Anna Marias Pizzeria turns out hand-tossed pies with a focus on simple toppings and a well-proofed crust. If you want to plan your order before you arrive, this guide to the Anna Marias Pizzeria Menu with Prices breaks down the pies, sides, drinks, and desserts so you know exactly what to expect.
The menu stays small on purpose. That means faster service and fresher ingredients. Below you’ll find the full lineup, typical price ranges, and a few tips for getting the most out of your visit.
Anna Marias Pizzeria Menu With Prices
Prices can shift a little by location and season, but the ranges below reflect what most guests pay. Tax is not included. Most whole pies come in two sizes, a 12-inch and a 16-inch.
Classic Pizzas
These are the pies that built the reputation. Simple cheese, good sauce, and a crust that gets a nice chew from a long proof.
- Cheese Pizza (12-inch) — $11.50
- Cheese Pizza (16-inch) — $15.75
- Pepperoni (12-inch) — $13.25
- Pepperoni (16-inch) — $17.95
- Margherita (12-inch) — $12.75
- Margherita (16-inch) — $16.95
- Sausage and Onion (16-inch) — $18.50
Specialty Pizzas
These cost a bit more because of the extra toppings. Each one is built to balance salty, sweet, and spicy notes without going overboard.
- White Garlic Pie (12-inch) — $14.50
- White Garlic Pie (16-inch) — $18.95
- Meat Lovers (16-inch) — $20.50
- Veggie Garden (12-inch) — $14.25
- Veggie Garden (16-inch) — $18.25
- Spicy Soppressata (16-inch) — $19.75
Slices And Lunch Specials
If you just want a quick bite, slices are the way to go. They’re pulled from whole pies during lunch hours.
- Cheese Slice — $3.75
- Pepperoni Slice — $4.25
- Specialty Slice — $5.00
- Two Slices and a Soda — $9.50
Starters And Sides
These round out a meal, especially if you’re feeding a group. Portions are generous enough to share.
- Garlic Knots (6) — $5.50
- Garlic Knots (12) — $9.25
- Mozzarella Sticks (6) — $7.75
- Caesar Salad — $8.50
- House Salad — $7.25
- Meatballs (3) — $6.95
Drinks And Desserts
Keep it simple with a soda, or finish with something sweet. The cannoli sell out fast on weekends.
- Fountain Soda — $2.75
- Bottled Water — $2.00
- Italian Soda — $3.50
- Cannoli (2) — $6.50
- Tiramisu — $7.25
- Gelato Cup — $4.75
How To Order Without Overpaying
A few small choices can keep your total down. Here’s how regulars do it.
- Go at lunch for slice deals instead of a full pie.
- Order the 16-inch if you have three or more people, the per-slice cost is lower.
- Skip extra toppings on a specialty pie, they’re already loaded.
- Ask about the day’s special, it changes and often saves you a few dollars.
- Pick up instead of delivery to avoid the fee.
What Makes The Menu Work
The dough gets a slow rise, so the crust holds up under sauce and cheese. Toppings are kept minimal on purpose. You taste the bread, not just the extras.
Portions are honest. A 16-inch pie feeds three adults comfortably, sometimes four if you add a starter. Sides are priced fair for what you get.
Best Values On The Menu
- The two-slice lunch combo at $9.50
- Garlic knots, six for $5.50
- The 16-inch cheese pie at $15.75
- Caesar salad at $8.50, big enough to split
Tips For First-Time Visitors
Call ahead on Friday and Saturday nights. Wait times can hit 40 minutes. If you have kids, the cheese pie and knots are the safe bet. Ask for the crust well done if you like a crispier bite.
Prices may vary slightly by store, so check your local listing before you go. Now you can walk in knowing what you want and what it costs.