When a neighborhood pizzeria has been around for generations, you want to know exactly what your dollar buys—Rey’s has the answers. This guide breaks down the Rey’s Pizza menu with prices so you can order with confidence, whether you are a first-timer or a regular looking for the current cost of your favorite pie.
We have done the legwork to give you a clear picture of what to expect when you walk in or call ahead. You will find the classic offerings, the specialty pies, and the sides that make this spot a local favorite.
Rey’s Pizza Menu With Prices
Rey’s keeps things straightforward, focusing on quality ingredients and generous portions. The menu is not overly complicated, but it covers all the bases you would expect from a traditional pizzeria that has survived the test of time.
Below, we break down the pricing structure by category. Remember that prices can shift slightly based on current supply costs, but this gives you a reliable baseline for your next visit.
Classic Cheese And Tomato Pies
The foundation of any great pizza place is the basic cheese pie. Rey’s does this right, with a slightly crispy crust and a tangy tomato sauce that has a hint of sweetness.
- Small Cheese Pizza (12″) – $12.50
- Medium Cheese Pizza (16″) – $16.75
- Large Cheese Pizza (18″) – $19.95
- Extra Cheese (Any Size) – +$2.50
- Gluten-Free Crust (Small Only) – +$4.00
You can also order by the slice during lunch hours. A single slice of cheese runs you about $3.25, which is a solid deal for a quick bite.
Specialty Pizzas
If you want something beyond the standard pepperoni, Rey’s has a lineup of house specialties. These are their best-sellers and come in medium and large sizes only.
- The Rey’s Special – Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions. Medium: $21.50 / Large: $25.75
- BBQ Chicken – Grilled chicken, red onions, and a smoky BBQ base. Medium: $22.00 / Large: $26.25
- White Pizza – Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, and spinach. Medium: $20.50 / Large: $24.50
- Meat Lovers – Pepperoni, ham, bacon, sausage, and ground beef. Medium: $23.00 / Large: $27.50
- Veggie Delight – Broccoli, tomatoes, black olives, and artichoke hearts. Medium: $20.00 / Large: $24.00
These specialty pies are loaded. Do not expect a light topping of ingredients; Rey’s is known for being generous with the portions.
Build Your Own Pizza
For those who like control, the build-your-own option is the way to go. You start with a cheese pizza and add from a list of fresh toppings.
Here is the current pricing for additional toppings:
- Standard Toppings (Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, olives, tomatoes) – $1.75 each
- Premium Toppings (Chicken, bacon, ham, anchovies, artichokes) – $2.50 each
Most people add between two and four toppings. A large pizza with three standard toppings will land you around $25.00, which feeds three to four hungry adults.
Appetizers And Sides
You cannot go wrong with some starters to share. Rey’s offers the usual suspects, all priced to be affordable for families.
- Garlic Knots (8 pieces) – $6.50
- Mozzarella Sticks (8 pieces) – $8.75
- Chicken Wings (10 pieces) – $11.95 (Choose mild, hot, or BBQ)
- Garlic Bread with Cheese – $7.25
- Side Salad – $5.50
- House Salad – $8.95 (Includes grilled chicken if you want it)
The garlic knots are a fan favorite. They come with a side of their house marinara that is perfect for dipping.
Calzones And Stromboli
If you are in the mood for a folded option, Rey’s makes a mean calzone. They are stuffed full and baked until golden brown.
- Cheese Calzone – $10.50
- Pepperoni Calzone – $12.00
- Meatball Calzone – $12.50
- Stromboli (Ham, Salami, and Cheese) – $13.25
These come with a small cup of sauce on the side. They are big enough to be a full meal, so plan on sharing or taking half home.
Sandwiches And Heroes
Rey’s also serves a selection of hot and cold sandwiches. These are served on fresh-baked rolls and come with a side of chips or a small salad for an extra dollar.
- Meatball Parm Hero – $11.75
- Chicken Parm Hero – $12.25
- Sausage and Peppers Hero – $11.50
- Eggplant Parm Hero – $10.95
- Italian Cold Cut – $11.25
- Turkey and Cheese – $10.50
These heroes are hefty. The bread is crusty on the outside but soft inside, which is the right texture for holding all the fillings.
Pasta Dishes
For a change of pace, you can order a plate of pasta. These are simple, home-style dishes that are cooked to order.
- Spaghetti with Marinara – $10.95
- Baked Ziti – $12.50
- Penne alla Vodka – $13.75
- Lasagna (Baked Fresh Daily) – $14.50
- Chicken Francese over Linguine – $16.95
Each pasta dish comes with a small side salad and a piece of garlic bread. It is a filling meal for the price.
Desserts And Drinks
Finish your meal on a sweet note. The dessert menu is short but satisfying.
- Tiramisu – $6.95
- Cannoli (2 pieces) – $5.75
- Cheesecake – $5.50
For drinks, they have the standard sodas, iced tea, and bottled water. A 2-liter bottle of soda costs $3.99, which is better value than individual cups if you are feeding a group.
Deals And Combos
Rey’s does offer a few ways to save money, especially for larger groups. These are not always advertised on the main menu board, so it pays to ask.
- Lunch Special (Mon-Fri, 11 AM – 2 PM) – Two slices and a soda for $8.99
- Family Deal – One large cheese pizza, a tray of baked ziti, and a 2-liter soda for $34.99
- Wing and Pizza Combo – A large one-topping pizza and 10 wings for $27.99
These combos offer decent savings compared to ordering items separately. The family deal is particularly good for a weeknight dinner.
How To Order
You have a few options when it comes to placing your order. The most reliable method is still calling the store directly, as they are often too busy to update third-party apps quickly.
- Call Ahead – This is the best way to ensure your order is correct and ready on time.
- Walk-In – You can order at the counter and wait, or grab a table if you are dining in.
- Delivery Apps – Rey’s is on DoorDash and Uber Eats, but expect higher prices due to app fees.
If you are ordering for pickup, they usually quote 20-25 minutes during peak hours. On Friday and Saturday nights, it can be closer to 40 minutes, so plan accordingly.
Tips For Getting The Best Value
Here are a few practical tips to make sure you get the most for your money at Rey’s.
- Always ask for the “well-done” crust. It comes out crispier and holds up better if you are getting delivery.
- Check the specials board above the counter. They often have a rotating “Pizza of the Month” at a reduced price.
- If you are dining in, the soda refills are free. Take advantage of that.
- The large pizza is usually a better deal per square inch than the medium. If you are feeding two people, just get the large and have leftovers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people have about the pricing and offerings at Rey’s.
Does Rey’s offer a student discount?
Yes, they offer a 10% discount to students with a valid ID during the weekdays after 2 PM. It is not advertised heavily, but they do honor it.
Are the prices on the delivery apps the same as in-store?
No, the prices on third-party apps are usually about 15-20% higher to cover the app’s commission fees. You will save money by ordering directly for pickup.
Can I buy just a slice of specialty pizza?
Usually, yes. They keep a few slices of the most popular specialty pies (like BBQ Chicken) available at the counter during lunch. They cost around $4.50 per slice.
Does Rey’s have a gluten-free option?
Yes, they have a gluten-free crust, but it is only available in the small size. There is an additional charge of $4.00 for this crust.
Is there a minimum for delivery?
Yes, the minimum delivery order is $15.00, and there is a delivery fee of $2.50 that goes to the driver. This fee is not a tip.
Final Thoughts On Pricing
Rey’s is not the cheapest pizza in town, but it is far from the most expensive. You are paying for consistent quality and generous portions that have kept people coming back for decades.
Compared to national chains, the prices are very competitive, especially when you consider the size of the pies. The specialty pizzas are loaded with toppings, so you are not paying for a mostly-bread experience.
If you are on a budget, the lunch special is the best deal around. Two slices and a drink for under nine dollars is hard to beat in this economy.
We hope this breakdown of the Rey’s Pizza menu with prices helps you plan your next order. Whether you are grabbing a quick slice or feeding a crowd, you now have a clear idea of the cost before you walk in the door. Go ahead and call in that order; your stomach will thank you.
Just remember to double check the daily specials when you arrive, as they sometimes have unadvertised deals that are even better than the standard menu prices. It is always worth asking the cashier what is running that day.
So next time you are thinking about pizza night, you know exactly what to expect. Rey’s remains a reliable choice for a satisfying, no-frills meal that tastes like tradition. Enjoy your pie.