American Pie Pizzeria builds its pricing around a simple principle: specialty pies cost more, classic cheese stays affordable, and sides fill the gap. If you want the full American Pie Pizzeria Menu with Prices before you order, this guide breaks it down in plain terms.
You will see how much a large pepperoni runs, what the veggie options cost, and where the deals hide. Prices can vary a bit by location, so treat these as close estimates.
American Pie Pizzeria Menu With Prices
The menu splits into four main groups: classic pizzas, specialty pizzas, sides, and drinks. Most people spend between $12 and $25 per person once they add a side and a drink.
Classic Pizzas And Their Prices
These are the everyday pies. Simple toppings, steady prices, and easy to split with a friend.
- Cheese Slice: $3.50
- Cheese Pie, 14 inch: $12.99
- Pepperoni Pie, 14 inch: $14.99
- Sausage Pie, 14 inch: $15.49
- Mushroom Pie, 14 inch: $14.49
- Half And Half Pie, 14 inch: $15.99
Extra toppings usually add $1.50 to $2.50 each. Onions, peppers, and olives sit at the low end. Bacon and chicken cost more.
Specialty Pizzas And Their Prices
Specialty pies carry the higher price tags because they use more ingredients. Expect $17 to $24 for a large.
- Meat Lovers, 14 inch: $21.99
- BBQ Chicken, 14 inch: $19.99
- White Garlic Pie, 14 inch: $17.99
- Veggie Supreme, 14 inch: $18.99
- Buffalo Chicken, 14 inch: $20.49
- Four Cheese, 14 inch: $18.49
The Meat Lovers is the priciest item on the board. If you order a 16 inch, add about $3 to each number above.
Sides, Salads, And Drinks
Sides are where you round out the meal without spending much. Most land under $10.
- Garlic Knots, 6 pieces: $5.49
- Mozzarella Sticks, 5 pieces: $7.99
- Chicken Wings, 8 pieces: $11.99
- Caesar Salad: $8.49
- Garden Salad: $7.49
- Fountain Drink: $2.99
- Canned Soda: $1.99
- Bottled Water: $1.79
Best Value Combos
Two slices and a drink often cost less than a full pie. Ask the counter staff if they run a lunch special on weekdays.
Family Deal Breakdown
A large pie, wings, and knots usually comes to about $40. That feeds three or four people without going over budget.
How To Order And Save Money
You do not need a coupon to eat well here. A few small choices cut the bill fast.
- Order a 14 inch instead of 16 inch. The savings are real and the slice count is close.
- Skip specialty pies on a tight budget. Cheese plus two toppings costs less.
- Buy garlic knots instead of wings. You save about $6.
- Split a salad between two people.
- Check for a weekday lunch deal before 3 pm.
Pickup beats delivery in most cases. Delivery adds a fee plus a tip, which can push a $25 order past $35.
What Affects The Final Price
Location matters. A shop in a big city charges more than one in a small town. Tax also changes the total, and some states tax prepared food higher than groceries.
Toppings add up quick. Three extras on a large pie can add $6 or more. If you want a loaded pie, a specialty option is often cheaper than building your own.
Seasonal items come and go. A pumpkin or holiday pie may show up in fall, and the price tends to sit near the specialty range.
Quick Price Summary
- Slices: $3 to $4
- Classic pies: $13 to $16
- Specialty pies: $18 to $24
- Sides: $5 to $12
- Drinks: $1.79 to $2.99
Call your local shop or check its online menu for the exact numbers, since franchise locations set there own prices. Now you can plan your order before you walk in the door.