Margarita’s Pizza menu with prices offer a taste of traditional recipes that prioritize flavor over frills. You get classic pies, hearty pastas, and fresh salads without the pretense. The menu is straightforward, making it easy for you to decide what to order for your next family dinner or casual night in.
This guide breaks down the full menu, item by item. You will find the exact costs for pizzas, appetizers, and desserts. We also point out the best value deals and share tips on how to order smart.
Appetizers And Starters
Before you get to the main event, you might want a light bite. The appetizer list is short but covers the basics well. These are great for sharing, but they are also filling enough to be a meal for one.
Garlic Bread And Cheese Sticks
The garlic bread here is a solid choice. It is baked fresh and brushed with a generous amount of garlic butter. You can get it plain or loaded with mozzarella.
- Garlic Bread (4 pieces) – $5.25
- Garlic Bread with Cheese (4 pieces) – $7.50
- Mozzarella Cheese Sticks (8 pieces) – $8.95
Each order comes with a side of marinara sauce. The sauce is tangy and helps cut through the richness of the cheese.
Wings And Fried Bites
If you like something with a bit of a kick, the wings are a good pick. They offer mild, medium, hot, and BBQ sauces. The fried mushrooms and calamari are also popular among regulars.
- Chicken Wings (10 pieces) – $10.99
- Fried Mushrooms – $7.25
- Calamari – $11.50
- French Fries – $4.25
Margarita’s Pizza Menu With Prices
This is the section you came for. The pizza menu is the heart of the operation. They use a thin crust that stays crispy even with a lot of toppings. The cheese is a blend of mozzarella and provolone, which gives a nice stretch.
Classic Cheese And Tomato Pies
The simplest options are often the best test of a pizzeria. The plain cheese pie is well balanced, not too greasy. You can order a tomato pie if you want a lighter option without cheese.
- Small Cheese Pizza (10″) – $10.75
- Medium Cheese Pizza (12″) – $13.50
- Large Cheese Pizza (16″) – $17.25
- Extra Large Cheese Pizza (18″) – $20.00
- Tomato Pie (Medium) – $11.95
Specialty Pizzas
These are pre-designed combinations that work well together. The “Margarita” pie is actually different from the restaurant name. It features fresh basil, sliced tomatoes, and a drizzle of olive oil. The Meat Lovers is heavy on the protein and very filling.
- Margherita Pizza (Medium) – $14.95
- Pepperoni Pizza (Large) – $18.75
- Supreme Pizza (Large) – $21.50
- Meat Lovers Pizza (Large) – $23.25
- BBQ Chicken Pizza (Large) – $20.95
- Veggie Pizza (Large) – $19.50
You can also build your own pizza. The base price includes the sauce and cheese. Then you add toppings for a small fee.
Build Your Own Toppings
Choosing your own toppings gives you control. Each topping is added to the base price of the pizza size you pick.
- Vegetables (onions, peppers, mushrooms, olives) – $1.50 each
- Premium Veggies (sun-dried tomatoes, artichokes) – $2.25 each
- Standard Meats (pepperoni, sausage, ham) – $2.00 each
- Premium Meats (chicken, bacon, meatball) – $2.75 each
- Extra Cheese – $2.50
A large pizza with three toppings will run you about $23.00. That is a reasonable price for the amount of food you get. You can easily feed three or four people with one large pie.
Oven-Baked Pastas
If you are not in the mood for pizza, the pasta dishes are hearty and hot. They are baked in the same oven as the pizza, which gives the cheese a nice golden crust on top. Each dish comes with a small side salad or a piece of garlic bread.
Baked Classics
These are comfort food staples. The lasagna is layered well and does not fall apart when you cut into it. The baked ziti is simple but satisfying.
- Baked Lasagna – $13.95
- Baked Ziti – $11.75
- Stuffed Shells (4 pieces) – $12.50
- Chicken Parmigiana – $14.95
- Eggplant Parmigiana – $13.25
Spaghetti And Traditional Dishes
These are served with your choice of marinara, meat sauce, or Alfredo. The portions are generous, so you might have leftovers for lunch tomorrow.
- Spaghetti with Meatballs – $12.95
- Spaghetti with Sausage – $12.95
- Fettuccine Alfredo – $11.50
- Penne alla Vodka – $12.25
- Rigatoni with Broccoli – $12.75
You can add grilled chicken to any pasta for an extra $3.00. Shrimp is also available for an additional $4.50.
Fresh Salads And Sides
Salads are a good way to balance out a heavy meal. The ingredients are fresh and the dressings are house-made. You can order a salad as a side or as a full meal.
House And Caesar Salads
The Caesar salad is tossed in a creamy dressing with real parmesan. The house salad comes with a mix of greens, tomatoes, onions, and peppers. You can get them small or large.
- Small House Salad – $5.50
- Large House Salad – $8.95
- Small Caesar Salad – $6.25
- Large Caesar Salad – $9.75
Specialty Salads
These are more substantial and include proteins. The antipasto salad is loaded with cured meats and cheeses. The chicken salad is a lighter option with grilled chicken on top.
- Antipasto Salad – $11.95
- Grilled Chicken Salad – $10.50
- Buffalo Chicken Salad – $11.25
- Greek Salad – $10.95
Desserts And Sweet Treats
After a savory meal, you might want something sweet. The dessert menu is not huge, but the items are made in-house. The cannoli is crisp and filled to order, so the shell stays crunchy.
Dessert Options
- Cannoli (1 piece) – $4.50
- Tiramisu – $6.25
- Cheesecake (plain or strawberry) – $5.95
- Chocolate Lava Cake – $6.75
- New York Style Cheesecake – $5.95
The lava cake takes about ten minutes to bake. If you are in a hurry, the tiramisu is already chilled and ready to serve.
Drinks And Beverages
You need something to wash down all that food. They offer the standard soda fountain options. They also have some bottled drinks and Italian sodas.
Beverage List
- Canned Soda (Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite) – $2.25
- Bottled Water – $2.00
- Italian Soda (various flavors) – $3.50
- Iced Tea (freshly brewed) – $2.75
- Perrier or San Pellegrino – $3.00
Deals And Combos
If you are feeding a group, the combos are the way to go. They offer better value than ordering items separately. You can save a few dollars and get a complete meal.
Family Meal Deals
These are designed for takeout. They come in a large box and are easy to transport. The “Family Feast” is the most popular option for parties.
- One Large Pizza (2 toppings) + 8 Wings – $27.99
- One Large Pizza + Large Salad + Garlic Bread – $29.99
- Family Feast (2 Large Pizzas + 12 Wings + 2-Liter Soda) – $42.99
- Pasta Combo (1 Large Pizza + 1 Baked Pasta) – $26.99
Lunch Specials
If you visit between 11:00 AM and 2:00 PM on weekdays, you can get a smaller portion for less money. These are served with a drink.
- Two Slices of Cheese Pizza + Drink – $7.99
- One Slice + Small Salad + Drink – $8.99
- Small Baked Ziti + Drink – $8.50
- Personal Pan Pizza (2 toppings) + Drink – $9.25
Gluten-Free And Dietary Options
They do offer a gluten-free crust for an extra charge. The crust is a bit denser than the regular one, but it holds up well. They also have vegan cheese available if you ask for it.
- Gluten-Free Crust (any size) – +$3.00
- Vegan Cheese Substitute – +$2.50
- Gluten-Free Pasta – +$2.00
Note that the kitchen is not a dedicated gluten-free facility. There is a risk of cross-contamination. If you have a severe allergy, you should call ahead and talk to the manager.
Prices And Value Comparison
When you compare Margarita’s prices to other local pizzerias, they sit right in the middle. You are not paying premium prices, but you are also not getting the cheapest slice in town. The value comes from the quality of the ingredients and the size of the portions.
A large cheese pizza at a chain restaurant might cost $15.00. Here, you pay $17.25. However, the pizza here is heavier and uses more cheese. You get what you pay for in terms of satiety.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Margarita’s Pizza Offer Delivery?
Yes, they offer local delivery within a 5-mile radius. The delivery fee is $2.99. You can also order through third-party apps like DoorDash or UberEats, but the prices might be slightly higher on those platforms.
Are There Any Coupons For Margarita’s Pizza?
You can find coupons in local mailers and on their social media pages. They often run a “Tuesday Special” where you get 10% off any large pizza. Signing up for their email list also gives you a one-time discount on your first order.
What Is The Most Popular Pizza On The Menu?
The classic Pepperoni is the best seller. However, the Margherita pizza is a close second. Regulars also love the Supreme because it has a bit of everything.
Can I Order A Half-and-half Pizza?
Yes, you can get different toppings on each half for no extra charge. If you want two completely different specialty pizzas on one base, you will be charged the price of the higher-priced specialty.
Is There A Minimum Order For Delivery?
Yes, there is a $15.00 minimum for delivery orders. This is standard for most pizzerias. If your order is under that amount, you will need to pick it up yourself.
Final Thoughts On Ordering
You now have the full picture of the menu and costs. The key takeaway is that the large pizzas offer the best value per square inch. If you are eating alone, go for the lunch special or a small pie.
Do not forget to check the specials board when you walk in. Sometimes they have a seasonal pizza that is not on the printed menu. The staff is usually happy to tell you what is new.
Ordering is simple. You can call ahead for pickup, which is often faster than waiting at the counter. The food is prepared quickly, usually within 15 to 20 minutes for a large pizza.
One thing to note is that the prices listed here are accurate as of this writing. However, like any restaurant, they can change. It is always a good idea to confirm the price when you place your order, especially if you are on a strict budget.
The menu is designed to be accessible. You won’t find any overly complicated dishes or exotic ingredients. It is honest, filling food that hits the spot. Whether you are grabbing a quick slice or feeding a crowd, you can do it without breaking the bank.
So next time you are thinking about pizza, keep this guide handy. You will know exactly what to expect and what it will cost. That makes the whole experience less stressful and more enjoyable. Go ahead and call in your order, you will not be disappointed with the outcome.