Bexley Pizza Plus serves handcrafted pizzas with fresh toppings and a variety of crust options to suit every preference. If you want to plan your next meal, this guide to the Bexley Pizza Plus Menu with Prices breaks down the pies, sides, and drinks so you know what to expect before you order.
The shop keeps things simple. You pick a size, pick a crust, then load it with toppings. Prices stay fair for the portion you get.
Bexley Pizza Plus Menu With Prices
Below is a general look at the menu. Actual prices can shift a bit by location and season, so treat these as close estimates.
Signature Pizzas
These are the house favorites. Each one comes in small, medium, and large.
- Cheese Pizza – $10.99 (S), $13.99 (M), $16.99 (L)
- Pepperoni Pizza – $11.99 (S), $14.99 (M), $17.99 (L)
- Supreme Pizza – $14.99 (S), $18.99 (M), $22.99 (L)
- Meat Lovers Pizza – $15.49 (S), $19.49 (M), $23.49 (L)
- Veggie Garden Pizza – $13.99 (S), $17.49 (M), $20.99 (L)
- BBQ Chicken Pizza – $14.49 (S), $18.49 (M), $21.99 (L)
Build Your Own Pizza
Start with a base price, then add toppings. This is the best route if you have picky eaters at home.
- Choose a size: small, medium, or large.
- Pick a crust: thin, hand tossed, deep dish, or gluten free.
- Add toppings at $1.25 to $2.00 each.
Crust Options And Upcharges
- Thin Crust – no extra charge
- Hand Tossed – no extra charge
- Deep Dish – add $2.00
- Gluten Free – add $3.00
Popular Toppings
- Extra cheese – $1.50
- Pepperoni – $1.75
- Sausage – $1.75
- Mushrooms – $1.25
- Onions – $1.25
- Green Peppers – $1.25
- Bacon – $2.00
- Chicken – $2.00
Sides And Starters
No pizza order feels complete without a side or two. These pair well with any pie.
- Garlic Bread – $4.99
- Cheesy Breadsticks – $6.49
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pc) – $7.49
- Chicken Wings (8 pc) – $9.99
- French Fries – $3.99
- Side Salad – $4.49
Drinks
- Fountain Soda – $2.29
- Bottled Water – $1.99
- 2-Liter Soda – $3.49
- Fresh Lemonade – $2.99
Combos And Deals
Combos save you money if you order for two or more people. Ask about daily specials when you call.
- Medium 1-Topping Pizza + Breadsticks + 2-Liter – $24.99
- Large 2-Topping Pizza + Wings + 2-Liter – $34.99
- Family Combo: 2 Large Pizzas + Cheesy Bread + Salad – $44.99
How To Order
- Call the shop or use the online ordering page.
- Pick your pizza, size, and crust.
- Add sides, drinks, or a combo deal.
- Confirm pickup or delivery time.
- Pay at pickup or online.
Delivery usually adds a small fee. Pickup is faster on busy nights like Friday and Saturday.
Tips For Saving Money
- Order a combo instead of items one by one.
- Skip premium toppings if you want a lower total.
- Check for weekly specials before you order.
- Split a large pizza instead of buying two mediums.
Prices above are estimates and can change without notice. Call Bexley Pizza Plus directly for the most current menu and pricing before you place your order.