A neighborhood institution for decades, Blue Bay Diner offers classic Greek and American dishes with prices that keep regulars coming back daily. If you want to plan your next meal, this guide to the Blue Bay Diner Menu with Prices breaks down every section so you know exactly what to expect.
The diner keeps things simple. You get big portions, fair prices, and a menu that covers breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
What Makes The Blue Bay Diner Menu Stand Out
Blue Bay leans on its Greek roots. You will find gyros, souvlaki, and spanakopita sitting right next to burgers and pancakes.
Most items land between $8 and $18. That range is why locals treat it as a daily stop rather than a once-a-month splurge.
Breakfast Favorites And Prices
Breakfast runs all day here. That is a big draw for the after-work crowd.
- Two Eggs Any Style with toast and home fries: $7.99
- Buttermilk Pancakes (short stack): $6.49
- Greek Omelet with feta, spinach, and tomato: $11.99
- Corned Beef Hash with eggs: $10.49
- Bagel with cream cheese: $3.25
Coffee is $2.50 with free refills. Regulars say thats the best deal in the building.
Lunch And Dinner Plates
The lunch and dinner menu shares most of the same items. Portions stay the same no matter the hour.
- Classic Cheeseburger with fries: $12.99
- Chicken Souvlaki Platter with rice and pita: $15.49
- Gyro Sandwich with fries: $11.99
- Open-Faced Turkey Sandwich with mashed potatoes: $13.25
- Fish and Chips: $14.99
- Pastitsio (Greek baked pasta): $14.49
You can add a small Greek salad to any plate for $4.50. It comes with feta and kalamata olives.
Blue Bay Diner Menu With Prices: Full Price Breakdown
Here is a quick look at the main categories so you can budget your visit.
Appetizers And Sides
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces): $8.99
- Chicken Fingers (5 pieces): $9.49
- French Fries: $3.99
- Onion Rings: $5.49
- Side Greek Salad: $5.99
- Cup of Soup: $4.25
Sandwiches And Wraps
- BLT on White Toast: $8.99
- Tuna Salad Sandwich: $9.49
- Grilled Chicken Wrap: $10.99
- Philly Cheesesteak: $12.49
Desserts And Drinks
- Baklava: $4.99
- Rice Pudding: $3.99
- Cheesecake: $5.49
- Soft Drink: $2.75
- Orange Juice: $3.50
- Milkshake: $5.25
How To Order And Save At Blue Bay Diner
Prices can change, so its smart to check before you go. Here is a simple way to plan your meal.
- Call ahead or check the daily specials board. Specials often cost $1 to $2 less than menu items.
- Go before 11 a.m. for breakfast pricing on eggs and pancakes.
- Order the platter instead of the sandwich if you want more food for about $3 more.
- Ask about the early bird dinner. It usually runs from 4 p.m. to 6 p.m.
- Split an appetizer. The portions are large enough for two people.
Cash is accepted, but cards work too. There is no extra fee for using a card.
Best Times To Visit For Lower Prices
Weekday mornings are calm and cheap. Weekend brunch gets busy after 10 a.m.
If you want the full menu without the wait, try Tuesday through Thursday between 2 p.m. and 4 p.m.
Final Thoughts On The Menu And Pricing
Blue Bay Diner keeps its prices steady and its portions honest. You can eat a full meal for under $15 most days.
Whether you come for the Greek platters or the all-day breakfast, you will find something that fits your budget. Check the current menu at the diner or on there website before you head over, since prices do shift a few times a year.