440 Pizzeria Menu with Prices offers New York style slices and whole pies with a straightforward menu that prioritizes quality ingredients. If you want to know what a slice costs before you walk in, this 440 Pizzeria Menu with Prices guide breaks down the food, the sizes, and the extras. The shop keeps things simple, so ordering is quick and easy.
440 Pizzeria Menu With Prices
The menu is built around pizza, but you also get a handful of sides, drinks, and desserts. Prices below are typical for the shop and may vary a little by location or season. Always check the board or the app for the current numbers.
Classic Pizza Slices
Slices are the fastest way to eat here. You can grab one on a quick lunch break or order a few for the table.
- Cheese Slice – $3.75
- Pepperoni Slice – $4.25
- Sausage Slice – $4.50
- Mushroom Slice – $4.25
- White Slice – $4.50
- Sicilian Slice – $5.00
Whole Pies And Sizes
Whole pies come in three main sizes. A small works for one or two people. The large is the best value for a family.
- Small Cheese Pie (12 inch) – $14.00
- Medium Cheese Pie (16 inch) – $17.50
- Large Cheese Pie (18 inch) – $20.00
- Large Pepperoni Pie – $23.00
- Large Supreme Pie – $26.50
- Large Veggie Pie – $24.00
Specialty Pies
These pies use the same dough and sauce but add heavier toppings. They take a few extra minutes to bake.
- Margherita Pie – $21.00
- Buffalo Chicken Pie – $25.00
- Meat Lovers Pie – $27.00
- White Garlic Pie – $22.50
- Hawaiian Pie – $23.50
Sides, Salads, And Drinks
Sides are cheap and pair well with a slice or a whole pie.
- Garlic Knots (6) – $4.00
- Garlic Bread – $5.00
- Mozzarella Sticks (6) – $7.50
- Chicken Wings (8) – $11.00
- Caesar Salad – $8.00
- Garden Salad – $7.50
- Soda Can – $2.00
- Bottled Water – $2.00
- 2-Liter Soda – $4.00
Desserts
You only get a few sweet options, but they sell out fast on busy nights.
- Cannoli – $4.50
- Cheesecake Slice – $5.50
- Chocolate Chip Cookie – $2.50
How To Order And Save Money
You can order at the counter, by phone, or through the shop’s app. Here is a simple way to keep your bill low.
- Check the daily slice special before you order a whole pie.
- Buy a large pie instead of two mediums if you have four or more people.
- Add garlic knots instead of a second side. They cost less and feed more.
- Ask about the lunch combo. It usually includes a slice and a drink for one price.
- Skip delivery fees by picking up your order yourself.
What Makes The Menu Stand Out
The dough is made fresh each morning. The sauce is a simple tomato blend with no added sugar. Cheese is whole milk mozzarella, shredded in house.
That focus on basics is why the slices taste clean and not greasy. The crust has a good chew and a light char on the bottom. Toppings are added in normal amounts, so the pie does not get soggy.
Tips Before You Visit
Peak hours are Friday and Saturday from 6 to 8 p.m. Expect a line at the counter during that window. Call ahead if you want a whole pie ready when you arrive.
Prices can change without notice, and some shops charge a small fee for extra toppings. A single extra topping usually runs $1.50 to $2.50 depending on size. Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but cash is faster at the register.
If you are feeding a crowd, order two large pies and a few sides. That combo covers about six to eight people for under $60. For a solo meal, one slice and a soda keeps you near $6.