Bagel Cafe charges per bagel style and spread combination, so customizing your order changes the final bill noticeably. If you are looking for a clear breakdown of the Bagel Cafe Menu with Prices, you came to the right place. We looked at the standard pricing structure, portion sizes, and the small add-ons that can sneak into your total.
Most people walk in expecting a flat rate for a sandwich. That is not how this cafe works. You pay for the base bagel, then you pay for the schmear, and then you pay for any protein or veggie toppings. It is a modular system that gives you total control, but it also means you need to do a little math before you order.
Bagel Cafe Menu With Prices
Below is the current standard price list for a classic location. Keep in mind that urban locations or franchises inside train stations might run about $0.50 higher on every item. We update this list frequently, but the cafe does change prices seasonally when flour costs shift.
Base Bagel Styles And Dough Options
The foundation of your meal is the dough. You have two main categories here: the traditional boiled bagel and the specialty stuffed bagel. The stuffed ones take longer to bake, so they cost a bit more.
- Plain, Everything, Sesame, Poppy, or Salt – $1.85 each
- Cinnamon Raisin or Blueberry – $2.10 each
- Asiago Cheese or Jalapeno Cheddar – $2.45 each
- Stuffed Bagel (cream cheese already inside) – $3.25 each
- Gluten-Free Plain or Everything – $3.75 each
You should ask for a “day-old” bagel if you are on a budget. They sell those for half price at the counter, but they are only available before 9 AM. The texture is still fine for toasting at home.
Cream Cheese And Butter Spreads
This is where the bill starts to grow. A plain bagel with nothing on it is cheap, but very few people eat it that way. The standard spread portion is about two tablespoons. If you ask for “extra schmear,” they will charge you for a second portion.
- Plain Cream Cheese – $1.25
- Vegetable or Chive Cream Cheese – $1.75
- Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese – $2.50
- Honey Walnut or Strawberry – $1.75
- Butter (salted or unsalted) – $0.75
- Vegan Tofu-Based Spread – $2.25
Pro tip: You can order a “light schmear” for free. It is less product, but they do not charge extra for it. This is a good way to save a dollar if you are watching your calories or your wallet.
Protein Add-Ons For Bagel Sandwiches
If you want a full breakfast or lunch sandwich, you will pick a protein. These are cooked to order, so expect a short wait. The prices below reflect a single serving portion.
- Bacon (2 strips) – $2.50
- Sausage Patty – $2.75
- Turkey Breast (3 slices) – $3.25
- Ham (2 slices) – $2.25
- Lox / Smoked Salmon (2 oz) – $5.50
- Fried Egg – $1.50
- Scrambled Egg – $2.00
Here is a common mistake. People order a “bagel with lox” thinking it includes cream cheese. It does not. The lox is just the fish. You have to add the cream cheese separately. That combo will run you about $8.50 before tax.
Vegetable And Extra Toppings
Fresh veggies are cheaper than proteins, but they still add up. The cafe charges per topping, not per handful. If you ask for “everything” on a sandwich, they will ring up each item individually.
- Tomato, Onion, or Lettuce – $0.60 each
- Cucumber or Sprouts – $0.75 each
- Avocado (sliced or mashed) – $1.95
- Pickles or Banana Peppers – $0.50
- Extra Cheese (slice of American or Swiss) – $1.10
I once watched a customer order a veggie bagel sandwich and the total came to over eleven dollars because they added avocado, sprouts, and double cheese. Be careful with the modifiers.
Bagel Combos And Meal Deals
The cafe does offer a few bundled options that can save you money. These are not advertised on the big menu board. You have to ask for them specifically at the register.
- Morning Combo – One plain bagel with plain cream cheese, a small coffee, and a fruit cup. Costs $7.95. Buying separately would be about $9.85.
- Lunch Box – One turkey sandwich on a bagel, a side salad, and a drink. Costs $10.50. This is a good deal if you want the turkey.
- Twofer Tuesday – Only on Tuesdays, you get two plain bagels and one tub of cream cheese for $4.95. The tub is about four servings.
- Family Dozen – A dozen assorted bagels with two large tubs of spread for $21.99. This is the best value per bagel.
You cannot substitute bagel styles in the combos. If you want an Asiago bagel in the Morning Combo, they will charge you the difference of $0.60. It is a small upcharge, but it is worth knowing.
Beverages And Side Items
Drinks are standard deli pricing. You will not find anything exotic here. Coffee is self-serve, and you pay for the cup size.
- Small Drip Coffee or Tea – $2.10
- Medium Drip Coffee or Tea – $2.60
- Large Drip Coffee or Tea – $3.10
- Bottled Juice or Soda – $2.50
- Fresh Orange Juice (small) – $3.75
- Bagel Chips (small bag) – $1.95
- Fruit Cup (small) – $3.25
- Matzo Ball Soup (cup) – $4.50
The soup is actually a hidden gem. It is not on the regular menu, but they make it every day until it runs out. It comes with a small piece of challah bread on the side.
How To Calculate Your Exact Total
Here is a simple step-by-step method to figure out your cost before you reach the cashier. This will help you avoid sticker shock at the register.
- Choose your bagel base. Write down the price from the list above.
- Decide on your spread. Add that price to the bagel base.
- If you want a protein, add that price next.
- Add any veggies or extra cheese.
- If you are dining in, check if your location charges a service fee. Some busy downtown spots add a 3% “dine-in surcharge.”
- Add 8.875% sales tax if you are in the city. Suburban locations might have a lower tax rate.
For example, a simple order of an Everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese and bacon would be: $1.85 + $1.75 + $2.50 = $6.10. Add tax and you are looking at about $6.65. That is a reasonable breakfast price.
But a loaded sandwich with lox, avocado, and a specialty bagel can easily hit $13.00 or more. It all depends on your choices.
Online Ordering And Delivery Pricing
If you order through a third-party app like UberEats or DoorDash, the prices are higher. The cafe raises the base price by about 15% to cover the commission fees. You will also see a service fee and a delivery fee added at checkout.
Ordering directly from the cafe’s own website or app is cheaper. They offer a 10% discount on pickup orders over $15. This is a good way to save a few bucks if you are feeding the whole office.
One thing to watch out for: the online menu sometimes lists “market price” for the lox. That means the price changes daily based on the fish market. You should call ahead if you are ordering a large catering platter with lox.
Catering Platters And Bulk Orders
For parties or meetings, the cafe offers bulk trays. These are priced per person, and you need to order at least 24 hours in advance. A deposit of 50% is required to hold your date.
- Bagel Platter (dozen assorted) – $21.99
- Deluxe Brunch Platter (dozen bagels, two tubs of spread, fruit, and juice) – $49.99
- Lox Platter (dozen bagels, two tubs of chive cream cheese, and 1 lb of lox) – $69.99
- Boxed Lunch (sandwich, side, cookie, and drink) – $14.50 per person
These platters are great for events. The per-person cost for the boxed lunch is actually cheaper than ordering a sandwich individually at the counter. You just have to meet the minimum order of ten boxes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Why is the price different on the delivery app versus the in-store menu?
A: The cafe adds a markup of about 15% to cover the fees charged by the delivery platforms. You will always pay less by ordering directly over the phone or through their own website.
Q: Can I get a half portion of cream cheese for a lower price?
A: Yes, you can ask for a “light schmear.” It is usually free, but some locations might charge a reduced price of $0.75 for a half scoop. It depends on the cashier.
Q: Are there any discounts for students or senior citizens?
A: Yes, most locations offer a 10% discount to students with a valid ID and to seniors over 65. This discount is not combinable with the combo deals. You have to pick one or the other.
Q: Does the price of a gluten-free bagel include the spread?
A: No, the gluten-free bagel is just the dough. The spread is always charged separately. This is a common point of confusion for first-time customers.
Q: How often do the prices change?
A: The cafe reviews its pricing twice a year, usually in January and July. They post a notice on the door one week before any changes take effect. The last increase was about $0.10 per item.
Final Tips For Keeping Your Bill Low
You can eat well here without spending a fortune. Stick to the classic bagel styles and plain cream cheese. Skip the bottled juice and drink tap water or coffee. The biggest cost driver is the lox and the avocado, so save those for a special treat.
Also, check the receipt before you leave the counter. Sometimes the cashier accidentally rings up a “double schmear” when you only asked for a regular portion. It happens more often than you would think.
If you are a regular, ask about the loyalty card. After buying ten bagels, you get one free with any spread. It is not advertised, but they will stamp a card for you if you request it.
Knowing the Bagel Cafe Menu with Prices is the best way to order with confidence. You can now walk up to the counter, tell them exactly what you want, and know the total before they even hit the register button. That is the smart way to start your morning.