Elaines Sandwich Shop builds oversized deli sandwiches on fresh-baked bread, drawing lunch crowds from nearby offices daily. If you want to plan your meal before you arrive, this guide to the Elaines Sandwich Shop Menu with Prices covers the full lineup, typical costs, and smart ways to order.
The shop keeps things simple. You pick a sandwich, choose a bread, and add sides or a drink. Most people spend between $9 and $16 per person.
Elaines Sandwich Shop Menu With Prices
Prices vary a little by location, but the ranges below reflect what most customers pay. Tax is not included.
Classic Sandwiches
- Turkey Club – $10.50
- Roast Beef and Cheddar – $11.25
- Ham and Swiss – $9.75
- Tuna Salad – $9.50
- Egg Salad – $8.75
- BLT – $8.95
Signature Sandwiches
- Elaine’s Italian Sub – $12.50
- Pastrami on Rye – $13.25
- Chicken Parmesan Hero – $12.75
- Philly Cheesesteak – $13.50
- Veggie Supreme – $10.95
- The Big Elaine (double meat) – $15.75
Sides And Extras
- Bag of chips – $2.25
- Pickle spear – $1.50
- Potato salad – $3.75
- Coleslaw – $3.50
- Macaroni salad – $3.75
- Extra cheese – $1.00
- Extra meat – $3.00
Drinks And Desserts
- Fountain soda – $2.50
- Bottled water – $2.00
- Fresh lemonade – $3.25
- Iced tea – $2.75
- Chocolate chip cookie – $2.50
- Brownie – $3.00
Combo Deals
Combos save you money if you want more than a sandwich.
- Sandwich plus chips and a soda – add $4.25
- Half sandwich plus soup – $9.95
- Family platter (serves four) – $42.00
- Catering tray (serves ten) – $95.00
How To Order Without Overspending
You do not need to spend a lot to eat well here. A few small choices keep your total low.
- Order the half sandwich if you eat a light lunch. It costs about 60 percent of the full price.
- Skip the combo and bring your own drink. You save around $2.
- Split the Big Elaine with a friend. It is large enough for two.
- Check the daily special board. Specials often run $1 to $2 cheaper.
- Ask for a loyalty card. Most shops give a free sandwich after ten purchases.
Best Times To Visit
Lunch rush runs from noon to 1:30 PM on weekdays. Lines move fast, but seating fills up.
Go before 11:30 AM or after 2 PM for a shorter wait. Friday afternoons are the quietest.
What Regulars Usually Order
- The Italian Sub with hot peppers
- Pastrami on Rye with extra mustard
- Turkey Club with potato salad
- Philly Cheesesteak with a side of pickles
Payment, Catering, And Other Details
The shop takes cash, credit cards, and mobile wallets. Minimum card purchase is $5.
Catering orders need 24 hours notice. You can call ahead or order at the counter.
Prices went up slightly last year due to bread and meat costs. Expect small changes every few months, so check the board or call before a big order.
If you are watching your budget, stick to the classic sandwiches and skip the extras. If you want the full experience, the signature list is worth the few extra dollars. Either way, you will leave full.