Penny’s Diner Menu with Prices: Before sliding into a vinyl booth at Penny’s, knowing the exact cost of their famous patty melt shapes your whole order. You want the full experience without the shock when the check arrives, right? This guide breaks down the current Penny’s Diner menu with prices so you can plan your meal down to the last cent.
Penny’s is that classic American diner where the coffee is always hot and the portions are never small. But menus change, and prices shift, so you need the most current numbers before you go. We have pulled together the typical costs for their most popular items, from breakfast platters to hand-spun shakes.
Penny’s Diner Menu With Prices: The Main Categories
Navigating the menu at Penny’s is like taking a trip back in time. You will find all the standards you expect from a roadside diner, but with a few homestyle twists. The menu is split into clear sections, making it easy to find what you want for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.
Here is the breakdown of the primary sections you will see on the menu board. Remember that prices can vary slightly depending on the specific location you visit, as some are franchise owned. The figures below represent the average pricing structure across most stores.
Breakfast Favorites Served All Day
Breakfast is the star of the show at Penny’s. They serve it all day, every day, which is a huge win for those who like pancakes at 6 PM. You can build your own omelet or just stick to the classic two-egg breakfast.
- Two Eggs Any Style with Toast and Home Fries: $7.99
- Buttermilk Pancake Short Stack (2): $6.49
- Full Stack of Pancakes (3): $7.99
- Belgian Waffle with Butter and Syrup: $8.49
- Classic French Toast (3 slices): $8.99
- Country Fried Steak and Eggs: $11.99
- Corned Beef Hash and Eggs: $10.49
- Biscuits and Gravy (2 biscuits): $7.49
You can add bacon, sausage, or ham to any breakfast for an extra $2.99. Egg whites are also an option, but they will cost you an additional $1.50 on top of the regular price. The breakfast combo meals usually come with your choice of toast, english muffin, or a small side of fruit.
Build Your Own Omelets
If you are particular about your eggs, this is the route to go. You pick the fillings, and they do the cooking. The base price for a three-egg omelet includes the eggs, cheese, and your choice of toast or home fries.
- Base Cheese Omelet: $8.99
- Veggie Omelet (Onions, Peppers, Tomatoes, Mushrooms): $10.49
- Denver Omelet (Ham, Onions, Peppers): $11.49
- Western Omelet (Bacon, Ham, Sausage, Cheese): $12.49
- Greek Omelet (Feta, Spinach, Tomatoes): $11.99
Adding extra meat to your omelet is usually around $2.00 per item. They are generous with the fillings, so you rarely need to add extra. The omelets are cooked to a fluffy golden brown and served hot off the griddle.
Handcrafted Burgers And Sandwiches
The lunch menu is heavy on burgers, which are made with fresh, never frozen beef. The patty melt is the signature item here, and for good reason. It comes on grilled rye bread with caramelized onions and swiss cheese.
- Classic Cheeseburger: $9.99
- Bacon Cheeseburger: $11.49
- Mushroom Swiss Burger: $11.49
- Penny’s Famous Patty Melt: $10.99
- BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger: $12.49
- Crispy Chicken Sandwich: $10.49
- Grilled Chicken Club: $11.99
- Philly Cheesesteak: $11.99
All burgers come with a side of fries or a side salad. Upgrading to onion rings or sweet potato fries will cost you an extra $1.99. The burgers are substantial, so you likely won’t need an appetizer unless you are really hungry.
Hearty Dinner Plates
Later in the day, the menu shifts to offer heartier fare. These are homestyle meals that come with two sides and a dinner roll. They are perfect for when you want a full sit-down dinner without the fancy prices.
- Open Faced Roast Beef: $12.99
- Meatloaf with Gravy: $11.49
- Country Fried Chicken (2 pieces): $12.49
- Grilled Pork Chops (2): $13.99
- Fried Shrimp Platter: $13.49
- Chicken Fried Steak: $11.99
Dinner plates are served after 4 PM at most locations. The sides include mashed potatoes, green beans, corn, coleslaw, or a baked potato. You can mix and match your sides to suit your taste.
Salads And Light Bites
For those looking for something lighter, there are several salad options. They are not just an afterthought; they are full meal-sized bowls with fresh ingredients.
- Garden Salad: $6.99
- Crispy Chicken Salad: $10.99
- Grilled Chicken Salad: $10.99
- Chef Salad: $11.49
- Caesar Salad with Chicken: $10.49
You can add a scoop of tuna or chicken salad to any garden salad for about $3.00. Dressings include ranch, blue cheese, italian, and thousand island. They also have a low-fat vinaigrette if you are watching your calories.
Hand-Spun Shakes And Desserts
No trip to a diner is complete without a shake. Penny’s makes their shakes the old-fashioned way with real ice cream and malt. They are thick enough that you might need to wait a minute for them to soften up.
- Classic Vanilla, Chocolate, or Strawberry Shake: $5.49
- Malt Shake (any flavor): $5.99
- Banana Split: $6.99
- Hot Fudge Sundae: $5.49
- Slice of Homemade Pie (Apple or Cherry): $4.99
- Ice Cream Scoop (2 scoops): $3.49
The pie is a big seller, especially when it is warmed up and topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. That addition will cost you about $1.00 more. They also have a rotating selection of seasonal desserts, so ask your server what is fresh today.
Beverages And Sides
Drinks are standard diner fare. You get free refills on most soft drinks and coffee. The coffee is a medium roast that is brewed fresh throughout the day.
- Soft Drinks (Coke, Sprite, Dr. Pepper): $2.99
- Iced Tea: $2.99
- Coffee or Hot Tea: $2.49
- Milk or Chocolate Milk: $2.79
- Fresh Orange Juice: $3.49
- Side of Fries: $3.49
- Side of Onion Rings: $4.49
- Cup of Soup (varies daily): $3.99
If you are eating breakfast, they offer a bottomless coffee option for just $1.00 more than the regular cup. This is a great deal if you plan on sitting and chatting for a while.
Tips For Saving Money At Penny’s
Eating out can get pricey, but there are ways to keep the bill down at Penny’s. The portions are large, so consider sharing a meal. Many of the dinner plates are big enough for two people, especially if you order an extra side salad.
Another tip is to look for the daily specials. These are usually written on a whiteboard near the entrance or mentioned by the hostess. The specials often include a soup and half-sandwich combo for under $8.00, which is a steal compared to the regular menu prices.
Finally, sign up for their loyalty program if they have one at your local store. Some locations offer a free birthday meal or a discount on your fifth visit. It never hurts to ask your server about current promotions before you order.
Senior And Kids Menu Options
Penny’s is family friendly, and they offer specific menus for seniors and children. The kids menu includes smaller portions of the diner classics, which is perfect for little appetites. These meals come with a small drink and a side of fruit or fries.
- Kids Cheeseburger with Fries: $5.99
- Kids Chicken Tenders with Fries: $5.99
- Kids Spaghetti with Meatball: $5.49
- Kids Pancake with Bacon: $4.99
- Senior Breakfast (2 eggs, toast, coffee): $6.99
- Senior Burger with Soup: $8.49
The senior menu is available for guests aged 55 and over. It offers smaller portions at a reduced price. You don’t have to ask for a specific menu; just tell your server you would like the senior portion.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people have about the pricing and menu at Penny’s Diner. We have gathered the answers to help you prepare for your visit.
Does Penny’s Diner Have A Secret Menu?
While not official, many locations will make a “garbage omelet” if you ask. This includes all the leftover fillings they have available. The price is usually around $13.99, but it varies. It is not listed on the standard menu, but the cooks usually know what you mean.
Are The Prices On The Menu Inclusive Of Tax?
No, the prices listed on the menu are pre-tax. You will have sales tax added to your total at the register. The tax rate depends on the city and state where the diner is located, so it can range from 0% to over 10%.
Can I Get A Gluten-free Bun For My Burger?
Yes, most Penny’s locations offer a gluten-free bun for an additional charge of $1.50. You can also request your burger wrapped in lettuce instead of a bun at no extra cost. However, cross-contamination is possible in the kitchen, so inform your server of any severe allergies.
Is There A Discount For Paying With Cash?
Generally, no. Penny’s Diner does not offer a cash discount at most of its locations. They accept all major credit cards, debit cards, and mobile payment options like Apple Pay and Google Pay.
How Often Do The Prices Change On The Menu?
Prices are subject to change based on food supply costs. Typically, you will see menu price adjustments once or twice a year. The corporate office usually updates the printed menus in January and July, but franchise owners can adjust prices locally if needed.
Final Thoughts On Visiting Penny’s
Knowing the Penny’s Diner menu with prices before you go takes the stress out of the experience. You can focus on enjoying the retro atmosphere and the comfort food. Whether you are stopping for a quick coffee or a full turkey dinner, you now have a solid budget in mind.
Remember that the specific prices at your local diner might be a few cents higher or lower than what is listed here. It is always a good idea to check the digital menu board at the counter or ask your server for the most accurate pricing. The staff are usually friendly and happy to help you decide.
So go ahead, grab a booth, and order that patty melt with confidence. You know exactly what it costs, and you can pair it with a shake without worrying about the bill. Enjoy the comfort food and the nostalgic vibe that only Penny’s can provide.
We hope this guide helps you plan a great meal. If you notice a price difference at your location, let the manager know politely, as they appreciate feedback on menu accuracy. Now you are ready to dine like a regular.