The best bagels in town often hide behind unassuming storefronts, and Bagelsmith proves it daily. If you are looking for the Bagelsmith menu with prices before you visit, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down every category, from classic spreads to specialty sandwiches, so you know exactly what to order and what it will cost.
Bagelsmith is known for its kettle-boiled, wood-fired bagels. They have a distinct crust and a chewy inside that is hard to find elsewhere. Prices are reasonable for the quality, and the portions are generous. Let us walk through the current offerings so you can plan your meal without any guesswork.
Bagelsmith Menu With Prices
Below is a detailed breakdown of the current pricing structure. Please note that prices can shift slightly based on location or seasonal ingredients. Always check the in-store board for the most accurate daily totals, but this list gives you a solid baseline for budgeting your trip.
Classic Bagels And Toasts
The foundation of the menu is the bagel itself. You can order them plain, toasted, or as part of a sandwich. Here are the standard prices for a single bagel.
- Plain Bagel (any flavor) – $1.50
- Toasted Bagel – $1.75
- Bagel with Butter – $2.25
- Bagel with Cream Cheese (plain) – $3.25
- Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese – $3.75
They offer a rotating selection of dough flavors. You will usually find everything from Everything and Sesame to less common options like Jalapeño Cheddar or Blueberry. The price stays the same regardless of the dough you choose.
Spread And Schmear Selections
If you like variety, the spread menu is where you should focus. They make most of their schmears in-house daily. The flavors change with the seasons, but these are the staples you can expect to see.
- Plain Cream Cheese – included in the base price above
- Vegetable or Chive – add $0.50
- Smoked Salmon Spread – add $1.00
- Honey Walnut or Cinnamon Raisin – add $0.50
- Vegan Tofu Cream Cheese – add $1.00
You can also buy their spreads by the tub to take home. A small 4oz container runs about $4.50, and a large 12oz container is around $9.00. These make great additions to your own breakfast at home.
Signature Breakfast Sandwiches
This is where the menu gets serious. They build sandwiches on your choice of bagel with eggs cooked to order. You can substitute egg whites or tofu eggs for a small upcharge.
- The Standard (Egg & Cheese) – $5.50
- The Standard with Meat (Bacon, Sausage, or Ham) – $6.75
- The Western (Egg, Peppers, Onions, Cheese) – $7.25
- The Veggie Delight (Egg, Spinach, Tomato, Avocado) – $8.00
- The Lox Sandwich (Smoked Salmon, Cream Cheese, Capers, Onion) – $12.50
All breakfast sandwiches come with a pickle spear on the side. That is a nice touch that adds a little crunch to your meal. If you want to add avocado to any sandwich, it will cost an extra $1.50.
Lunch And Deli Sandwiches
After 11 AM, the menu expands to include heartier deli options. These are served on your choice of bagel, but many people prefer a Hearty Multigrain or Pumpernickel for these fillings.
- Turkey & Swiss – $9.50
- Roast Beef & Provolone – $10.50
- Pastrami & Russian Dressing – $11.00
- Chicken Salad – $8.50
- Tuna Melt – $9.00
Each lunch sandwich is served with lettuce, tomato, and onion unless you ask to omit them. You can add coleslaw or potato salad for an additional $2.00. These sandwiches are stacked high, so you likely will not need a side.
Bagel Bites And Mini Meals
For lighter appetites or for kids, they offer a few smaller options. These are perfect if you want a taste without committing to a full-size meal.
- Bagel Bite (Mini bagel with cream cheese) – $2.75
- Bagel Dog (Frank wrapped in bagel dough) – $3.50
- Soup of the Day (Cup) – $4.00
- Soup of the Day (Bowl) – $5.50
- Side Salad – $4.25
The Bagel Dog is a hidden gem. It is a great snack to grab if you are walking around the city and need something portable. The soup is always hearty and changes daily, so ask the counter person what is in the pot.
Beverages And Coffee
No bagel shop is complete without a solid drink menu. They serve locally roasted coffee that pairs well with the savory flavors of the food.
- Drip Coffee (Small) – $2.25
- Drip Coffee (Large) – $3.00
- Espresso Drinks (Latte, Cappuccino) – $4.50 – $5.50
- Fresh Orange Juice – $4.00
- Assorted Bottled Sodas – $2.50
- Iced Tea – $2.75
They also offer a selection of specialty cold brew drinks in the summer months. Those prices range from $4.75 to $6.00 depending on the flavor syrups you choose. The coffee is strong but smooth, with no bitter aftertaste.
How To Order Efficiently
Bagelsmith can get very busy during the morning rush. The line moves fast, but you will make it even easier for everyone if you know what you want. Here is a simple step-by-step process to ordering like a pro.
- Decide on your bagel flavor first. Do not wait until you are at the counter to browse the bins.
- Choose your spread or filling. If you want a sandwich, tell them the base ingredients you saw on the board.
- Specify if you want it toasted. Toasting takes extra time, so say it upfront.
- Tell them if it is for here or to go. This determines the packaging.
- Pay at the register. They will call your name when the order is ready.
If you are ordering for a large group or an office, call ahead. They offer platters of bagels and spreads that serve 10 to 20 people. These platters start at $25.00 and go up based on the number of bagels and the types of spreads you select.
Seasonal Specials And Limited Offers
The menu is not static. Throughout the year, they introduce limited-time items that are worth trying. In the fall, you might see a Pumpkin Bagel with a Maple Walnut spread. In the spring, they often feature a Lemon Ricotta schmear.
These seasonal items usually cost the same as the regular menu items. The flavored cream cheese will be priced at the standard $3.75 rate. The specialty doughs do not carry a premium price, which is a nice change from other shops.
Keep an eye on their social media pages for announcements about these specials. They often sell out by midday, so arrive early if you want to snag a seasonal favorite. The staff is always happy to give you a taste sample if you are unsure about a new flavor.
Value Meals And Combos
If you are looking to save a little money, you should consider the combo deals. These are not always advertised on the main board, so you have to ask for them. However, they provide the best value for a full meal.
- Bagel, Spread, and Coffee Combo – $6.50
- Breakfast Sandwich and Coffee Combo – $8.75
- Soup and Half Sandwich Combo – $10.50
These combos save you about $1.50 compared to buying items separately. The staff will usually ask if you want to make your order a combo before you pay. If they do not, just mention it and they will ring it up correctly.
Nutritional Considerations And Substitutions
Dietary restrictions are easy to accommodate here. They clearly label which bagels are vegan and which spreads are dairy-free. The vegan tofu cream cheese is surprisingly good and has a texture very close to the real thing.
For gluten-sensitive customers, they do offer a gluten-free bagel. However, there is a surcharge of $1.00 for this option. Please note that the kitchen is not a gluten-free environment, so cross-contamination is possible. If you have a severe allergy, you should speak directly with the manager on duty.
You can also request your sandwich to be made as a salad. They will place all the fillings over a bed of fresh greens instead of the bagel. This is a great low-carb option that costs the same as the sandwich version.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people have about the pricing and menu structure. This should clear up any remaining confusion before you visit.
Do Bagelsmith prices vary by location?
Yes, there can be slight differences between franchises. The prices listed here are based on the standard urban locations. Suburban branches might have a small increase of $0.25 to $0.50 on certain items due to higher operating costs.
Is there a discount for buying a dozen bagels?
Yes, a dozen plain bagels costs $15.00. That is a savings of $3.00 compared to buying them individually. If you want a dozen with assorted flavors, the price remains the same. Cream cheese tubs are not included in this deal.
Can I order the Bagelsmith menu online for pickup?
Absolutely. You can place an order through their website or a third-party delivery app. The prices online might be slightly higher to cover the service fees. Pickup orders are usually ready within 15 minutes.
What is the most popular item on the menu?
The Lox Sandwich is the signature item that most regulars recommend. The Pastrami sandwich is also a big hit for lunch. If you are a first-timer, you cannot go wrong with the classic Everything bagel with Vegetable cream cheese.
Are there any hidden charges on the menu?
No, the prices you see on the board are the prices you pay. There is no charge for slicing or toasting. The only extra fees come from adding premium ingredients like avocado or extra meat portions.
Final Tips For Your Visit
Go early if you want the freshest bagels. The batches come out of the oven continuously until about 10 AM. After that, they slow down production, and the selection might be thinner. The texture is always good, but nothing beats a bagel that is still warm from the fire.
Do not be afraid to ask for recommendations. The counter staff eats here every day and knows exactly which combinations work best together. They might suggest a flavor pairing you would not have considered on your own.
Bring cash if you want to skip the line. There is usually a dedicated cash lane that moves much faster than the card line. However, they do accept all major credit cards and mobile payments if you prefer to use plastic.
Take a moment to look at the pastry case near the register. They often have bagel chips, rugelach, and other baked goods that are not listed on the main menu. These make great snacks for later or gifts for friends.
The Bagelsmith menu with prices is straightforward and fair. You get high-quality ingredients and a filling meal for a price that is hard to beat in the city. Whether you are a local or just passing through, this is a stop worth making. Plan your order ahead, bring your appetite, and enjoy one of the best bagels you will ever have.