Baker’s Square keeps their famous pies affordable, but the full menu reveals where your money goes. If you are looking for the Baker’s Square Menu with Prices before you head out, you came to the right place. We broke down the entire list so you know exactly what to expect when the check arrives.
Most people walk in for the pie, but they stay for the hearty breakfasts and classic dinners. The prices have shifted a little over the last year, but the portions remain generous. Let’s look at the current costs for every section of the menu, from the early bird specials to the late-night slices.
Breakfast Menu Costs
Breakfast is served all day, which is a big win for people who wake up late. You can grab a full plate of eggs and pancakes at 3 PM if you want. The breakfast menu is split into sweet options and savory skillets.
Classic Egg Plates
The standard two-egg breakfast comes with your choice of toast, hash browns, or fruit. You get bacon, sausage links, or ham on the side.
- Two Egg Breakfast – $9.99
- Steak and Eggs – $14.49
- Country Fried Steak and Eggs – $13.29
- Ham and Swiss Omelet – $11.79
- Veggie Omelet – $10.99
You can add a side of avocado to any egg plate for $1.49. Egg whites are available as a substitute for an extra $0.79.
Sweet Breakfast Favorites
If you have a sweet tooth, the bakery case influences the breakfast menu. The French toast uses thick-cut bread, not the flimsy store-bought kind.
- Original French Toast – $8.99
- Stuffed French Toast (Strawberry or Apple) – $10.49
- Buttermilk Pancake Stack – $8.49
- Blueberry Pancakes – $9.79
- Belgian Waffle – $9.29
Add a side of seasonal fruit for $2.29. Whipped butter is always complimentary, but extra syrup costs $0.50.
Baker’s Square Menu With Prices For Lunch
Lunch starts at 11 AM and runs until close. The menu focuses on sandwiches, soups, and salads. The portions are large enough that you might have leftovers for dinner.
Sandwiches And Burgers
All sandwiches come with a pickle spear and your choice of fries, coleslaw, or a cup of soup. The burgers are cooked to order, and you can request a lettuce wrap instead of a bun for no extra charge.
- Classic Cheeseburger – $10.99
- Bacon Avocado Burger – $12.49
- Chicken Club Sandwich – $11.29
- Philly Cheesesteak – $12.99
- Turkey Avocado Wrap – $10.79
- Grilled Reuben – $11.49
Upgrade your fries to sweet potato fries for $1.29. Onion rings cost an extra $1.99.
Soup And Salad Combos
The soup rotation changes daily, but the chicken noodle and broccoli cheddar are usually available. You can pair a half sandwich with a cup of soup for a lighter meal.
- Cup of Soup – $3.79
- Bowl of Soup – $4.99
- House Salad (Small) – $4.29
- House Salad (Large) – $6.79
- Caesar Salad – $7.49
- Chicken Caesar Salad – $9.99
- Half Sandwich and Cup of Soup Combo – $8.99
Add grilled chicken to any salad for $3.29. Dressing packets are available if you ask, but the house ranch is made in-house.
Dinner Entrees And Sides
Dinner is where the menu gets serious. The dinner plates are served with a side salad or a cup of soup, plus your choice of potato or vegetable. The portions are heavy, so come hungry.
Steak And Chicken Dinners
The grill items are the most expensive part of the menu. The steaks are USDA choice, and the chicken is always grilled fresh, not fried ahead of time.
- Grilled Chicken Breast – $12.99
- Chicken Fried Chicken – $13.49
- Top Sirloin Steak (8 oz) – $16.99
- Ribeye Steak (12 oz) – $19.99
- BBQ Ribs (Half Rack) – $14.99
- BBQ Ribs (Full Rack) – $18.49
Add a shrimp skewer to any dinner for $4.99. Steak sauces are complimentary, but au jus is an extra $0.79.
Pasta And Seafood Options
Seafood is not the main focus, but the options are solid. The pasta dishes are filling and come with garlic bread.
- Spaghetti with Meat Sauce – $10.99
- Chicken Alfredo – $12.49
- Shrimp Scampi – $14.29
- Fish and Chips – $11.99
- Grilled Salmon – $15.99
Substitute gluten-free pasta for $1.99. Extra garlic bread is $1.29 for two slices.
Dinner Sides
You can order sides individually if you just want a snack or a small plate. The mashed potatoes are real, not from a box.
- Mashed Potatoes – $2.79
- Baked Potato – $2.99
- Steamed Broccoli – $2.49
- Seasonal Vegetables – $2.29
- French Fries – $2.79
- Side Salad – $3.49
Gravy on the mashed potatoes is free. Cheese sauce on the broccoli adds $0.99.
Famous Pies And Desserts
You cannot talk about this place without mentioning the pie. The pies are baked fresh daily, and the cases usually run out by early evening on weekends. You can buy a whole pie to go, or grab a slice at the table.
Slice Prices
A single slice of pie is served warm if you request it. The standard slice is thick, about one-sixth of the whole pie.
- French Silk – $4.49
- Dutch Apple – $4.29
- Cherry Crumb – $4.29
- Lemon Meringue – $4.49
- Banana Cream – $4.49
- Pecan – $4.79
Add a scoop of vanilla ice cream for $1.49. Whipped cream is always free.
Whole Pie Prices
Buying a whole pie is cheaper per slice. You can order ahead for pickup, or grab one from the display case.
- Classic Fruit Pies (Apple, Cherry) – $14.99
- Cream Pies (Banana, Coconut) – $15.49
- Specialty Pies (French Silk, Key Lime) – $16.99
- Seasonal Pies (Pumpkin, Peach) – $13.99
Whole pies are not available for delivery through third-party apps. You have to order directly from the store.
Pie Shakes And Sundaes
If you want something different, the pie shakes blend a slice of pie with ice cream. They are thick enough to eat with a spoon.
- Pie Shake (Any Flavor) – $5.99
- Hot Fudge Sundae – $3.99
- Brownie Sundae – $5.49
- Ice Cream Scoop – $1.79
You can add caramel or hot fudge to any dessert for $0.79.
Kids Menu And Senior Discounts
Families get a good deal here. The kids menu is affordable, and seniors get a discount on most items before 4 PM.
Kids Meal Options
Kids meals come with a small drink, a side, and a treat. The treat is usually a cookie or a small scoop of ice cream.
- Chicken Tenders – $5.99
- Mac and Cheese – $4.99
- Mini Cheeseburger – $5.49
- Grilled Cheese – $4.79
- Spaghetti with Marinara – $5.29
Kids meals are available for children under 12. You cannot order them for adults, even if you ask nicely.
Senior Menu
The senior menu is available for guests 55 and older. Portions are slightly smaller, but the prices are noticeably lower.
- Senior Chicken Breast – $8.99
- Senior Fish and Chips – $9.49
- Senior Salad Plate – $7.99
- Senior Half Sandwich – $6.99
Senior meals include a beverage. Coffee refills are free for seniors.
Drinks And Beverages
Drinks are standard for a family restaurant. You get free refills on most soft drinks and coffee.
Non-Alcoholic Drinks
- Soft Drinks (Coke, Sprite, etc.) – $2.99
- Iced Tea – $2.99
- Lemonade – $3.29
- Coffee (Regular or Decaf) – $2.49
- Hot Tea – $2.29
- Milk (Chocolate or White) – $2.79
- Juice (Orange, Apple) – $2.99
Bottomless coffee is a good deal if you are staying to chat. You can get a carafe for the table for $5.99.
Alcoholic Beverages
Some locations have a full bar, but not all of them. Check with your local store to see if they serve alcohol.
- House Wine (Glass) – $5.49
- Domestic Beer – $4.29
- Imported Beer – $5.29
- Mimosa – $6.49
- Bloody Mary – $6.99
Happy hour runs from 3 PM to 6 PM on weekdays. Drinks are $1 off during that time.
Deals, Coupons, And Value Tips
You do not have to pay full price if you plan ahead. There are several ways to save money on your visit.
Current Promotions
The restaurant runs a few recurring deals throughout the week. These are not advertised heavily, so you have to ask.
- Tuesday Pie Slice Special – $2.99 with any entree
- Wednesday Senior Day – 10% off entire bill
- Friday Fish Fry – $10.99 all-you-can-eat
- Sunday Brunch Buffet – $12.99 (select locations)
Join the email list on their website to get a free slice of pie on your birthday. The coupon arrives about a week before your birthday.
How To Save More
If you are on a budget, skip the appetizers. The dinner salads are huge, and you can split one between two people.
- Order water instead of a soft drink to save $3.
- Ask for extra bread instead of buying an appetizer.
- Get the lunch portion instead of the dinner portion.
- Use the rewards app to earn points on every dollar.
- Check the local newspaper for paper coupons.
The rewards program gives you $5 off after you spend $50. It adds up quickly if you eat here often.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people ask about the pricing and menu options.
Does Baker’s Square Have A Gluten-free Menu?
They do not have a dedicated gluten-free menu, but they offer gluten-free buns and pasta. The pie crusts contain gluten, so avoid the pie if you are sensitive.
Are There Any Vegetarian Options On The Menu?
Yes, there are several vegetarian choices. The veggie omelet, house salad, and mac and cheese are all meat-free. You can also order the grilled cheese sandwich.
Can I Order A Whole Pie Online?
Yes, you can order whole pies online for pickup. The website allows you to select your local store and pay in advance. Delivery is not available for whole pies.
What Are The Hours For The Breakfast Menu?
Breakfast is served all day, every day. You can order pancakes at 9 PM if you want. The only exception is on holidays when hours may be reduced.
Is There A Military Discount?
Yes, most locations offer a 10% discount for active military and veterans. You need to show a valid military ID. The discount applies to the entire table.
Final Thoughts On Pricing
The prices at Baker’s Square are fair for the portion sizes. A dinner entree with a salad and a side will run you about $15. If you add a slice of pie and a drink, you are looking at around $22 per person.
That is not the cheapest meal in town, but the quality is consistent. The pies alone are worth the trip. If you are watching your wallet, stick to the lunch menu or the senior specials.
Remember that prices can vary slightly by location. Stores in higher-cost areas might charge $0.50 to $1.00 more for certain items. The menu we listed above reflects the average pricing across most locations in the Midwest.
Check the exact menu at your local store before you go. The online menu is usually up to date, but sometimes the printed menu at the table has different prices. Do not be afraid to ask your server for the current price of an item before you order.
Overall, you get decent value for your money. The service is usually friendly, and the food comes out fast. Just save room for the pie, because that is the real reason you are here.