Late-night study sessions call for a specific kind of fuel, and Pickleman’s Menu with Prices for their fresh-baked subs make them a smart choice for hungry students. You don’t need to guess what you will pay before you walk in the door. The menu is simple, the ingredients are fresh, and the cost is fair for the portion size you get.
Pickleman’s is not your average sandwich shop. They focus on artisan bread, quality meats, and a signature “dirty” style that keeps people coming back. If you are watching your budget or just want to know the damage before you order, this guide breaks down the full menu with current pricing.
Pickleman’s Menu With Prices
Below is a full breakdown of the current offerings. Prices can vary slightly by location, but this gives you a solid baseline for what to expect. You will find that most subs fall into a comfortable range for a filling meal.
Signature Gourmet Hot Subs
These are the reason most people walk through the door. The bread is baked fresh every morning, and the meats are piled high. You get a toasted, crispy exterior with a soft center.
- **The Dirty** – Roast beef, turkey, ham, bacon, cheddar, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, and house dressing. A full 8-inch sub runs about **$9.99**.
- **The Italian** – Genoa salami, capicola, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, and Italian vinaigrette. Priced around **$8.99** for a regular size.
- **The Club** – Smoked turkey, ham, bacon, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. Expect to pay **$9.49**.
- **The Reuben** – Corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and thousand island dressing on rye. This one is a solid **$9.79**.
- **The Chicken Bacon Ranch** – Grilled chicken, bacon, ranch, and cheddar. It will cost you about **$9.29**.
- **The Meatball** – Homemade meatballs, marinara, and provolone. A filling option at **$8.49**.
- **The Philly** – Shaved ribeye, peppers, onions, and provolone. You are looking at **$9.99**.
Cold Subs And Wraps
If you are not in the mood for a hot, toasted sub, the cold options are just as good. They use the same fresh bread and crisp veggies. These are perfect for a quick lunch that does not weigh you down.
- **The Turkey Bacon Club** – Sliced turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. Around **$8.99**.
- **The Veggie** – Loaded with lettuce, tomato, onion, peppers, cucumber, and cheese. A lighter option at **$7.49**.
- **The Ham And Swiss** – Classic pairing with mustard and mayo. Priced near **$7.99**.
- **The Roast Beef** – Simple, with lettuce, tomato, and horseradish sauce. Expect **$8.79**.
- **Chicken Salad** – House-made chicken salad on your choice of bread. Usually **$7.99**.
- **Turkey Avocado Wrap** – Sliced turkey, fresh avocado, lettuce, and tomato in a flour tortilla. Runs about **$8.49**.
Fresh Baked Cookies And Sides
No meal is complete without a side. Pickleman’s keeps the sides simple but satisfying. You can grab a bag of chips or a giant cookie to round out your order.
- **Giant Cookies** – Chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, or M&M. Each cookie is **$1.99**.
- **Potato Chips** – A single bag runs **$1.29**. You can also get a variety pack for the table.
- **Pasta Salad** – A side portion is **$2.49**. It is creamy and has a bit of a kick.
- **Pickle Spear** – You cannot leave without trying one. A spear is **$0.99**. They are crunchy and briny.
Meal Deals And Combos
If you want to save a little cash, the combo deals are the way to go. You get a sub, a side, and a drink for one flat price. This is usually a better value than ordering everything separate.
- **The Classic Combo** – Any 8-inch sub, chips, and a 21-ounce drink. Priced at **$11.99**. You save about two dollars compared to buying ala carte.
- **The Big Combo** – Any 8-inch sub, a giant cookie, and a drink. This runs **$12.49**. Good for a sweet tooth.
- **The Works Combo** – Sub, chips, cookie, and a drink. The full spread is **$13.99**. This is the best value if you are really hungry.
Bread Options And Extras
You get to choose your bread with every sub. The options are not complicated, but they make a difference. You can also add extra meat or cheese for a small upcharge.
- **White** – Soft and classic.
- **Wheat** – A bit heartier and nutty.
- **Rye** – Perfect for the Reuben or any deli-style sub.
- **Gluten-Free** – Available at most locations for an extra **$1.50**.
Adding extra meat will cost you around **$2.00**. Extra cheese is usually **$1.00**. You can also add bacon to any sub for **$1.50**. These prices are standard across most franchise locations.
Drinks And Fountain Beverages
They have a standard fountain machine with all the usual sodas. You can also grab bottled water or a can of soda if you prefer. The prices are typical for a fast-casual spot.
- **21 oz Fountain Drink** – **$2.29**.
- **32 oz Fountain Drink** – **$2.79**.
- **Bottled Water** – **$1.99**.
- **Canned Soda** – **$1.79**.
How To Order To Save Money
You can keep your total low if you know how to navigate the menu. Here are a few practical tips that work every time you visit.
- Skip the combo if you are not thirsty. Water is free, and you can use that saved money on a cookie.
- Order the 8-inch instead of the 12-inch. The smaller size is still filling for most people. The 12-inch is usually only two or three dollars more, but you might not finish it.
- Check the daily specials. Many locations run a specific sub deal on certain days of the week. Ask at the counter or look at the board.
- Use the app for rewards. Pickleman’s has a loyalty program. You earn points on every order, and those points turn into free subs.
- Share a giant cookie. They are big enough to split. That cuts your dessert cost in half.
Nutritional Considerations And Allergens
If you are counting calories or have food allergies, you need to pay attention. The subs are hearty and calorie-dense. The bread is fresh, but it is not low-carb.
- Calories: A standard 8-inch sub ranges from 600 to 900 calories depending on the meat and cheese. The Dirty is on the higher end.
- Sodium: Processed meats are high in sodium. If you are watching your salt intake, you might want to skip the bacon.
- Allergens: The bread contains gluten. The cookies contain nuts in some varieties. Tell the staff if you have a serious allergy, as cross-contamination is possible.
- Vegetarian Options: The Veggie sub is the main choice. You can also ask for any sub without meat, but you will still be charged the full price.
Comparing Value To Other Chains
You might be wondering if Pickleman’s is worth the price compared to Subway or Jimmy John’s. The answer is yes, but with a caveat. You are paying for better ingredients and fresher bread.
A footlong at Subway can be cheaper, sometimes around six or seven dollars on a promo. However, the quality of the meat and the bread is not the same. Pickleman’s uses higher-grade meats and bakes their bread in-house. The flavor difference is noticeable.
Jimmy John’s is a bit cheaper too, but they do not toast their subs. If you like a warm, crispy sub, Pickleman’s is the better choice. The extra two or three dollars is worth it for the taste and the portion size.
What Customers Usually Say
Regulars tend to say the same things about their experience. The service is fast, and the staff is friendly. The store is usually clean, even during a rush.
- Bread is the star. People rave about the texture and taste of the baked bread.
- Portions are generous. You do not feel short-changed when you open the wrapper.
- Consistency is good. You get the same quality at different locations.
- Prices are fair. Most people agree that the cost matches the quality.
Some people complain about the lack of seating in certain locations. A few stores are set up for takeout only. If you plan to eat there, check if they have tables before you order.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people have about the menu and pricing. These should help you before you go.
What is the most popular sub at Pickleman’s?
The Dirty is the fan favorite. It has a mix of roast beef, turkey, ham, and bacon. The house dressing ties it all together. It is also one of the pricier items on the menu, but most people think it is worth it.
Does Pickleman’s offer any discounts for students?
Some locations do offer a student discount, but it is not a chain-wide policy. You should ask at the counter and show your student ID. It is usually around 10% off your total order.
Can I order a half sub or a smaller portion?
No, Pickleman’s does not offer half subs. The smallest size is the 8-inch. You can, however, ask for extra lettuce or veggies to make it feel more substantial without paying extra.
Are there any low-carb options on the menu?
You can order any sub as a lettuce wrap instead of bread. This is a good option if you are watching your carbs. The price is the same as a regular sub, but you save on the bread calories.
Does Pickleman’s deliver?
Yes, most locations deliver through third-party apps like DoorDash and Uber Eats. Keep in mind that delivery fees and service charges will raise the total cost. The menu prices on the apps are also slightly higher than in-store.
Final Thoughts On The Menu And Costs
Pickleman’s is a solid choice when you want a sub that tastes like it was made with care. The prices are reasonable for the quality. You are not going to find a cheaper option that uses the same level of fresh ingredients.
If you are a student on a budget, the classic combo is your best bet. It gives you a full meal for under twelve dollars. If you are just stopping by for a quick bite, a single sub and a water will keep you under ten bucks.
Remember that prices can shift slightly depending on your city and the specific franchise owner. The numbers listed here are a reliable estimate based on current average pricing across the country. Always check the board when you walk in to confirm the exact cost.
Take your time looking over the menu. There is something for everyone, from the meat lover to the vegetarian. And do not forget to grab a pickle spear on your way out. It is part of the experience.