Amato’s pricing strategy balances traditional Italian portions with modern expectations about what a full meal should cost. If you are looking for a clear breakdown of Amato’s Menu with Prices before you walk in the door, you have come to the right spot. We have looked at the current offerings so you can plan your order without any guesswork.
Italian dining can sometimes feel like a gamble. You never know if you are paying for the name or the actual food. This guide breaks down every section of the menu, from the appetizers to the desserts. We will also point out where the real value hides and what items might stretch your budget.
Appetizers And Small Plates
Starting your meal with a shareable plate is usually the smartest move. The portions here are generous, but the starters give you a taste of the kitchen’s style. You can easily build a meal from just these items if you are not overly hungry.
Here is the current price list for the opening courses:
- Garlic Bread with Mozzarella – $7.95
- Calamari Fritti (Fried Calamari) – $12.50
- Bruschetta al Pomodoro – $9.25
- Stuffed Mushrooms (6 pieces) – $10.75
- Fried Ravioli (8 pieces) – $9.95
- Soup of the Day – $5.50 per cup / $7.50 per bowl
- Caesar Salad (Side) – $6.25
- House Salad (Side) – $5.75
The Calamari is a fan favorite, but the portion can vary depending on who is working the fryer. If you want consistency, stick to the Bruschetta. It is light, fresh, and the price is fair for what you get.
One thing to note is that the side salads are not huge. If you are planning to share a salad between two people, you should order the full size instead. The full Caesar will cost you around $11.95 and comes with grilled chicken if you ask for it.
Pizza Selection
Pizza is a staple here, and the prices reflect the quality of the ingredients. They use a thin crust that holds up well to toppings without becoming soggy. You can order a personal size or go for a large to feed the whole table.
Here is the breakdown for the pizza menu:
- Margherita (Personal 10″) – $10.95 / (Large 16″) – $17.95
- Pepperoni – $12.50 / $19.50
- Quattro Formaggi (Four Cheese) – $13.25 / $20.75
- Supreme (Sausage, Pepperoni, Peppers, Onions) – $14.95 / $22.95
- BBQ Chicken – $13.75 / $21.50
- White Pizza (Ricotta Base) – $12.95 / $20.25
You can add extra toppings for $1.75 on a personal and $2.50 on a large. That is a standard price, but the quality of the sausage makes it worth the upgrade. The crust has a nice chew to it, which is rare to find at this price point.
If you are dining alone, the personal size is actually enough for two meals. I usually eat half and save the rest for lunch the next day. That makes the $10.95 price tag feel a lot more reasonable.
Pasta Dishes
This is where Amato’s really shines. The pasta is cooked to order, and the sauces are made in-house. You will not find any pre-packaged gravy here. The menu covers all the classics, but the portions are what keep people coming back.
Take a look at the pasta section of the menu:
- Spaghetti with Marinara – $11.95
- Spaghetti with Meatballs – $15.95
- Fettuccine Alfredo – $13.95
- Chicken Parmigiana (Served with Spaghetti) – $17.95
- Eggplant Parmigiana – $15.25
- Lasagna (Baked) – $16.50
- Penne alla Vodka – $14.75
- Rigatoni with Sausage – $16.25
- Shrimp Scampi – $18.95
- Tortellini Alfredo – $15.95
Notice that the Chicken Parm comes with a side of spaghetti. That is a full plate of food. You will not leave hungry. The Lasagna is also a solid choice, but it is very heavy. If you are looking for something lighter, the Penne alla Vodka has a nice kick to it.
The Shrimp Scampi is the most expensive pasta, but it comes with a generous number of shrimp. I counted seven large shrimp on my last order. That is a fair deal compared to other Italian spots in the area.
Main Courses And Entrees
If you want a full dinner experience, the entrees are the way to go. These come with a side of pasta or vegetables. You have to specify which one you want when you order, otherwise, they will default to spaghetti.
Here are the main dishes with their current prices:
- Veal Parmigiana – $19.95
- Chicken Marsala – $18.50
- Chicken Francese – $18.50
- Chicken Scarpariello – $19.25
- Eggplant Rollatini – $16.95
- Baked Ziti with Sausage – $14.95
- Sausage and Peppers – $15.95
- Filet of Sole – $21.95
- Shrimp Marinara – $20.50
The Chicken Marsala is a safe bet. The sauce is rich but not overly sweet. The Veal Parmigiana is also good, but the price is creeping up there. If you are watching your wallet, the Baked Ziti with Sausage is the best value on this part of the menu.
All entrees include a small salad and a side of bread. The bread is served warm with a garlic butter spread. It is easy to fill up on the bread, but try to save room for the main event.
Specialty Dishes And Chef’s Specials
Amato’s also has a rotating list of specials that are not always printed on the standard menu. These are usually written on a whiteboard near the register or announced by the server. The prices for these can change based on the market cost of the ingredients.
Some of the regular specials you might see include:
- Lobster Ravioli in a Pink Sauce – $22.95
- Osso Buco (When Available) – $28.00
- Risotto of the Day – $17.95
- Fresh Fish (Seasonal) – Market Price
You should always ask what the specials are before you order. Sometimes the Risotto is a better deal than the standard pasta dishes. However, the “Market Price” on the fresh fish can be a trap. Always ask for the exact price before you commit to it.
I have seen the Osso Buco sell out by 6 PM on a Saturday. If you want that dish, you need to get there early. It is a labor-intensive meal, so the price is justified.
Desserts And Beverages
Dessert is not an afterthought here. They have a display case near the front with cakes and pastries. You can also order classic Italian desserts from the menu.
Here is what you can expect to pay for something sweet:
- Tiramisu – $7.50
- Cannoli (2 pieces) – $6.95
- Cheesecake – $6.95
- Tartufo – $7.25
- Spumoni – $5.95
For drinks, they have the usual sodas and iced tea for $2.95. They also have a small wine list. A glass of house Chianti or Pinot Grigio will run you about $8.50. A bottle will cost between $28 and $45 depending on the label.
The Cannoli are made fresh throughout the day. The shell is crispy, and the filling is not too sweet. That is a great way to end the meal.
Lunch Specials And Value Deals
If you are visiting during the weekday, you should look at the lunch menu. It is a scaled-down version of the dinner menu, but the prices are significantly lower. This is the best way to try the food without spending a lot of money.
The lunch specials run from 11:30 AM to 3:00 PM, Monday through Friday. Here is what they offer:
- Pasta Lunch (Choice of Marinara, Alfredo, or Vodka) – $9.95
- Chicken Parm Sandwich – $10.95
- Meatball Sub – $10.25
- Eggplant Parm Sandwich – $9.95
- Personal Pizza Lunch Combo – $11.50
These lunch deals come with a small side salad or a cup of soup. You cannot beat that price for the quality. The Chicken Parm Sandwich is huge, so you might want to split it with a friend.
There is also a “Senior Discount” available for guests over 65. It is not advertised heavily, but it takes 10% off your total bill. You just have to ask for it when you pay.
Amato’s Menu With Prices
Now that we have covered the specific categories, let’s summarize the overall cost structure. The average price for a dinner entree is around $17.00. The average price for a lunch item is around $10.50. This puts Amato’s in the mid-range category for Italian food.
You are not paying fine-dining prices, but you are also not getting fast-food quality. The ingredients are fresh, and the portions are large. For a family of four, you can expect to spend roughly $70 to $90 for a full dinner with drinks and appetizers, but without dessert.
Here is a quick cost breakdown for a typical dinner for two:
- Appetizer (Calamari) – $12.50
- Two Entrees (Pasta and Chicken Parm) – $33.90
- Two Soft Drinks – $5.90
- One Dessert (Tiramisu) – $7.50
- Subtotal – $59.80
- Tax (approx. 8%) – $4.78
- Total before tip – $64.58
That is a very reasonable price for a sit-down Italian meal. You could easily spend double that at a chain restaurant and get food that is not as good.
Tips For Saving Money
If you want to keep your bill low, there are a few strategies that work well. The menu is flexible, and the staff is usually willing to accommodate requests.
- Order the lunch specials instead of the dinner menu.
- Ask for the “Side of Pasta” instead of a full entree. It is cheaper and often just as filling.
- Split an entree. The kitchen will plate it on two dishes for a small fee of $2.00.
- Skip the bottled water and order tap water. It saves you $3.00.
- Check for a coupon in the local mailers. They send them out every few months.
These small changes can save you up to $15 on a single visit. That is enough to cover a dessert and a coffee.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people have about the pricing and the menu before they visit.
Does Amato’s offer gluten-free pasta options?
Yes, they do. You can substitute gluten-free penne for any pasta dish for an additional $2.50. The price is not listed on the main menu, but you just need to ask your server.
Is there a difference in price for takeout versus dining in?
No, the prices are exactly the same. However, if you order takeout directly from the restaurant (not through a third-party app), you avoid the delivery service fees. The portions are also the same size.
Are the prices on the online menu the same as in the restaurant?
Generally, yes. But the online menu can sometimes lag behind. If there is a discrepancy, the price at the register is the one that counts. It is always a good idea to confirm the price when you order.
Do they charge extra for extra sauce or dressing?
They do not charge for extra marinara or alfredo sauce on the side. However, if you want a specific salad dressing that is not the house standard, there might be a $0.75 charge. The ranch and blue cheese are free.
Is the gratuity included in the bill?
For regular tables, no. Gratuity is only automatically added for parties of six or larger. That standard gratuity is 18%. For smaller groups, you can tip whatever you feel is appropriate.
Amato’s Menu with Prices shows a clear commitment to value. You get large portions of solid, home-style Italian food without the inflated prices you see at tourist spots. The staff is friendly, and the service is usually quick, even when the dining room is full. If you are local or just passing through, this is a dependable choice for a satisfying meal that will not break the bank. Just remember to bring your appetite, because the plates are stacked high.