Deli counters are rarely this expansive, yet TooJay’s Gourmet Deli prices reflect a menu that spans from classic corned beef to Reuben variations. If you are looking for a full breakdown of the **Toojay’s Gourmet Deli Menu with Prices**, you have come to the right spot. This guide covers the most popular items, what you can expect to pay, and how to get the best value for your meal.
TooJay’s has been a Florida staple since 1981. They are known for their hand-cut meats, fresh baked goods, and huge portions. But menus change, and prices vary by location. So, let’s get into the specifics of what you will see when you sit down or order online.
Toojay’s Gourmet Deli Menu With Prices
Before we break down the categories, you should know that this is a mid-to-upper scale deli. You are not paying fast-food prices here. However, the quality of the ingredients and the size of the sandwiches usually justify the cost. Most locations also offer a “Daily Special” which is the best way to save a few bucks.
Below is a general price guide based on recent menu data. Remember that prices can shift slightly depending on the state or city you are in (Florida vs. New York).
Hot And Cold Sandwiches
This is the heart of the menu. The sandwiches are stacked high with meat. You can usually order a half or a whole. A whole sandwich is massive and can easily feed two people if you are not a big eater.
- Classic Corned Beef Sandwich – $16.99 (Whole)
- Pastrami On Rye – $17.49 (Whole)
- Turkey Breast And Swiss – $15.99 (Whole)
- The Reuben (Corned Beef) – $17.99 (Whole)
- The Rachel (Turkey Pastrami) – $17.49 (Whole)
- Tuna Salad Sandwich – $14.99 (Whole)
- Egg Salad Sandwich – $13.49 (Whole)
- Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich – $15.49 (Whole)
Most sandwiches come with a pickle spear and coleslaw. You will need to ask for extra dressing if you want it on the side. They are not shy with the Russian dressing on the Reuben, though.
Build Your Own Deli Platter
If you are eating low carb or just want the meat without the bread, this is a solid option. You can pick two or three meats. The platter comes with a choice of two sides.
- Two Meat Platter – $18.99
- Three Meat Platter – $22.49
- Add A Bagel Or Rye Toast – $1.50
This is a good deal if you are sharing. The platter is arranged nicely on a bed of lettuce. You get a lot of protein for the price.
Breakfast All Day
TooJay’s serves breakfast until closing time. That is a big plus if you wake up late. The omelets are fluffy and come with potatoes or grits and a bagel or toast.
- Classic Two Egg Breakfast – $11.99
- Lox And Bagel Platter – $18.99
- Western Omelet – $14.99
- Vegetarian Omelet – $13.99
- Nova Scotia Salmon Omelet – $17.49
The Lox platter is expensive, but they give you a generous portion of fish. It comes with cream cheese, tomatoes, red onion, and a big, chewy bagel. If you like capers, you have to ask for them specifically.
Salads And Soups
You do not have to eat a sandwich to enjoy TooJay’s. The salads are fresh and crisp. The soup of the day is always a good bet, especially the chicken noodle or matzo ball.
- Chef Salad – $16.99
- Cobb Salad – $17.49
- Caesar Salad With Chicken – $15.99
- Cup Of Soup – $5.49
- Bowl Of Soup – $7.99
- Matzo Ball Soup (Bowl) – $8.99
You can get a “Soup And Half Sandwich” combo for around $13.99. This is probably the most economical choice on the menu if you are moderately hungry. It comes with a cup of soup, not a bowl, so keep that in mind.
Burgers And Melts
They have a few options for those who want a hot, greasy meal. The patty melt is a standout. The burgers are cooked to order and are fairly juicy.
- Classic Patty Melt – $15.99
- TooJay’s Burger – $16.49
- Turkey Burger – $15.49
- Grilled Cheese With Tomato – $10.99
The grilled cheese is simple, but it uses good bread. If you are dining with a picky kid, this is a safe bet. The burgers come with lettuce, tomato, and onion on the side.
Sides And Extras
Portions are big, but sometimes you need a little extra. Here is what you can expect to pay for sides.
- Hand-Cut Fries – $4.99
- Sweet Potato Fries – $5.49
- Potato Salad – $4.49
- Coleslaw – $3.99
- Mac And Cheese – $5.99
- Pickle Spear – $1.29
The fries are crispy and seasoned well. The mac and cheese is creamy, but it is not gourmet. It tastes like a high-quality homestyle version.
Desserts And Bakery
You cannot leave TooJay’s without looking at the dessert case. The cakes are enormous. The slices are thick and rich. They also have a full bakery counter where you can buy whole pies and cakes to take home.
- Slice Of Layer Cake – $7.99
- Whole Layer Cake – $45.00 – $55.00
- Cheesecake Slice – $6.99
- Cookies (Each) – $2.49
- Rugelach (Per Piece) – $1.99
- Bagels (Sold By The Dozen) – $14.99
The carrot cake is famous. It has a thick, sweet cream cheese frosting. If you are celebrating a birthday, you can order a custom cake ahead of time. They do a great job with the writing on top.
Beverages
Drinks are standard deli pricing. You can get a bottomless soft drink or a fresh squeezed juice.
- Soft Drinks (Bottomless) – $3.49
- Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice – $5.99
- Iced Tea (Bottomless) – $3.49
- Cel-Ray Soda – $3.99
- Coffee Or Hot Tea – $3.29
The Cel-Ray soda is a nod to the classic New York delis. It is an acquired taste. If you have never tried it, order one just to see what the fuss is about. It tastes like celery and sugar.
Kids Menu
If you have little ones, the kids menu is reasonably priced. It comes with a drink and a side.
- Grilled Cheese – $7.99
- Chicken Tenders – $8.99
- Mini Hot Dog – $7.49
- Spaghetti With Butter Or Sauce – $7.99
Kids meals are served on a plastic plate with a cup that has a lid. It is practical and easy for parents. The portions are just right for children under 10.
Daily Specials And Combos
This is where you save money. TooJay’s runs a different special every day of the week. These are usually advertised on their website or on a board at the entrance.
- Monday: Meatloaf Platter with soup or salad.
- Tuesday: Roast Turkey Dinner.
- Wednesday: Pot Roast Special.
- Thursday: Stuffed Cabbage.
- Friday: Fish And Chips.
These specials usually run between $13.99 and $15.99. They come with a side and a piece of bread. It is the best way to try something new without breaking the bank.
How To Order Online
Ordering online is easy. You can go to their website or use a third-party app like DoorDash or Uber Eats. Be aware that third-party apps inflate the prices by about 15-20%. If you want the exact menu prices, order directly from the TooJay’s website for pickup.
When you order for pickup, you can skip the line. The food is usually packed well. They put the dressing on the side for salads automatically, which is a nice touch.
Tips For Getting The Best Value
Here are a few practical tips to make sure you get the most for your money.
- Share a whole sandwich. They are huge.
- Ask for the “Senior Menu” if you are over 55. They offer smaller portions at lower prices.
- Join the “Toast To Jay” rewards program. You earn points for every dollar spent.
- Check the “Heat And Eat” section near the register. They sell take-home meals that are cheaper than dining in.
- Get the soup and half sandwich combo instead of a full meal.
Also, do not forget to grab a free pickle from the barrel if you are dining in. It is located near the cash register in most locations.
Are There Any Hidden Fees?
When you dine in, there are no hidden fees. When you order delivery, there is a service fee and a delivery fee. The prices on the app are also higher. For example, a $16.99 sandwich might show up as $18.99 on the delivery app. This is standard practice for most restaurants now.
If you are on a strict budget, always choose pickup. It saves you the delivery fee and the inflated menu prices.
Is The Quality Worth The Price?
In our opinion, yes. The meat is carved fresh in the store. They do not use pre-packaged, low-quality deli meat. The bread is baked daily. The pickles are crisp and garlicky. You are paying for quality ingredients and generous portions.
However, if you are just looking for a cheap quick lunch, this is not the place. You can get a sub for $6 at a fast-food joint. TooJay’s is for when you want a real, satisfying meal that tastes homemade.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does TooJay’s offer a senior discount?
Yes, they offer a special menu for seniors (usually 55 and older). It features smaller portions of popular items like the turkey sandwich and the meatloaf. The prices are significantly lower than the regular menu. You have to ask for this menu specifically, as it is not always on the main table tent.
Are there any gluten-free options on the menu?
Yes, you can get most sandwiches as a lettuce wrap or on gluten-free bread for an extra charge. The salads are also a good option. However, the matzo ball soup is not gluten-free. You should inform your server of any allergies so they can alert the kitchen.
What is the most popular item to order?
The Corned Beef Reuben is the most famous item. It is piled high with tender corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing on grilled rye bread. The Pastrami sandwich is a close second. If you are a first-timer, you should try the Reuben.
Can I buy just the meats by the pound?
Yes, TooJay’s has a deli counter where you can order meats and cheeses by the pound. You can also buy their coleslaw, potato salad, and mac and cheese by the quart. This is great for parties or for making sandwiches at home. The prices are comparable to a high-end grocery store.
Do they have a happy hour?
Most locations have a happy hour at the bar area. It usually runs from 3 PM to 6 PM on weekdays. They offer discounted drinks and half-priced appetizers. It is a good way to try their wings or potato skins without spending too much.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
TooJay’s is a reliable spot for a hearty meal. The menu is extensive, and the staff is usually friendly and efficient. While the prices are not cheap, the experience is consistent. You know you are going to get a good meal with fast service.
We recommend going for the daily special if you are a regular. If it is your first time, splurge on the Reuben and a slice of cake. You will not be disappointed. Just be prepared to take a doggy bag home, because you will not finish everything.
Remember that prices are subject to change. Always check the official TooJay’s website or your local store for the most current pricing. The menu we provided here is a solid baseline for budgeting your meal. Enjoy your visit and make sure to save room for dessert.