New Yorkers line up early at Elaines Bagels for hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels that rival anything found in Manhattan. If you want to know what to order before you get to the counter, this guide to the Elaines Bagels Menu with Prices breaks down every section so you can plan your visit.
The shop keeps things simple. You pick a bagel, choose a spread, and add a sandwich if you are hungry. Prices stay fair for the quality you get.
Elaines Bagels Menu With Prices
Below is a full breakdown of the menu. Prices can shift slightly by location, so treat these as close estimates. Tax is not included.
Classic Bagels
Every bagel here is rolled by hand and boiled in a kettle before baking. That is the reason the crust snaps and the inside stays chewy.
- Plain Bagel — $1.75
- Sesame Bagel — $1.85
- Poppy Seed Bagel — $1.85
- Everything Bagel — $1.95
- Onion Bagel — $1.85
- Garlic Bagel — $1.85
- Whole Wheat Bagel — $1.95
- Cinnamon Raisin Bagel — $2.10
- Blueberry Bagel — $2.10
A baker’s dozen runs about $18.50. That works out cheaper then buying them one at a time.
Spreads And Schmears
You can add a spread to any bagel. The staff spreads it thick, so one bagel is a real meal.
- Plain Cream Cheese — $2.25
- Scallion Cream Cheese — $2.75
- Veggie Cream Cheese — $2.95
- Lox Cream Cheese — $4.50
- Peanut Butter — $2.00
- Butter — $1.25
- Jelly — $1.50
Breakfast Sandwiches
These come on any bagel you like. Ask for it toasted if you want extra crunch.
- Egg And Cheese — $5.50
- Bacon, Egg And Cheese — $7.25
- Sausage, Egg And Cheese — $7.25
- Ham, Egg And Cheese — $7.50
- Turkey Bacon, Egg And Cheese — $7.75
- Western Omelet Sandwich — $8.50
Bagel Sandwiches
Lunch runs from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. Each sandwich includes a pickle on the side.
- Classic Lox Sandwich — $13.95
- Whitefish Salad Sandwich — $11.50
- Tuna Salad Sandwich — $9.75
- Chicken Salad Sandwich — $9.75
- Egg Salad Sandwich — $8.95
- Turkey And Swiss — $10.50
- Roast Beef And Cheddar — $11.95
- BLT — $8.75
Drinks
Coffee is brewed fresh all day. Refills cost a dollar if you stay in the shop.
- Drip Coffee (Small) — $2.50
- Drip Coffee (Large) — $3.25
- Iced Coffee — $3.50
- Latte — $4.75
- Cappuccino — $4.50
- Hot Tea — $2.25
- Orange Juice — $3.75
- Bottled Water — $2.00
- Soda Can — $2.25
Sides And Extras
Small additions that round out a order.
- Hash Brown — $2.50
- Side Of Bacon — $4.00
- Side Of Sausage — $4.00
- Fruit Cup — $4.50
- Extra Cream Cheese — $1.00
How To Order And Save Money
A few small moves keep your total low without cutting quality.
- Buy the baker’s dozen if you have a family. It saves you around four dollars.
- Order a plain bagel with butter instead of a sandwich. It costs under three dollars.
- Skip the bottled drink and get a large drip coffee. Refills are cheap.
- Go before 8 a.m. The line moves faster and the first batch is still warm.
- Ask for the day old bagels. They sell them at half price after 4 p.m.
What Regulars Recommend
The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese is the top seller. The lox sandwich comes second.
If you like a sweeter start, try the cinnamon raisin with plain cream cheese. It taste like a pastry but fills you up like a meal.
First timers should get one classic bagel with butter. That way you taste the bagel itself, not the toppings. Then come back and build a bigger order.
Final Tips Before You Go
Cash and cards both work. There is a small fee on cards under five dollars.
Seating is limited, so most people take their order to go. Weekend mornings are the busiest time, with waits up to twenty minutes.
Prices listed here are current as of this year. Call your local shop to confirm before a big order. Now you can walk in knowing exactly what you want and what it will cost.