The ice cream counter has been scooping since your grandparents’ first date, but the prices on the board above have definitely changed since then. If you are looking for the current Newport Creamery Menu with Prices, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down every category, from the famous Awful Awfuls to the casual lunch items, so you know exactly what to expect before you walk in.
We have pulled together the most recent pricing data from official locations and customer reports. Keep in mind that prices can shift slightly depending on the specific store you visit in Rhode Island or Massachusetts. Still, this breakdown gives you a solid ballpark figure for budgeting your next trip.
Newport Creamery Menu With Prices
Newport Creamery is not just an ice cream stand. It is a full-service diner and restaurant that has been operating since 1923. The menu is huge, so we have organized it into clear sections below. You will find the classic burgers, sandwiches, and of course, the dessert case that everyone talks about.
Below is the full price list for the main food items. We have noted where prices are averages because some franchise locations add a small markup. The core menu items remain consistent across the board.
Burgers And Sandwiches
The grill items are simple and reliable. They use fresh beef patties and serve everything with your choice of fries, onion rings, or a side salad. You can add cheese to any burger for a small extra charge.
- Classic Cheeseburger – $8.99
- Bacon Cheddar Burger – $10.49
- Mushroom Swiss Burger – $10.49
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich – $9.79
- Crispy Chicken Sandwich – $9.49
- Fish Sandwich (Fried Cod) – $10.29
- BLT – $8.79
- Grilled Cheese – $6.99
- Tuna Melt – $9.29
- Reuben – $10.99
Most sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, and onion on request. The portions are generous. If you are really hungry, you can upgrade any sandwich to a “double” for about two dollars more.
Hot Dogs And Chowder
You cannot visit a Rhode Island classic without trying the chowder. Newport Creamery serves a creamy New England style that is thick and full of clams. They also do a red Manhattan style on certain days.
- New England Clam Chowder (Cup) – $4.79
- New England Clam Chowder (Bowl) – $6.29
- All Beef Hot Dog – $4.49
- Chili Dog – $5.79
- Hot Dog with Sauerkraut – $4.99
The hot dogs are snappy and grilled. You can order them “dragged through the garden” which means they add all the toppings. That is a local term you will hear at the counter.
Salads And Wraps
If you want something lighter, the salad selection is better than you might expect from an ice cream place. The chicken salad is made in-house daily.
- Garden Salad – $7.49
- Cobb Salad – $10.99
- Grilled Chicken Caesar – $10.49
- Chicken Salad Wrap – $8.99
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap – $9.29
All salads come with a dinner roll. You can add grilled shrimp to any salad for an extra $4.00. The dressings are standard house brands, but the ranch is quite popular.
Awful Awful Milkshakes
This is the main event. The Awful Awful is a large milkshake that is so thick you need a long spoon to eat it. The name comes from the phrase “awful big, awful good.” They come in over 20 flavors.
Here is the pricing structure for the shakes:
- Small Awful Awful (12 oz) – $5.49
- Medium Awful Awful (16 oz) – $6.79
- Large Awful Awful (20 oz) – $8.29
- Add Real Fruit (Strawberry, Banana, Peach) – $1.00
- Add Hot Fudge or Caramel Swirl – $0.75
The most popular flavor is Coffee. The second most popular is Vanilla with a shot of chocolate syrup. You can also order a “Cabinet” which is the Rhode Island term for a milkshake that includes ice cream, syrup, and milk.
Ice Cream Sundaes And Splits
If you do not want a full shake, the sundae menu is extensive. Everything is served in a classic tulip glass with whipped cream and a cherry on top.
- Hot Fudge Sundae – $6.29
- Caramel Sundae – $6.29
- Pineapple Sundae – $6.29
- Butterscotch Sundae – $6.49
- Banana Split – $8.99
- Brownie Sundae – $7.49
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae – $7.29
The banana split uses three scoops of ice cream. You can pick vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry, or go all one flavor if you prefer. The brownie is baked fresh and warmed before serving.
Ice Cream Cakes And Pies
Newport Creamery sells whole ice cream cakes for parties. You need to order these at least 24 hours in advance. They are very popular for birthdays and graduations.
- Round Ice Cream Cake (8 inch, serves 8) – $24.99
- Round Ice Cream Cake (10 inch, serves 12) – $32.99
- Ice Cream Pie (Chocolate or Graham Cracker Crust) – $18.99
- Ice Cream Pie with Hot Fudge Layer – $21.49
You can customize the cake with a message written in frosting. There is no extra charge for this. They also sell half-gallons of ice cream to take home for $7.99.
Kids Menu
For the little ones, there is a dedicated kids menu. It comes with a small drink and a scoop of ice cream for dessert.
- Kids Cheeseburger with Fries – $6.49
- Kids Chicken Tenders (3 pieces) – $6.29
- Kids Grilled Cheese – $5.79
- Kids Spaghetti with Meatball – $6.49
- Kids Hot Dog – $5.49
The kids meal includes a choice of a small sundae or a single scoop cone. This is a good deal compared to other family restaurants in the area.
Breakfast Menu
Several locations serve breakfast all day. This is not advertised everywhere, so check with your local store. The breakfast menu is simple but filling.
- Two Eggs Any Style with Toast – $6.99
- Egg and Cheese Sandwich – $5.49
- Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich – $6.79
- Pancake Stack (3) – $7.29
- French Toast (3 slices) – $7.49
- Breakfast Burrito – $8.29
Breakfast is served until 11:00 AM on weekdays and until noon on weekends at most locations. The coffee is regular diner coffee, nothing fancy, but it is bottomless.
Sides And Extras
You can order sides a la carte if you want to share or just need a snack. The onion rings are a standout item.
- French Fries – $3.99
- Onion Rings – $4.79
- Sweet Potato Fries – $4.49
- Side Salad – $3.49
- Coleslaw – $2.29
- Apple Sauce – $2.29
You can also order a side of gravy for the fries for an extra $0.89. The fries are crinkle cut, which is the classic diner style.
Beverages
Besides the shakes, there are standard fountain drinks and some local favorites. You can get coffee milk, which is the official state drink of Rhode Island.
- Coffee Milk (Glass) – $3.29
- Chocolate Milk (Glass) – $3.29
- Soft Drinks (Refillable) – $2.99
- Iced Tea – $2.79
- Fresh Lemonade – $3.49
- Hot Coffee (Bottomless) – $2.49
The coffee milk is made with Autocrat syrup. It is a unique flavor that you will not find in most other states. If you have never tried it, order one with your meal.
How To Save Money On Your Visit
There are a few ways to reduce the total cost of your meal. The prices listed above are the regular menu prices. You can often do better with a coupon or a special.
Here are some practical tips:
- Join the Newport Creamery Rewards Program for a free scoop on your birthday.
- Check the local newspaper for “Buy One Get One Free” Awful Awful coupons.
- Visit on a weekday afternoon to avoid the rush and get faster service.
- Order the “Small” Awful Awful if you are also getting a meal. It is plenty big.
- Share a banana split. It is easily enough for two people.
The rewards program sends a text message coupon every month. That coupon is usually for a discounted sundae or a free topping.
Does The Price Vary By Location?
Yes, there is a slight variation. The corporate stores in Middletown and Warwick tend to stick to the standard pricing. The franchise locations in Attleboro and Cranston may add a 10 to 15 percent markup on certain items.
For example, the Large Awful Awful might cost $8.99 at a franchise instead of $8.29. This is not a huge difference, but it is worth knowing if you are on a strict budget. The menu board inside the store will always show the exact price for that specific location.
Are There Any Hidden Fees?
No, there are no service charges or mandatory gratuities. You pay at the counter or at the end of your meal if you are dining in. The prices listed on the menu include the food cost but not the tax.
Rhode Island has a 7% sales tax on prepared food. Massachusetts has a 6.25% tax. So your final bill will be slightly higher than the menu prices. There is no surcharge for using a credit card.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most expensive item on the Newport Creamery menu?
The most expensive regular menu item is the 10-inch ice cream cake at $32.99. For dine-in items, the Cobb Salad and the Reuben are the highest at around $10.99.
Can I get a gluten free bun for my burger?
Yes, most locations offer a gluten free bun for an additional $1.50. You need to ask at the counter because it is not listed on the main menu board.
Does Newport Creamery offer senior discounts?
Some locations offer a 10% discount for customers over 65. This is not a corporate policy, so you need to ask the manager on duty if they honor it.
Are the Awful Awfuls really that big?
Yes. The Large size is 20 ounces of pure ice cream and syrup. It is served in a tall glass with the extra shake in the metal mixing cup. You are getting close to a pint of ice cream in the large size.
Is there a military discount?
Yes, Newport Creamery offers a 10% discount to active duty military and veterans. You just need to show your military ID at the register.
Final Thoughts On Pricing
The Newport Creamery Menu with Prices is fair for the portion sizes you receive. A burger and a small shake will cost you around $15.00 per person. If you skip the shake and just get a scoop of ice cream for dessert, you can get out for under $12.00.
The quality of the ice cream is high. They use a proprietary mix that has a very high butterfat content. That is why the shakes are so thick and creamy. You are paying for a product that has been consistent for almost a century.
One last tip: the parking lots at the Middletown and Warwick locations get very crowded on summer nights. If you are just going for ice cream, you can use the take-out window at some locations. This is faster and you do not have to wait for a table.
Check the official website or call your local store before you go if you need the most current pricing. Menu prices are subject to change, but the list above reflects the standard rates as of the last update. Enjoy your Awful Awful.