New York Pizzeria Menu with Prices is something you likely want to check before you call for delivery. The menu is straightforward, but the price differences between a plain slice and a specialty square can surprise first-timers. New York Pizzeria prices its specialty pies above the standard cheese and pepperoni options, but the topping quality justifies the difference for regulars.
You do not need to guess what a large pie costs or how much extra garlic knots add to your total. This guide breaks down the full menu, item by item, with the current prices. We will cover slices, whole pies, appetizers, and drinks, so you can order with confidence.
New York Pizzeria Menu With Prices
The core menu at New York Pizzeria is built around classic round pies, but they also offer Sicilian squares and calzones. Prices here are for the main location on 5th Avenue. Delivery apps might charge a small markup, so call directly if you want the exact numbers below.
Below is the complete price list for the standard menu items. These are the prices as of this month, but they can change if supply costs go up.
Appetizers And Sides
You should start with something small if you are waiting for a pie. The appetizer list is short but covers the basics well.
- Garlic Knots (6 pieces) – $5.50
- Garlic Bread with Mozzarella – $7.25
- Bruschetta (4 pieces) – $8.00
- Chicken Wings (6 pieces) – $9.75
- Chicken Wings (12 pieces) – $17.50
- French Fries – $4.50
- Onion Rings – $5.75
- Mozzarella Sticks (8 pieces) – $8.50
The garlic knots come with a side of marinara sauce. You might want to ask for extra sauce because they give you just a small cup.
Salads
Salads are fresh and made to order. They are large enough to share, but most people get one for themselves.
- House Salad – $8.25
- Caesar Salad – $9.00
- Antipasto Salad – $11.50
- Chicken Caesar Salad – $11.75
- Greek Salad – $10.50
Add grilled chicken to any salad for an extra $3.00. Add shrimp for $4.50. The house salad is a simple mix of iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and black olives.
Specialty Slices
If you are eating at the counter, the slice menu is what you will look at. They keep a few specialty slices warm in the display case next to the regular cheese.
- Cheese Slice – $3.50
- Pepperoni Slice – $4.00
- Sicilian Slice – $4.50
- Margherita Slice – $4.75
- White Slice – $4.50
- BBQ Chicken Slice – $5.25
- Buffalo Chicken Slice – $5.25
The BBQ chicken slice is a fan favorite. It has a sweet sauce base and red onions. The buffalo slice is spicier, so be careful if you are sensitive to heat.
Whole Round Pies
This is the main event. Whole pies come in two sizes: Medium (14 inches) and Large (18 inches). The prices below are for cheese pies. Each topping adds a set amount.
- Medium Cheese Pie – $14.50
- Large Cheese Pie – $18.75
- Medium Sicilian (16×16) – $19.00
- Large Sicilian (18×18) – $22.50
Toppings for round pies are priced per pie, not per slice. A medium pie costs an extra $2.25 per topping. A large pie costs an extra $2.75 per topping.
Here is a list of available toppings:
- Pepperoni
- Sausage
- Meatballs
- Ham
- Bacon
- Chicken
- Mushrooms
- Onions
- Green Peppers
- Black Olives
- Jalapenos
- Fresh Garlic
- Extra Cheese
- Pineapple
- Anchovies
You can get a half-and-half pie for no extra charge. Just tell them what you want on each side. They do not charge for splitting the toppings.
Specialty Pies
New York Pizzeria prices its specialty pies higher than the build-your-own options. These pies come with pre-set topping combinations. They are popular because the portions are generous.
- The Brooklyn (Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions) – Medium $20.50 / Large $25.75
- The Manhattan (Fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil) – Medium $19.75 / Large $24.50
- The Bronx Bomber (Meatballs, pepperoni, ham, bacon) – Medium $22.00 / Large $27.25
- The Staten Island (Chicken, broccoli, alfredo sauce) – Medium $21.50 / Large $26.75
- The Queens (BBQ chicken, red onion, cilantro) – Medium $21.00 / Large $26.25
- The Veggie Supreme (Mushrooms, peppers, onions, olives, tomatoes) – Medium $20.00 / Large $25.00
The Manhattan pie is a classic margherita. It uses a thick slice of fresh mozzarella on top of the sauce. The crust is thinner than the regular round pie.
Calzones And Stromboli
These are folded pizzas, baked in the oven. They come with a side of marinara sauce for dipping. You can get them filled with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of meat or veggies.
- Cheese Calzone – $9.50
- Pepperoni Calzone – $10.75
- Meatball Calzone – $10.75
- Chicken Calzone – $11.25
- Veggie Calzone – $10.50
- Stromboli (Ham, salami, pepperoni) – $11.50
Calzones are big. One is enough for two people if you also order a salad or appetizer. They cut it in half for you if you ask.
Pasta Dishes
They offer a few pasta plates for those who want a break from pizza. The pasta is cooked to order, so it takes a few extra minutes.
- Spaghetti with Marinara – $9.75
- Spaghetti with Meatballs – $12.50
- Baked Ziti – $11.25
- Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti – $14.75
- Eggplant Parmigiana with Spaghetti – $13.50
- Penne alla Vodka – $12.00
The chicken parm is a large cutlet, breaded and fried, then covered in mozzarella. It comes with a full portion of spaghetti on the side. You will likely have leftovers.
Desserts
Dessert options are limited but satisfying. They are made by a local bakery, not in-house.
- Tiramisu – $6.50
- Cannoli (2 pieces) – $5.75
- Cheesecake Slice – $6.00
- Chocolate Cake Slice – $5.50
The cannoli are filled fresh when you order. The shell stays crispy because they do not fill them ahead of time.
Beverages
Drink prices are standard for the area. They have a soda fountain with self-serve cups.
- Can Soda – $1.75
- 20oz Bottle Soda – $2.50
- 2-Liter Bottle – $4.00
- Bottled Water – $1.50
- Snapple or Iced Tea – $2.75
They also have a small selection of beer in the cooler. Domestic bottles are $4.50. Imported bottles are $5.50. You need to show ID even if you look old enough.
Deals And Combos
If you want to save money, look for the combo deals. They are not printed on the main menu, but the cashier will honor them if you ask.
- Lunch Special (2 slices + can soda) – $8.95 (valid until 3 PM)
- Dinner Combo (Large cheese pie + 12 wings) – $27.99
- Family Deal (2 large pies with 2 toppings each + 2-liter soda) – $39.99
- Party Tray (24 garlic knots + 2 large salads) – $24.99
The lunch special is the best value. You get two slices of cheese or pepperoni. You can upgrade to a specialty slice for an extra $1.00.
For the family deal, you can choose any two toppings per pie. They do not allow you to get a specialty pie in this combo. You have to stick with the regular build-your-own options.
Delivery And Pickup
Delivery is available within a three-mile radius. The delivery fee is $2.50. There is a minimum order of $15.00 for delivery.
Pickup is usually faster. You can call ahead and they will have your order ready in about 15 to 20 minutes for a pie. Slices are ready immediately if you order them at the counter.
They do not have a online ordering system on their own website. You have to use third-party apps if you want to order digitally. Those apps will show higher prices to cover their fees.
Payment Methods
They accept cash, all major credit cards, and contactless payments like Apple Pay. They do not accept personal checks. The card machine will ask for a tip, even for pickup orders. You can skip that if you want.
There is no ATM inside the store. If you want to pay cash, bring it with you. The nearest ATM is across the street at the gas station.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions about the menu and pricing. These should help you avoid confusion when you order.
Does New York Pizzeria charge for extra sauce or dip?
Yes. Extra marinara sauce cups cost $0.75 each. Ranch or blue cheese dressing cups are $0.85 each. They give you one free sauce cup with calzones and garlic knots.
Are the prices on the delivery app the same as the in-store menu?
No. The delivery apps add about 15 to 20 percent to each item. The restaurant sets lower prices for in-store and phone orders. You will save money by calling directly for pickup.
Can I buy just one slice of a specialty pie?
Yes, if they have that slice available in the display case. They only make a few specialty pies at a time. If they are out, you have to order a whole pie and wait.
Is there a gluten-free crust option?
Yes. They offer a gluten-free crust for an additional $3.00 on any round pie. It is only available in a small 10-inch size. The gluten-free crust costs $12.00 for a cheese pie.
Do they offer a student discount?
Yes, if you show a valid student ID at the counter. You get 10 percent off your total order. This discount does not apply to delivery orders.
Tips For Ordering
To get the best experience, order during off-peak hours. Lunch rush is from 12 PM to 1:30 PM. Dinner rush starts around 6 PM. If you call in during these times, the phone might ring for a while.
If you want your pie well-done, ask for it at the counter. They will leave it in the oven an extra two minutes. This makes the bottom crust crispier. There is no extra charge for this.
Check your order before you leave the store. They occasionally mix up toppings, especially during busy hours. It is easier to fix a mistake at the counter than after you drive home.
The menu is simple, but the prices add up fast if you add many toppings. A large pie with three toppings will cost you around $27.00. That is still cheaper than ordering two separate medium pies.
If you are feeding a crowd, the family deal is the smart choice. You get more food for less money compared to ordering items separately. The two-liter soda is a nice bonus, even if it is just a generic brand.
Remember that New York Pizzeria prices its specialty pies higher for a reason. The ingredients are fresher and the portions are bigger. If you are on a tight budget, stick with the regular cheese pie and add one or two toppings. You will still get a good meal without overspending.
Now you have the full picture. You know what each item costs, which deals are worth it, and how to avoid extra fees. The next time you are hungry for a slice, you can order without hesitation. Just bring cash if you want to skip the card fee, and call ahead for pickup to save the delivery charge.
One last note: the prices listed here are accurate for the current menu, but they do change a few times a year. If you are planning a large order, call them first to confirm the total. That way, there are no surprises when you pick up your food. Enjoy your pizza.