Cookies arrive warm, but the price list tells a different story than the box. If you are looking at the Tiff’s Treats Menu with Prices for the first time, you might expect a simple cookie line. The truth is, this brand has a full range of treats, bundles, and delivery options that change the final total. Let us break down the real costs so you know exactly what to pay before you hit “checkout.”
How The Tiff’s Treats Pricing System Works
Before you order, you need to understand that this is not a bakery where you buy one cookie. Tiff’s Treats focuses on boxes and dozens. You will almost always see a “per dozen” price, but you can mix flavors in many cases.
Here is the basic structure:
- You pick a treat type (cookie, brownie, or a mix)
- You choose a size (usually 6, 12, or 24 count)
- You add a “bake time” for delivery or pickup
Prices vary by location. A store in Texas might charge a different rate than one in Georgia. The menu below reflects standard averages, but you should confirm your local store price during checkout.
Tiff’s Treats Menu With Prices
This is the core section you came for. We have listed the standard cookie menu, the brownie options, and the specialty boxes. Remember, these prices are for the base menu without delivery fees or tax.
Classic Cookie Flavors And Costs
The classic cookies are the backbone of the brand. They bake these fresh and deliver them warm. Here are the standard flavors you will see on the menu.
- Chocolate Chip – $14.95 per dozen
- Snickerdoodle – $14.95 per dozen
- Oatmeal Raisin – $14.95 per dozen
- Peanut Butter – $14.95 per dozen
- Double Fudge – $15.95 per dozen
- Sugar – $14.95 per dozen
- White Chocolate Macadamia – $15.95 per dozen
You can usually order a half dozen (6 cookies) for about half the price. However, the per-cookie cost is slightly higher on smaller orders. A half dozen typically runs $8.50 to $9.50 depending on the flavor.
Specialty And Seasonal Cookie Prices
These rotate throughout the year. You might see flavors like Birthday Cake, Red Velvet, or Pumpkin Spice during specific months.
Specialty cookies usually cost a bit more:
- Specialty flavors – $16.95 to $17.95 per dozen
- Seasonal limited batches – $17.95 per dozen
- Gluten-free options – $18.95 per dozen (when available)
If you want a mix of classic and specialty, you can build a custom dozen. The system will charge you based on the highest-priced cookie in the box. That is an important detail to remember.
Brownie Menu And Pricing
They are not just about cookies. The brownies are fudgy and come in a few styles.
- Chocolate Brownie – $16.95 per dozen
- Walnut Brownie – $17.95 per dozen
- Gluten-Free Brownie – $19.95 per dozen
Brownies are typically sold in the same box sizes as cookies. You can mix brownies and cookies in one box, but the price calculation uses the higher priced item for the entire box.
Cookie And Brownie Combo Boxes
If you cannot decide, the combo box is a smart move. You get half cookies and half brownies.
- Combo Dozen (6 cookies + 6 brownies) – $16.95
- Combo 24 Count (12 + 12) – $32.95
- Combo 48 Count (24 + 24) – $62.95
These combo boxes are popular for office deliveries. They give everyone a choice without forcing you to buy two separate boxes.
Bundles, Gifts, And Party Packs
Beyond the basic dozens, Tiff’s Treats sells larger bundles for events. These are not on the regular menu board, but they are available online or through customer service.
Cookie Cake And Large Format Options
You can order a giant cookie cake instead of individual cookies.
- 8-inch Cookie Cake – $24.95
- 10-inch Cookie Cake – $34.95
- 12-inch Cookie Cake – $44.95
These come with a standard message written in frosting. You can add custom decorations for an extra $3 to $5.
Corporate And Office Gift Boxes
If you are sending to a business, look for the branded gift boxes. These include a nicer presentation and sometimes a card.
- Small Gift Box (6 treats) – $12.95
- Medium Gift Box (12 treats) – $22.95
- Large Gift Box (24 treats) – $42.95
These boxes are sealed with a ribbon. They cost a little more than the standard paper boxes because of the packaging.
Ice Cream And Cookie Sandwiches
Some locations offer ice cream scoops to pair with your warm cookies. This is a newer addition to the menu.
- Vanilla Ice Cream Pint – $6.95
- Chocolate Ice Cream Pint – $6.95
- Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich – $8.95
Not every store carries ice cream. You should check your local menu online before you get your hopes up.
Delivery Fees And Minimum Order Rules
The menu prices are only half the story. Delivery fees can add a significant amount to your total. Tiff’s Treats uses a zone-based delivery system.
Here is what you need to know:
- Delivery radius varies by store location
- Fees range from $4.99 to $14.99 based on distance
- There is often a minimum order for delivery (usually $15 to $20)
- You can schedule delivery for a specific time slot
If you want to avoid the fee, you can choose curbside pickup. Pickup orders are usually ready within 20 to 30 minutes. You do not pay a service fee for pickup.
How To Calculate Your Final Total
Follow these steps to know your final cost before you order:
- Pick your treat type and flavor
- Select the quantity (dozen, half dozen, etc.)
- Enter your zip code to see if delivery is available
- Review the delivery fee for your zone
- Add estimated tax (usually 6% to 8% depending on state)
For example, a dozen classic chocolate chip cookies at $14.95 plus a $6.99 delivery fee and $1.20 tax equals roughly $23.14. That is significantly more than the base menu price.
Tips For Saving Money On Your Order
You do not have to pay full price every time. There are several ways to reduce the cost of your warm cookie delivery.
Sign Up For Text Alerts
The brand frequently sends out promo codes for free delivery or percentage discounts. If you sign up for their text list, you will often get a welcome offer for 20% off your first order.
Check The “Deals” Page On Their Website
Sometimes they run seasonal promotions. You might find a “Buy One Get One Half Off” deal on brownies or a free cookie with a large order.
Order During Off-Peak Hours
Delivery fees tend to be lower during the middle of the day. Evening delivery slots on weekends often have surge pricing. If you can wait until a weekday afternoon, you will save a few dollars.
Comparing Prices To Other Cookie Delivery Services
You might wonder if Tiff’s Treats is expensive compared to competitors. Let us look at the average market rate.
- Insomnia Cookies: $12 to $16 per dozen (cold, not warm)
- Local bakeries: $18 to $25 per dozen (premium)
- Grocery store bakery: $8 to $12 per dozen (not delivered)
Tiff’s Treats sits in the middle. You are paying a premium for the warm delivery experience. The cookies themselves are not overpriced, but the convenience fee is real.
What About The “Warm” Factor?
One thing that sets this menu apart is the baking schedule. You cannot just order a cookie and have it sit on a shelf. The system asks you when you want the treats to arrive. They bake them so they are warm at that exact moment.
This means you cannot order “now” for immediate pickup in most cases. You need to allow at least 15 to 20 minutes of baking time. For delivery, you need to schedule at least 45 minutes in advance.
Does Warm Delivery Affect The Price?
No. The base cookie price is the same whether you pick it up cold or have it delivered warm. The only difference is the delivery fee. There is no “warm surcharge” on the menu.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are the most common questions people ask about the pricing and menu.
Can I mix cookie flavors in one dozen?
Yes, you can mix flavors freely. The system charges the highest price per dozen if you include specialty items. If you stick to classic flavors only, the price stays at the standard rate.
Is there a minimum order for delivery?
Most locations require a minimum of $15 before tax and fees. If you only want a half dozen, you might need to add a drink or extra cookies to meet the threshold.
Do prices include tax?
No. The menu prices are pre-tax. You will see tax added at checkout based on your local sales tax rate.
Can I order a single cookie?
No. The smallest order is typically a half dozen (6 cookies). You cannot buy just one or two cookies from the standard menu.
Are there any discounts for large corporate orders?
Yes, if you order over 100 cookies, you can contact customer service for a bulk rate. The online menu does not show these prices, so you have to ask.
Final Thoughts On The Price List
You now have a clear picture of the Tiff’s Treats Menu with Prices. The base cost for a dozen cookies is fair, but you must factor in delivery and tax. If you are on a budget, stick to classic flavors and choose pickup. If you want the full experience, budget an extra $10 to $15 for delivery and fees.
Remember that prices can shift slightly between locations. A store in a high-rent urban area might charge $1 to $2 more per dozen than a suburban location. Always check your local store page for the exact numbers.
Ordering warm cookies is a nice treat. Now you know exactly what it will cost you before you click that order button. Go ahead and plan your next delivery with confidence, knowing you are not going to be surprised at the register.