Whether you order a thin crust or a deep dish at Broadway Pizza, the size of the pie directly influences the final total. That is why checking the current Broadway Pizza Menu with Prices before you call is a smart move for your wallet. This guide breaks down the costs, portions, and best value picks so you know exactly what to expect when the bill arrives.
Broadway Pizza has been a local favorite for decades, known for generous toppings and a crispy yet chewy base. But prices shift, and specials change more often than you might think. So, let’s get into the numbers, the combos, and the little extras that can add up fast.
Broadway Pizza Menu With Prices
You will find that the menu is pretty straightforward, but the pricing structure can be a bit tricky if you are not paying attention. They charge by size first, then by the number of toppings you pile on. A plain cheese pie is your baseline, and every addition moves the price up a notch.
Here is the thing: their “large” is actually a solid 16 inches, which feeds three or four hungry people. Do not order a large for one person unless you want leftovers for a week. The medium is 14 inches, and the small is 12 inches, which is perfect for a light meal or a side dish.
Pizza Size And Base Pricing
The base price is for cheese only. That includes the sauce and the mozzarella blend they use. You should always ask about the daily special, because sometimes you can get a large one-topping for the price of a medium.
- Small 12″ Cheese – $12.99
- Medium 14″ Cheese – $15.99
- Large 16″ Cheese – $18.99
- Extra Large 18″ Cheese – $21.99 (only at certain locations)
Those prices are pretty standard for a sit-down pizza joint. But here is where the costs start to climb. Each topping, whether it is pepperoni, sausage, or mushrooms, adds a flat fee to the total. It does not matter if you ask for a light sprinkle or a heavy load; the price is the same.
Toppings run about $1.75 on a small, $2.25 on a medium, and $2.75 on a large. If you order a “supreme” or a “specialty” pizza, the price is already set, and you cannot swap ingredients without paying extra. Specialty pies usually run between $17.99 and $24.99 depending on the size.
Specialty Pizzas And Combos
Specialty pizzas are where you get the most bang for your buck if you like meat or veggies. The “Broadway Special” is their top seller, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. It is a full meal on its own.
- Broadway Special (Large) – $23.99
- BBQ Chicken (Medium) – $19.99
- Veggie Delight (Large) – $21.99
- Meat Lovers (Large) – $25.99
- Hawaiian (Medium) – $18.99
Do not forget about the deep dish option. That is a whole different ballgame. The deep dish takes longer to bake, about 30 to 40 minutes, so you cannot be in a hurry. The price is higher because of the extra dough and butter content.
A small deep dish cheese will set you back $14.99, and a large deep dish with two toppings is around $26.99. The crust is thick and bready, so one slice is usually enough. If you are counting calories, maybe skip this one.
Appetizers And Sides Pricing
You are probably not going to eat just pizza. The sides are simple but tasty. Garlic bread with mozzarella is a crowd pleaser, and the wings are decent, though not the star of the show. The prices here are reasonable, but they can sneak up on you if you order a bunch of extras.
- Garlic Cheese Bread – $7.99
- Bone-In Wings (10 pcs) – $11.99
- Boneless Wings (10 pcs) – $10.99
- Side Salad – $5.99
- Breadsticks (6 pcs) – $6.49
If you want a salad, the dinner salad is a better deal at $8.99 because it comes with tomatoes, olives, and pepperoncini. The side salad is mostly lettuce and a couple of croutons. You can add grilled chicken to any salad for an extra $3.50.
Drinks And Desserts
Soft drinks are served by the glass or by the pitcher. A single soda refill is around $2.99, and a pitcher is $6.99. They also have bottled beer and a few local drafts on tap, but those prices vary by location. Expect to pay $4.50 to $6.00 for a domestic bottle.
Dessert is limited. You have a choice of tiramisu or a chocolate chip cookie skillet. The cookie skillet is $7.99 and takes about 15 minutes to bake. It is big enough for two people, maybe three if you are sharing.
How To Calculate Your Total Bill
Before you dial the phone or walk in, you should have a rough idea of what you are going to spend. The easiest way is to start with the base cheese price, then add the topping fees, then add tax and a tip if you are dining in.
Let me give you a real example. Suppose you want a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza. Start with the large cheese at $18.99. Add $2.75 for pepperoni and $2.75 for mushrooms. That gives you a subtotal of $24.49 before tax.
- Pick your size (Small, Medium, Large).
- Choose your crust style (Thin, Hand-Tossed, Deep Dish).
- Count your toppings (Each one adds a flat fee).
- Check for a specialty pizza deal (Often cheaper than custom).
- Add sides and drinks to your cart.
If you order online through their website or app, you will see the running total as you go. That is the best way to avoid sticker shock at the register. Also, they often have a “coupon code” box on the checkout page, so search for a promo code before you pay.
Deals And Coupon Codes
Broadway Pizza runs a lot of promotions, but they are not always advertised. You have to ask or look at their social media pages. The most common deal is the “Two Medium Two-Topping” special for $21.99, which is a great value if you are feeding a family.
Another popular one is the “Lunch Combo” from 11 AM to 2 PM on weekdays. That gets you a personal pizza, a small salad, and a drink for $8.99. It is only available for dine-in, so you cannot get that deal for delivery.
They also have a “Rewards Program” where you earn points for every dollar you spend. After you accumulate 100 points, you get a free small cheese pizza. It takes a while to get there, but it is free food, so why not sign up?
Delivery Fees And Tipping
If you are getting delivery, there is a flat delivery fee of $2.99 on all orders. That fee does not go to the driver, so you still need to tip them. Most people tip 15% to 20% on the subtotal, not including the delivery fee.
There is also a minimum order amount for delivery, usually $15.00 before tax. If you just want a small cheese pizza, you might not meet that threshold, so you will have to add a side or a drink to get over the line.
Delivery times vary, but expect 30 to 45 minutes during peak hours. On a Friday night, it could be closer to an hour. They do not have their own drivers in every area, so sometimes they use a third-party service like DoorDash or Grubhub, which has higher fees.
Dine-In Vs Takeout Pricing
Here is a little secret: the prices are the same whether you dine in or take out. There is no discount for picking up your own order. However, you will save money on the delivery fee and the tip, so takeout is usually the cheaper route.
When you dine in, you also have the option to order a “personal pan” pizza that is not on the takeout menu. That is a 9-inch pizza with one topping for $7.99. It is a good option if you are not super hungry.
Takeout orders are usually ready in 15 to 20 minutes. You can call ahead and they will have it waiting at the counter. Just make sure you check the order before you leave, because they do mess up toppings sometimes.
Frequently Asked Questions
I get a lot of questions about the menu and the pricing, so here are the answers to the most common ones. This should clear up any confusion before you place your order.
What is the cheapest item on the Broadway Pizza menu?
The cheapest item is the personal pan cheese pizza at $7.99 for dine-in. If you are doing takeout, the side salad at $5.99 is the lowest price, but it is not a meal on its own.
Does Broadway Pizza have a gluten-free crust option?
Yes, they do offer a gluten-free crust, but it is only available in a small size. It costs an additional $3.00 on top of the regular small pizza price. Just be aware that it is prepared in the same kitchen, so there is a risk of cross-contamination.
Are the prices the same at every Broadway Pizza location?
No, the prices can vary slightly depending on the location and the local cost of living. The franchise owner sets the prices, so a store in the city might be a dollar or two higher than one in the suburbs.
Can I get a half-and-half pizza with different toppings?
Yes, you can order a half-and-half pizza, but you will be charged for the full topping on both sides. For example, if you get pepperoni on one half and mushrooms on the other, you pay for two toppings, not one.
Is there a senior discount or military discount?
Some locations offer a 10% senior discount on Tuesdays, but it is not a chain-wide policy. Military discounts are also location-specific, so you have to ask your local store if they offer one.
Final Tips For Ordering Smart
To get the best value, always order the largest size you think you can finish. A large pizza is only a few dollars more than a medium, but you get a lot more food. If you have leftovers, they reheat well in the oven or an air fryer.
Do not be afraid to ask for extra sauce or well-done crust. Those requests are free and can make a big difference in taste. The staff is usually friendly and will accommodate reasonable requests without any fuss.
One last thing: check your receipt before you leave. Sometimes they add a “service charge” for large groups or a “holiday surcharge” on certain days. If you see a charge you do not understand, ask the manager to explain it. That is your right as a customer.
So, the next time you are thinking about ordering, pull up the Broadway Pizza Menu with Prices online or give them a call. A few minutes of planning will save you from any surprises when the total comes due. Enjoy your meal, and do not forget to save a slice for later.