip it and go straight for the pizza. If you do order a salad, the house Italian dressing is the way to go. It’s tangy and slightly sweet.
Sandwiches And Burgers
Barraco’s isn’t just pizza. They offer a full lineup of hot sandwiches and burgers. These are grilled fresh and served on a soft roll. Most sandwiches come with a side of fries or chips.
- Italian Beef (Small): $7.95
- Italian Beef (Large): $10.50
- Meatball Sandwich: $8.25
- Sausage Sandwich: $8.25
- Chicken Parm Sandwich: $9.50
- Eggplant Parm Sandwich: $8.95
- Cheeseburger (1/3 lb): $8.75
- Double Cheeseburger: $11.50
The Italian beef is a local favorite. Ask for it “dipped” if you want the bread soaked in au jus. That’s the authentic Chicago way. Adding cheese (mozzarella or provolone) costs an extra $1.25. The fries that come with the sandwiches are crinkle-cut and salted well.
Pasta Dinners
Pasta plates are served with a side salad and garlic bread. They’re hearty portions, easily enough for two meals. The prices are competitive with other family-style Italian spots in the area.
- Spaghetti with Marinara: $9.95
- Spaghetti with Meatballs: $12.95
- Baked Ziti: $11.50
- Lasagna: $12.95
- Ravioli (Cheese or Meat): $11.75
- Fettuccine Alfredo: $10.95
You can add grilled chicken to any pasta for $3.50. The marinara sauce is smooth and has a slight herb kick. The lasagna is layered well and comes out piping hot. Just be careful, the plate is hot when it hits the table.
Pizza By The Slice
If you’re eating alone or just want a quick bite, Barraco’s sells pizza by the slice at certain locations during lunch hours. This is not available at all stores, so call ahead. The Blue Island location usually has slices ready by 11:00 AM.
- Cheese Slice: $3.25
- Pepperoni Slice: $3.75
- Sausage Slice: $3.75
- Combination Slice: $4.25
Slices are large, folded over, and reheated in the oven. They’re a great value compared to fast food. A slice and a soft drink will set you back about $6.00 total. That’s hard to beat for a filling lunch.
Desserts And Drinks
Don’t skip dessert. The cannoli is the standout item. It’s filled to order, so the shell stays crispy.
- Cannoli (1 piece): $3.95
- Tiramisu: $5.50
- Chocolate Cake: $4.75
- Cheesecake: $5.25
For drinks, they have the standard fountain sodas, bottled water, and iced tea. A 2-liter bottle of soda costs $3.99 if you want to take it home. They also have a small selection of Italian sodas, which are refreshing but a little pricey at $3.50 each.
Deals And Specials
Barraco’s runs daily specials that can save you a few bucks. These are worth knowing about if you’re on a budget. The deals are usually posted on their in-store boards and sometimes on social media.
- Monday: Large one-topping thin crust for $12.99 (dine-in only)
- Tuesday: Buy one large pasta, get one half off
- Wednesday: 10% off for seniors
- Thursday: Free delivery fee on orders over $25
Delivery fees vary by location. The standard delivery charge is $2.50 within a five-mile radius. They do not deliver outside that zone. Carryout is always free, and they usually have your order ready in 20 minutes if you call ahead.
Comparing Location Prices
Here is where things get tricky. The Tinley Park location tends to be about $0.50 cheaper per item compared to the Orland Park store. The Blue Island original is priced in the middle. This is likely due to rent and overhead costs.
For example, a large thin crust cheese pizza at Tinley Park is $15.25, while the same pizza at Orland Park is $15.75. It’s not a huge difference, but if you’re ordering for a large group, it adds up. The Blue Island location charges $15.50 for the same pie.
Appetizers and sides have similar small gaps. The wings at Tinley Park are $0.25 cheaper than Orland Park. Sandwiches are more consistent, with only a $0.10 to $0.20 variance. If you live near a border between locations, it might be worth driving the extra mile to save a couple of dollars.
How To Order Efficiently
To get the best experience and avoid mistakes, follow these simple steps when ordering. This will save you time and ensure your food is correct.
- Decide on your pizza style first (thin, stuffed, or pan).
- Check the location-specific pricing online or call the store directly.
- Ask about the daily special before you order. Don’t assume the online menu shows current deals.
- Specify your cut preference. Barraco’s cuts thin crust into squares by default, but you can ask for party cut (larger slices).
- Confirm your pickup time. Stuffed pizzas take 45 minutes, so plan ahead.
- Mention any allergies. They use shared prep areas, so cross-contamination is possible.
If you order online, use the store locator on their website to ensure you are viewing the correct menu for your chosen location. The online ordering system is user-friendly and remembers your past orders, which speeds things up.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are answers to common questions about pricing and the menu. These should clear up any remaining confusion before you place your order.
Does Barraco’s Pizza have a lunch menu with lower prices?
Yes, most locations offer a lunch special from 11:00 AM to 2:00 PM on weekdays. This usually includes a personal thin crust pizza or a small pasta with a drink for around $7.99. The exact items vary by store, so ask when you call.
Are the prices on the Barraco’s Pizza menu with prices the same for delivery?
No, delivery prices are typically 10% to 15% higher than carryout prices. This is standard practice to cover packaging and driver costs. The delivery fee is added on top of that increased menu price.
Can I get a gluten-free crust at Barraco’s?
Yes, they offer a gluten-free crust for an additional $2.50. However, it is only available in a 12-inch size. The gluten-free crust is thinner and more brittle than the regular dough, so handle it carefully.
Do they offer any coupons or loyalty programs?
Barraco’s occasionally runs coupons in local mailers. They also have a punch card system where you get a free small cheese pizza after purchasing ten large pizzas. Ask your server about the punch card on your next visit.
What is the price difference between a specialty pizza and a custom pizza?
A specialty pizza with multiple toppings is usually about $2.00 to $3.00 cheaper than building the same pizza from scratch with individual toppings. For example, a large specialty with five toppings costs around $22.00, while adding five individual toppings to a cheese pizza would cost about $25.00.
Barraco’s offers solid value for the quality and portion size. The prices are fair for the Chicago market, and the daily specials make it even more affordable. Just remember to check the specific location pricing and ask about current deals. That way, you get the best possible price on your next pizza night.
Whether you are a first-timer or a regular, this breakdown of the Barraco’s Pizza menu with prices should help you budget your meal. The food is consistent, the service is friendly, and the thin crust is worth the trip. Go ahead and place your order, but double-check those location prices first. It is a small step that keeps your bill predictable.
One last tip: if you are feeding a crowd, the extra large thin crust is the best bang for your buck. It is only a few dollars more than the large, but it gives you significantly more surface area. Pair it with a couple of sides and a pitcher of soda, and you have a complete meal for four people without breaking the bank.
So next time you are planning a casual dinner, keep this guide handy. You will know exactly what to expect when the bill arrives, and you can focus on enjoying the food. Barraco’s has been around for decades for a reason, and their menu prices reflect a commitment to keeping things reasonable while maintaining quality.