Regulars know that the true value at Mario’s Pizzeria isn’t in the specialty pies, but in the build-your-own option’s base price. That is why most people searching for the Mario’s Pizzeria menu with prices are actually looking for a way to feed a crowd without breaking the bank. You can get a solid, filling meal here for less than you’d spend at a chain, but you have to know what to look for before you walk in.
This guide breaks down the current menu, item by item, so you can plan your order. We will cover the pizzas, the sides, the pastas, and the drinks. You will also get a few tips on how to combo your order to save even more cash. Let’s get straight to the numbers, because that is why you are here.
Mario’s Pizzeria Menu With Prices
The menu is pretty standard for a neighborhood joint, but the pricing structure is what sets it apart. They keep the base items cheap and make their profit on the toppings and the drinks. If you are smart about it, you can eat like a king for a very modest amount of money. Here is the full breakdown of what you can expect to pay.
Build-Your-Own Pizzas
This is the heart of the operation. The base price includes the dough, the sauce, and a standard mozzarella cheese blend. You do not have to pay extra for the basics, which is nice. The price scales up depending on the size you choose.
- Personal 10″ – $7.99
- Medium 14″ – $11.99
- Large 16″ – $14.49
- X-Large 18″ – $17.99
- Sicilian (Square) 16″x16″ – $18.99
You should note that the Sicilian has a thicker dough, so it takes a little longer to bake. If you are in a hurry, stick to the round pies. The X-Large is usually the best value if you are feeding more than two people, as the price per slice drops significantly compared to the medium.
Topping Costs
Here is where they get you. Each topping is charged separately, and the price goes up with the size of the pie. The standard toppings include pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, and extra cheese. They also have some premium options like bacon and meatball.
- Standard Toppings (Personal) – $0.75 each
- Standard Toppings (Medium) – $1.50 each
- Standard Toppings (Large) – $1.95 each
- Standard Toppings (X-Large) – $2.50 each
- Premium Toppings (Bacon, Meatball, Chicken) – Add $1.00 to the standard price
If you are watching your budget, the smart move is to get a plain cheese pizza and add one or two toppings max. The cost of a fully loaded large pizza can easily hit $25.00, which defeats the purpose of coming here. Stick to the basics for the best deal.
Specialty Pizzas
They do offer pre-made specialty pies, but they are rarely the best value. You are paying for the convenience of not choosing your own toppings. They are good, but you could usually recreate them for less by using the build-your-own option. Here are the current prices for the house favorites.
- Margherita (Large) – $16.99
- Meat Lovers (Large) – $21.99
- Veggie Supreme (Large) – $18.99
- BBQ Chicken (Large) – $19.99
- White Pizza (Large) – $17.49
The White Pizza is actually a decent deal because it comes with ricotta and garlic. The Meat Lovers is usually a ripoff unless you really want five different meats. You are better off ordering a plain large and asking for pepperoni and sausage on the side.
Appetizers And Sides
You cannot just eat pizza, right? The sides are reasonably priced, but they are smaller than you might expect. The garlic knots are the crowd favorite, but the fries are a better value if you are hungry. Here is the full list of sides with their current pricing.
- Garlic Knots (6 pcs) – $4.99
- Garlic Knots (12 pcs) – $8.99
- Mozzarella Sticks (8 pcs) – $7.49
- Chicken Wings (6 pcs) – $8.99
- Chicken Wings (12 pcs) – $15.99
- French Fries – $3.99
- Onion Rings – $4.99
- Side Salad – $5.49
- Bruschetta – $6.99
The side salad is pretty small for the price. You are better off getting a small antipasto if they have it, but they don’t always list it on the menu board. The garlic knots are the best bang for your buck if you need a carb fix while you wait.
Wing Sauces
If you order the wings, you have a choice of sauces. The classic buffalo is the standard, but they also have a sweet teriyaki and a spicy garlic. There is no extra charge for the sauce, which is good. Just remember that the wings are fried, not baked, so they are crispy.
- Buffalo (Mild, Medium, Hot)
- BBQ
- Teriyaki
- Garlic Parmesan (Dry Rub)
- Lemon Pepper (Dry Rub)
The dry rubs are applied after cooking, so they can be a little messy. If you are eating in the car, stick to the wet sauces. The hot buffalo has a decent kick, but it is not insane. You can handle it.
Pasta And Entrees
They have a small selection of pasta dishes for those who do not want pizza. These are made to order and take about 15 minutes to prepare. The portions are generous, so you can usually get two meals out of one order. Here are the prices.
- Baked Ziti – $10.99
- Chicken Parmigiana – $13.99
- Eggplant Parmigiana – $11.99
- Spaghetti with Meatballs – $11.49
- Fettuccine Alfredo – $10.99
- Chicken Alfredo – $13.49
- Lasagna – $12.99
The Chicken Parmigiana comes with a side of spaghetti, so you get a lot of food for the price. The Lasagna is also a good choice, but it is very heavy. You will need a nap after eating it. All pasta dishes come with a piece of garlic bread, not garlic knots.
Pasta Add-Ons
You can add extra meatballs or sausage to any pasta dish for a small fee. The prices are listed below. This is a good way to bulk up a meal if you are really hungry. The meatballs are homemade, which makes a big difference.
- Extra Meatball (1 pc) – $1.50
- Extra Sausage (1 link) – $2.00
- Extra Chicken (6 oz) – $3.00
- Extra Shrimp (4 pcs) – $4.00
Skip the shrimp. It is frozen and not worth the upcharge. The meatballs are the way to go. They are large and seasoned well. You will not be disappointed.
Calzones And Stromboli
These are folded pizzas that are baked and served with a side of marinara sauce. They are filling and portable. The calzone has ricotta cheese inside, while the stromboli does not. That is the main difference. Here is the pricing.
- Cheese Calzone – $8.99
- Pepperoni Calzone – $9.99
- Meatball Calzone – $10.49
- Chicken Stromboli – $10.99
- Philly Cheesesteak Stromboli – $11.99
The Philly Cheesesteak Stromboli is the most expensive item on the appetizer side of the menu. It is good, but it is basically a sandwich wrapped in pizza dough. You can get a better deal by ordering a regular cheesesteak sandwich if they have one.
Desserts
They have a few dessert options, but they are not the main focus. The cannoli is the best choice if you want something authentic. The other desserts are just frozen items that they heat up. Prices are low, so it is not a big risk to try one.
- Cannoli (1 pc) – $3.50
- Tiramisu – $5.99
- Cheesecake (Slice) – $4.99
- Chocolate Lava Cake – $4.49
The Tiramisu is made in-house, but the cheesecake is from a food service company. You can tell by the texture. Stick to the cannoli if you want a fresh dessert. The shell is crispy and the filling is sweet.
Beverages
Drinks are where they make a lot of their profit. The prices are higher than the grocery store, but that is normal for a restaurant. They have the standard fountain sodas and bottled drinks. You cannot bring in outside drinks, so factor this into your budget.
- Fountain Soda (Medium) – $2.49
- Fountain Soda (Large) – $2.99
- Bottled Water – $1.99
- Can of Soda – $1.79
- Iced Tea (Fresh Brewed) – $2.79
- Italian Soda – $3.49
The fresh brewed iced tea is a better value than the fountain soda because it is not syrupy. The Italian soda is a treat, but it is mostly ice. You are better off getting a large water and adding a lemon from the counter.
Deals And Combos
Mario’s does not advertise their deals very well. You have to ask for them. They have a lunch special that runs from 11:00 AM to 2:00 PM on weekdays. This is the best time to go if you are on a budget. The lunch special includes a personal pizza and a drink for a set price.
- Lunch Special (Personal Cheese Pizza + Soda) – $8.99
- Lunch Special (Personal 1-Topping Pizza + Soda) – $9.99
- Two Large Cheese Pizzas (Carry-Out Only) – $25.99
- Large Pizza + 12 Wings – $27.99
The Two Large Pizza deal is the best for groups. You save about $3.00 compared to buying them separately. The Pizza and Wings combo is also solid. You have to specifically ask for these deals because they are not on the main menu board. They are listed on a small sign near the register.
How To Order To Save Money
If you want to keep your total under $20.00 for two people, you need to follow a specific strategy. Do not just walk in and order randomly. You will end up spending $30.00 without realizing it. Here is a step-by-step plan.
- Order a Medium Cheese Pizza – This is your base. It costs $11.99.
- Add One Topping – Choose pepperoni or mushrooms. This adds $1.50.
- Skip the Appetizers – They are not worth the money if you are hungry.
- Get a Large Water – Do not buy soda. Save $2.49.
- Split the Pizza – A medium has 8 slices. That is 4 slices per person.
This order will cost you about $13.50 before tax. That is a very cheap meal for two people. If you want to add a dessert, get one cannoli and split it. That brings your total to around $17.00, which is still reasonable.
Delivery Fees And Charges
If you order delivery, there is a delivery fee that is not a tip for the driver. This fee goes to the restaurant to cover the cost of the vehicle and insurance. You should also tip the driver separately. The delivery fee is usually around $2.99 to $3.99 depending on how far you live from the store.
- Local Delivery Fee – $2.99
- Extended Zone Fee – $4.99
- Minimum Order for Delivery – $15.00
The minimum order for delivery is $15.00, which is easy to hit. If you only order a small pizza and a drink, you will be under the minimum and they will not deliver to you. You have to add a side or a dessert to get over the threshold.
Payment Methods
They accept all major credit cards, debit cards, and cash. They also accept contactless payments like Apple Pay and Google Pay. There is no surcharge for using a credit card, which is good. Some places charge a 3% fee, but Mario’s does not do that.
- Visa
- Mastercard
- American Express
- Discover
- Cash
- Apple Pay
- Google Pay
If you pay in cash, you might get a small discount on large orders. It is not advertised, but if you are ordering more than $50.00 worth of food, ask if they can knock a few bucks off for cash. Sometimes they will give you a 10% discount because they save on processing fees.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions that people have about the menu and the pricing. These answers are based on the current menu board and the staff’s responses to inquiries.
Does Mario’s Pizzeria have a gluten-free crust?
Yes, they offer a gluten-free crust, but it is only available in the personal 10″ size. There is an additional charge of $2.50 for the gluten-free dough. They also have a separate prep area to avoid cross-contamination, but they do not guarantee it is 100% safe for celiacs.
Are there any vegetarian options besides cheese pizza?
Yes, the Veggie Supreme is a good option. You can also build your own pizza with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, and tomatoes. The side salad is also vegetarian, but you should ask for no meat on it if you do not want the ham or chicken.
What are the hours for the lunch special?
The lunch special runs from 11:00 AM to 2:00 PM, Monday through Friday. It is not available on weekends or holidays. The special includes a personal cheese or one-topping pizza and a medium fountain soda. You cannot substitute the drink for a water or a bottled drink.
Is the price on the menu the final price?
No, the prices listed do not include sales tax. There is also a delivery fee if you order online or by phone for delivery. If you are dining in, there is no service charge, but you are expected to tip the waitstaff if you sit at a table.
Can I order a half and half pizza with different toppings?
Yes, you can order a pizza with