Ordering a bagel sandwich at 5Th Ave Bagelry goes smoother when you already know what each combination costs before reaching the counter. This guide breaks down the full 5Th Ave Bagelry Menu with Prices so you can pick your meal and budget without guesswork.
The shop keeps things simple. You choose a bagel, a spread, and a filling. Then you pay based on the combo you build.
What You Should Know Before You Order
Most locations follow the same basic pricing. A few stores in busy areas charge slightly more. Its always smart to check the board when you walk in.
Here is how the menu is organized:
- Plain bagels and spreads
- Breakfast sandwiches
- Lunch bagel sandwiches
- Sides and extras
- Drinks
5Th Ave Bagelry Menu With Prices
Below is a typical price list. Treat these numbers as a close estimate, not a locked-in quote.
Bagels And Spreads
- Plain bagel: $1.50
- Sesame bagel: $1.60
- Everything bagel: $1.75
- Poppy seed bagel: $1.60
- Cinnamon raisin bagel: $1.85
- Whole wheat bagel: $1.70
- Plain cream cheese: $1.25
- Flavored cream cheese: $1.75
- Butter: $0.75
- Peanut butter: $1.10
Breakfast Sandwiches
These come on your choice of bagel. Egg and cheese is the base.
- Egg and cheese: $4.25
- Bacon, egg, and cheese: $5.75
- Sausage, egg, and cheese: $5.75
- Ham, egg, and cheese: $5.95
- Turkey, egg, and cheese: $6.25
- Veggie egg and cheese: $5.50
Lunch Bagel Sandwiches
- Turkey and Swiss: $7.50
- Ham and cheddar: $7.50
- Roast beef and provolone: $8.25
- Tuna salad: $7.25
- Chicken salad: $7.25
- BLT: $6.95
- Veggie and hummus: $6.50
Sides And Extras
- Hash brown: $1.95
- Side of fruit: $3.25
- Bag of chips: $1.50
- Pickle spear: $0.95
- Extra cheese: $0.80
- Extra meat: $1.75
- Avocado: $1.50
Drinks
- Small coffee: $2.25
- Large coffee: $2.95
- Iced coffee: $3.25
- Hot tea: $2.00
- Orange juice: $3.50
- Bottled water: $1.75
- Soda can: $1.85
How To Build A Cheap Order
You do not need to spend a lot to eat well here. Follow these steps.
- Pick a plain or sesame bagel instead of a specialty one.
- Skip the meat and get egg and cheese only.
- Drink water or brew coffee at home.
- Share a side of fruit or hash browns.
- Ask about the daily combo, which often saves you a dollar.
A plain bagel with butter and a small coffee lands around $3.50. That is one of the cheapest full breakfasts you will find on the avenue.
Ways To Save On Your Total
Combo Deals
Many shops bundle a sandwich, a side, and a drink. The bundle usually costs less then buying each item alone.
Loyalty Cards
Ask the cashier if they have a punch card. Buy ten bagels, get one free is common. It adds up fast if you visit weekly.
Off-Peak Hours
Prices stay the same all day, but the line is shorter before 7 a.m. and after 2 p.m. You save time, which counts too.
Tips For First-Time Visitors
- Order at the counter, then wait for your name.
- Cash and card are both accepted at most spots.
- Ask for the bagel toasted if you like a crisp edge.
- Say yes to the wrapper if you are taking it to go.
- Check the receipt, since tax varies by location.
Prices can shift with food costs, so confirm the total at the register. Now you can walk in, order fast, and know exactly what you will pay.