Martha’s Country Bakery charges by the slice for their towering cakes, so your dessert budget depends on how many layers you choose. When you first look at the Martha’s Country Bakery Menu with Prices, you will notice that the portions are huge and the costs are actually fair for what you get. This guide breaks down the full menu, real prices, and the best ways to order without any surprises.
You have probably seen the photos on Instagram. The cakes are tall, the frosting is thick, and the fruit tarts are loaded. But what does it cost to eat there today? We went through the current menu items and checked the price points across their locations in Queens and Long Island. Here is the honest breakdown you need before you walk in.
Martha’s Country Bakery Menu With Prices
The menu is massive. You will find cakes, pies, cookies, savory items, and a full breakfast menu. The prices below reflect the standard menu pricing as of this year. Keep in mind that some locations might add a small surcharge for credit cards or delivery orders.
Signature Cakes And Slices
The cakes are the main reason people visit. You can buy a whole cake or just a slice. The slices are very generous, often enough for two people.
- Chocolate Mousse Cake (Slice) – $8.95
- Chocolate Mousse Cake (Whole) – $48.00
- Red Velvet Cake (Slice) – $7.95
- Red Velvet Cake (Whole) – $42.00
- Carrot Cake (Slice) – $7.95
- Carrot Cake (Whole) – $42.00
- Strawberry Shortcake (Slice) – $8.50
- Blackout Cake (Slice) – $8.95
- Cheesecake (Plain, Slice) – $6.95
- Cheesecake (Plain, Whole) – $38.00
You should ask about the daily special cake. They often have a seasonal fruit cake or a new flavor that is not on the printed menu. The special slice is usually the same price as the regular slices, around $8.50.
Cookies And Small Pastries
If you are not looking for a full cake, the cookie case is a good option. You can mix and match, and they sell by the pound or per piece.
- Black and White Cookie – $3.50
- Chocolate Chip Cookie – $2.75
- Rainbow Cookie (per pound) – $18.99
- Butter Croissant – $3.95
- Chocolate Croissant – $4.50
- Cannoli (per piece) – $5.50
- Lobster Tail – $6.75
The rainbow cookies are a crowd favorite. They are soft and the apricot jam inside is noticeable. You can buy a small box or a large tray for parties.
Breakfast And Brunch Items
Martha’s is not only a dessert shop. They serve breakfast all day. The prices are reasonable for the size of the plates.
- Two Eggs Any Style with Home Fries and Toast – $9.95
- Belgian Waffle with Strawberries – $11.50
- French Toast Combo – $10.95
- Egg and Cheese on a Roll – $5.75
- Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich – $7.25
- Avocado Toast – $12.50
- Omelette (Three Egg, Choose Fillings) – $11.95
Breakfast is served until closing time. That means you can get pancakes at 8 PM if you want. The coffee is decent and they offer free refills on regular brewed coffee when you dine in.
Savory Sandwiches And Paninis
For lunch, they have a full deli counter and grill. The sandwiches are made on their fresh bread.
- Turkey Club Sandwich – $13.95
- Grilled Chicken Panini – $12.95
- Tuna Melt – $11.50
- BLT – $10.95
- Reuben Sandwich – $14.50
- Vegetarian Wrap – $10.95
Most sandwiches come with a small side salad or coleslaw. You can upgrade to a soup for an extra $2.50. The soup of the day is usually a chicken noodle or a tomato bisque.
Pies And Tarts
The fruit tarts are a visual masterpiece. They use fresh fruit and a light glaze.
- Apple Pie (Slice) – $6.95
- Apple Pie (Whole) – $28.00
- Cherry Pie (Slice) – $6.95
- Lemon Meringue Pie (Slice) – $7.50
- Fruit Tart (Small, Individual) – $5.95
- Fruit Tart (Large, 9-inch) – $32.00
- Pecan Pie (Slice) – $7.95
The pecan pie is very sweet. If you do not have a huge sweet tooth, you might want to share it. The fruit tart has a custard base that is not too heavy.
Drinks And Beverages
You can get standard fountain drinks, fresh juices, and specialty coffee drinks.
- Fresh Orange Juice (Small) – $4.95
- Fresh Orange Juice (Large) – $6.95
- Hot Chocolate – $4.50
- Latte – $4.95
- Cappuccino – $4.75
- Iced Coffee – $3.95
- Bottled Water – $2.00
The hot chocolate is made with real melted chocolate, not just powder. It is rich and comes with whipped cream on top.
Custom Cake Orders And Pricing
If you need a custom cake for a birthday or event, you need to order ahead. The price depends on the size and the decorations.
- Choose your base flavor (chocolate, vanilla, red velvet, or carrot).
- Select the filling (fruit, mousse, or buttercream).
- Decide on the size (8-inch, 10-inch, or sheet cake).
- Add custom decorations or a message.
An 8-inch custom cake starts around $55.00. A larger sheet cake can go up to $90.00 or more depending on the design. You should call the store directly to get a quote because the online menu does not list all custom options. They require at least 48 hours notice for custom orders, but for wedding cakes, you should call a week ahead.
Location Differences In Pricing
There are several locations. The main ones are in Bayside, Forest Hills, and Huntington. The prices are mostly the same across these locations. However, the Huntington location sometimes has a slightly higher price on the specialty cakes, about $0.50 more per slice. The Forest Hills location is the busiest, so expect a line on weekends.
You can also order through delivery apps like Uber Eats or DoorDash. Be aware that the app prices are higher than the in-store prices. You might pay an extra $1.00 to $2.00 per item on the app. The delivery fee is also separate. If you want the best price, you should go to the store in person.
Tips For Saving Money
You can keep your bill lower if you know how to order.
- Share a slice. The slices are large enough for two.
- Skip the bottled drinks and get a regular coffee.
- Check the day-old pastry rack near the register. They sell items for half price.
- Join their email list for a birthday discount coupon.
- Go on a weekday morning to avoid the crowd and get faster service.
The day-old rack is a secret. You can get a muffin or a danish for $1.50 or $2.00. They are still fresh enough, just not perfect looking.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Martha’s Country Bakery have a senior discount?
Yes, they offer a small discount for senior citizens on certain items. You need to ask the cashier when you order. It is usually about 10% off the total, but it does not apply to custom cakes.
Are there any gluten-free options on the menu?
They have a few gluten-free cakes available, but the selection is limited. The flourless chocolate cake is a good option. It costs about $8.95 per slice. They do not have a dedicated gluten-free kitchen, so there is a risk of cross-contamination.
Can I order a half cake?
No, they do not sell half cakes. You have to buy either a slice or a whole cake. The whole cake prices are listed above.
Do they accept credit cards?
Yes, all locations accept major credit cards. They also accept Apple Pay and Google Pay. There is no minimum purchase for using a card.
Is the price on the menu the final price with tax?
No, the prices listed are before tax. You will pay New York state sales tax on top of the listed price. There is no additional service charge for dining in.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
The overall value is good. You are paying for quality ingredients and large portions. The savory breakfast items are priced competitively with local diners. The cakes are the premium item, but the slices are shareable, which makes the cost per person lower.
If you are on a budget, stick to the cookies or the day-old items. If you are celebrating something, the whole cake is worth the price. The staff is usually helpful if you ask for recommendations. They will let you know what is the most popular item that day.
One thing to note is that the menu can change slightly with the seasons. In the summer, they add more fruit-based desserts. In the winter, they have more chocolate and peppermint flavors. The core items like the red velvet and the cheesecake are always available.
You should also look at the display case before you order. Sometimes the actual cake looks different from the photo. The portions are always generous, so do not be shocked when you see the size of the slice. It is almost double the size of a standard bakery slice.
Parking can be tricky at the Bayside location. There is a small lot, but it fills up fast. The Forest Hills location is near the subway, so it is easier to get to if you are using public transit. The Huntington location has a larger parking lot.
For the best experience, go during the late morning on a weekday. You will beat the lunch rush and the after-school crowd. The bakery opens early, around 7 AM, so you can also grab a quick breakfast before work.
Remember to check your receipt before you leave. Sometimes the cashier will add a tip line even for takeout orders. You do not have to tip for takeout, but you can leave a dollar or two if you want. For table service, a 15% to 20% tip is standard.
The menu is long, so do not feel rushed. Take your time to look at the glass cases. If you have questions about an ingredient, just ask. The bakers are usually in the back and the counter staff knows the recipes well. They can tell you if a cake has nuts or if a pie is made with lard.
Overall, you will leave full and satisfied. The prices are fair for the quality and the size. Just remember to bring your appetite and maybe a friend to share with. That way you can try two different slices without feeling too full.
If you are planning a party, the sheet cakes are the most economical option. They serve about 20 people and start around $70. That is a better deal than buying individual slices. You can also get a variety platter of pastries for around $25, which is good for a small gathering.
The hot food menu is not the main attraction, but it is solid. The burgers are decent and the fries are crispy. The prices are a little higher than a fast food place, but the quality is better. You get a real plate and silverware if you dine in.
Do not forget to grab some coffee to go with your dessert. The coffee is strong and pairs well with the sweet cakes. They also have decaf and a variety of teas. The chai latte is a good choice if you want something spiced.
One last tip: if you are getting a whole cake for a special occasion, ask them to write a message on top. It is free of charge and they do a neat job with the piping. You can also request a specific color for the frosting.
That covers the full menu and the prices you can expect. Go check it out and enjoy your dessert.