Potbelly’s toasted sandwiches have a devoted following, yet the final bill often depends on which size, bread, and add-ons make it into your basket. If you are looking for the full Potbelly Sandwich Shop Menu with Prices, you have come to the right place. We have broken down the current costs so you can plan your order without any surprises at the register.
Potbelly is known for its warm, toasted subs and classic American deli sides. But prices can change based on your location, so we have provided a general guide based on typical franchise pricing. Below, you will find a clear breakdown of sandwiches, salads, shakes, and extras.
Potbelly Sandwich Shop Menu With Prices
Before you walk in, it helps to understand the sizing system. Potbelly offers three main sizes: Original, Big, and a smaller “Skinny” option for those watching portions. The price difference between Original and Big is usually around two to three dollars.
Most locations also run a daily “Pick Your Pickle” deal where you can get a combo for a set price. This often includes a sandwich, chips, and a drink. It is one of the best ways to save money if you are hungry.
Classic Sandwiches And Pricing
The menu is built around a few signature recipes. Here is the standard pricing structure for the most popular items. Remember that these are average prices and may vary slightly by state.
- Original (Regular Size): $7.50 – $8.50
- Big Size: $9.50 – $10.50
- Skinny (Low Carb): $6.50 – $7.50
The most famous sandwich is the Italian. It comes with salami, pepperoni, and capicola. You can expect to pay around $8.00 for the Original size. The Turkey Breast is a lighter option, usually priced slightly lower at $7.75 for the Original.
Another crowd favorite is the Beef sandwich, which features roast beef and provolone. This one tends to be on the higher end of the price range. Expect to pay around $8.50 for the Original size.
Specialty And Signature Sandwiches
Potbelly also has a line of “Signature” sandwiches that come with specific sauces and toppings. These are often a bit more expensive because they include premium ingredients like bacon or avocado.
The Wreck is their most indulgent option. It includes salami, turkey, roast beef, and bacon. This is a hefty sandwich, and the price reflects it. You will likely pay between $8.75 and $9.25 for the Original size.
The Mediterranean is a vegetarian option with feta cheese and hummus. It is usually priced around $7.50. If you add chicken to it, the price jumps up by about two dollars.
Here is a quick list of the signature sandwiches and their average Original price:
- The Wreck: $9.00
- Mediterranean: $7.50
- Chicken Salad: $7.75
- BLT: $7.25
- Tuna Salad: $7.50
Bread Options And Upgrades
Your choice of bread does not usually change the base price of the sandwich. However, if you opt for a wrap instead of bread, there might be a small upcharge of about fifty cents. The standard options include white, wheat, rye, and a jalapeno cheese bread.
Toasting is free, and most people get their sandwich toasted by default. You can ask for it “untoasted” if you prefer a cold deli style. There is no extra cost for this, but it is good to know.
Adding extra meat will cost you. A double meat portion typically adds between $2.50 and $3.00 to the total. Extra cheese is usually around $1.00 to $1.50.
Salads And Light Bites
If you are not in the mood for bread, Potbelly offers a selection of chopped salads. These are made fresh and come with your choice of protein. The base price for a salad is usually around $8.00.
Adding chicken or steak to a salad will increase the price to roughly $9.50. The salads are generous and come with a side of dressing. You can also get any of the sandwich meats added to a salad for the same price as a sandwich upgrade.
Sides, Chips, And Cookies
No sandwich meal is complete without a side. Potbelly offers several options, from classic chips to their famous cookies. The pricing for sides is very consistent across locations.
- Bag of Chips: $1.50 – $1.75
- Potato Salad: $2.50
- Coleslaw: $2.50
- Soup (Cup): $3.50
- Soup (Bowl): $4.50
- Cookies: $1.75 each
The cookies are a big draw for many customers. They are baked fresh and come in flavors like chocolate chip and oatmeal. You can also buy a box of cookies to take home, which costs around $10.00 for a half dozen.
Shakes And Drinks
Potbelly is also known for its hand-dipped milkshakes. These are thick and made with real ice cream. The standard shake flavors include chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry.
A regular shake will cost you about $4.50. If you want to add malt or a flavor swirl, it will be an extra fifty cents. They also offer a “Dream Bar” shake which is topped with a chocolate bar piece. That one is closer to $5.25.
Soft drinks are standard pricing. A medium fountain drink is around $2.50. Bottled water is usually $2.00. If you are ordering a combo, the drink is included in the meal price.
How To Save Money On Your Order
There are several ways to reduce the cost of your meal. First, always check the app for exclusive coupons. Potbelly frequently sends out offers for buy-one-get-one-free deals or discounts on specific sandwiches.
Second, consider the “Pick Your Pickle” combo. This is often the best value. You get a sandwich, chips, and a drink for a price that is usually about two dollars less than buying them separately.
Third, skip the premium add-ons. Avocado and bacon are tasty, but they add up quickly. If you are on a budget, stick to the classic recipes that already have good flavor.
Here is a step-by-step guide to ordering on a budget:
- Open the Potbelly app and look for the “Deals” section.
- Choose the Original size instead of the Big size.
- Select a standard bread like wheat or white.
- Skip the extra cheese and bacon.
- Opt for the combo meal to include chips and a drink.
- Use a reward points code if you have one.
Nutritional Considerations
If you are counting calories, the Skinny sandwiches are a good option. They are served in a lettuce wrap or on a smaller portion of bread. The Skinny Turkey is usually under 300 calories, making it a solid choice for a light lunch.
The Big size sandwiches can easily exceed 800 calories, especially if you add sauces. The creamy sauces like mayo and ranch add significant calories. You can ask for sauces on the side to control the portion.
Most locations post their full nutritional guide online. It is wise to check that before you go if you have specific dietary needs. The allergen information is also available on their official website.
Location Based Price Differences
It is important to note that the prices we have listed are averages. A Potbelly in New York City or San Francisco will likely charge more than one in a rural area in the Midwest. The cost of rent and labor affects the menu pricing.
Airport locations and mall kiosks also tend to have higher prices. If you are near a stand-alone store, you will get the best value. You can always call ahead to ask for the exact price of your favorite sandwich.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Potbelly have a secret menu?
Yes, there are a few off-menu items. The most famous is the “Skinny” version of any sandwich, which is not always listed on the board. You can also ask for a “Salad Wreck” which is the Wreck sandwich ingredients served over lettuce.
Are there any gluten-free options?
Potbelly does not have a dedicated gluten-free kitchen. However, you can order any sandwich as a lettuce wrap or in a bowl. This removes the gluten from the bread, but there is a risk of cross-contamination.
Why is my local Potbelly more expensive?
Franchise owners have the ability to set their own prices within a certain range. This is why you might see a price difference between two locations in the same city. It is not a mistake.
Can I order a half sandwich?
No, Potbelly does not offer a half sandwich option. The smallest size is the Skinny, which is a full sandwich but with less bread. The Original is the standard size.
Do they offer catering?
Yes, Potbelly has a catering menu. You can order party platters with assorted sandwiches. The pricing for catering is different and usually requires a 24-hour notice. You can get a platter that serves 10 people for around $70.
Final Thoughts On Pricing
Potbelly is not the cheapest sandwich shop, but the quality is generally high. The toasted bread and fresh ingredients justify the price for most customers. A meal for one person, including a sandwich, chips, and a drink, will typically run you between $10 and $12.
If you are feeding a family of four, you can expect to pay around $40 to $50. This is comparable to other fast-casual deli chains. Using the app for rewards is the smartest way to keep the cost down over time.
We hope this guide to the Potbelly Sandwich Shop Menu with Prices helps you order with confidence. The next time you are near a store, you will know exactly what to expect. Go ahead and grab that Wreck sandwich, you have earned it.