Starting your morning at Manhattan Bagel Company works best when you know the difference between their breakfast sandwich combos and à la carte pricing. The Manhattan Bagel Company Menu with Prices is actually simpler than most people expect, but only if you understand how they group their items. You can walk in, order fast, and still keep your budget in check when you know exactly what each category costs.
Most locations follow a similar pricing structure, though local franchise owners can adjust a few cents here and there. This guide breaks down the core menu items, the real prices you will see at the register, and a few ordering tricks that regulars use every day.
Manhattan Bagel Company Menu With Prices
The menu is divided into five clear sections: bagels, spreads, sandwiches, coffee, and sides. Each section has its own pricing logic. Once you see the pattern, you can mix and match without guessing.
Bagel Pricing Basics
A single plain bagel costs around $1.09 at most stores. But you rarely buy just one, so here is the standard tier list:
- Single bagel: $1.09 – $1.29
- Half dozen (6 bagels): $6.49 – $6.99
- Dozen (12 bagels): $11.99 – $12.99
- Bakers dozen (13 bagels): $13.49 – $14.29
- Party pack (24 bagels): $23.99 – $25.99
The price difference between a half dozen and a full dozen is usually around $5.50. If you eat bagels more than twice a week, the dozen is the better deal. You can freeze them for up to three months without losing texture.
Flavored bagels like everything, cinnamon raisin, or asiago cost the same as plain ones. There is no upcharge for flavor at Manhattan Bagel Company, which is not true at many competing shops.
Specialty Bagels And Seasonal Options
Some locations rotate seasonal bagels like pumpkin or apple cider in the fall. These specialty items sometimes carry a $0.20 to $0.30 premium. Ask at the counter because the seasonal board is not always listed on the printed menu.
Gluten-free bagels are available at select locations. They cost around $2.49 each, which is significantly more than the regular ones. They also come pre-packaged and are toasted separately to avoid cross-contamination.
Spread And Cream Cheese Pricing
You can buy cream cheese by the tub or by the schmear. The single serving option is the most popular for dine-in customers.
- Single schmear (2 oz): $0.99 – $1.29
- Double schmear (4 oz): $1.79 – $1.99
- Tub (8 oz): $4.99 – $5.49
- Large tub (16 oz): $8.99 – $9.49
The flavored cream cheeses like veggie, lox, or jalapeno are the same price as plain. The only exception is the reduced-fat option, which sometimes costs $0.10 more at franchise locations.
If you are feeding a family, the 16 oz tub is the smart move. It gives you about eight generous schmears, which brings the per-serving cost down to roughly $1.10. That is a 20% savings compared to buying individual portions.
Other Spread Options
Peanut butter, jelly, and butter are available as add-ons. These cost between $0.50 and $0.75 per serving. You can also ask for a side of honey or cinnamon sugar, but those are not always listed on the menu board.
Breakfast Sandwich Combos
This is where the menu gets a bit confusing for first-timers. Manhattan Bagel Company offers two distinct ways to order breakfast sandwiches: as a combo or as a custom build.
Combo Meals
The combo includes a sandwich, a small coffee, and a side of potatoes or fruit. Prices vary by protein choice:
- Egg and cheese combo: $6.99 – $7.49
- Bacon, egg, and cheese combo: $7.99 – $8.49
- Sausage, egg, and cheese combo: $8.49 – $8.99
- Turkey sausage, egg, and cheese combo: $8.49 – $8.99
- Steak, egg, and cheese combo: $9.49 – $9.99
You can upgrade the coffee to a large for $0.50. You can also swap the side for a second bagel with schmear for $1.00. The combo is usually a better value than ordering everything separately, but only if you actually want the coffee and the side.
À La Carte Sandwich Pricing
If you skip the combo, you pay per ingredient. The base sandwich structure is:
- Choose your bagel (included in the sandwich price)
- Choose your egg style (scrambled, fried, or egg whites)
- Choose your cheese (American, cheddar, Swiss, or pepper jack)
- Choose your protein (optional)
The base egg and cheese sandwich costs $4.49. Adding bacon or sausage adds $1.50 to $2.00. Adding steak adds $2.50 to $3.00. Egg whites are a $0.75 upcharge.
So a bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel will run you about $6.49 à la carte. Compare that to the $7.99 combo, and you see the combo gives you coffee and a side for only $1.50 more. That is a solid deal if you want the full breakfast.
Lunch Sandwiches And Deli Items
After 11 AM, the menu shifts to lunch options. These are served on your choice of bagel, but you can also request a wrap or a sub roll at most locations.
Classic Deli Sandwiches
- Turkey and Swiss: $7.99 – $8.49
- Roast beef and cheddar: $8.99 – $9.49
- Chicken salad: $7.49 – $7.99
- Tuna salad: $7.49 – $7.99
- Ham and American: $7.49 – $7.99
- Pastrami and Russian dressing: $8.99 – $9.49
These sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, onion, and a pickle spear. You can add bacon for $1.50 or avocado for $1.75. All sandwiches are served cold unless you ask for them toasted.
Hot Panini Options
Some locations have a panini press. The hot sandwich menu includes:
- Grilled chicken panini: $8.49
- Meatball parmesan panini: $8.99
- Turkey club panini: $8.99
- Caprese panini: $7.99
Paninis come with a side of chips or a small salad. Upgrading to a full salad costs $2.00 extra.
Salads And Soups
For lighter meals, the menu includes a few salad options. These are not the main focus of the restaurant, but they are consistent and fresh.
- Garden salad: $5.99
- Caesar salad with chicken: $7.99
- Greek salad: $7.49
- Chef salad: $8.49
Soup is available daily, usually a rotating selection of chicken noodle, tomato basil, and vegetable barley. A cup costs $3.49 and a bowl costs $4.49. You can get a half sandwich and a cup of soup for $8.99, which is one of the better lunch values on the menu.
Beverages And Coffee Pricing
Coffee is a big part of the Manhattan Bagel Company experience. They use a proprietary blend that is smooth and not overly acidic.
Coffee And Espresso Drinks
- Small coffee: $1.99
- Medium coffee: $2.29
- Large coffee: $2.59
- Iced coffee (any size): $2.49 – $2.99
- Latte: $3.99 – $4.49
- Cappuccino: $3.99
- Mocha: $4.49 – $4.99
Free refills are available on regular coffee for dine-in customers. This is a nice perk if you plan to sit and work for a while. The iced coffee does not qualify for free refills.
Other Drinks
Bottled water, soda, and juices are available. These are priced between $1.79 and $2.49. Fresh squeezed orange juice is $3.49 for a small and $4.49 for a large.
Kids Menu And Sides
For younger customers, there is a small kids menu. It includes a mini bagel with cream cheese, a small bagel pizza, or a half sandwich. Kids meals cost between $3.99 and $4.99 and come with a small drink.
Side orders include:
- Hash browns: $1.99
- Home fries: $2.49
- Fresh fruit cup: $2.99
- Yogurt parfait: $3.49
- Bagel chips: $1.79
The home fries are seasoned with paprika and onion powder. They are crispy on the outside and soft inside. Worth the $2.49 if you are hungry.
Ordering Tips To Save Money
You can keep your total under $8 for a filling breakfast if you follow these steps:
- Order a plain bagel with a single schmear ($2.08)
- Add a side of home fries ($2.49)
- Get a small coffee ($1.99)
That totals $6.56 before tax. Compare that to the $7.99 combo, and you save about $1.40. The tradeoff is you do not get the egg protein, so you might feel hungry sooner.
Another trick is to ask for your sandwich with “light cheese” or “extra egg” instead of adding meat. Extra egg costs $0.75, which is cheaper than adding bacon at $1.50. You get more protein for less money.
Loyalty Program And Discounts
Manhattan Bagel Company runs a loyalty program through their mobile app. You earn points on every purchase. Every 100 points gives you $5 off your next order. A typical breakfast sandwich combo earns about 15 points, so you get a free $5 reward after roughly seven visits.
Some locations offer a 10% discount for students, military personnel, and seniors. You have to ask at the register because it is not advertised. The discount is not combinable with the loyalty program points.
On Tuesdays, some franchises run a “dozen bagels for $8.99” special. This is a significant discount from the regular $11.99 price. Call your local store to confirm because participation varies by owner.
Nutritional Considerations
A plain bagel has about 280 calories. Adding a schmear of cream cheese brings that to roughly 380 calories. A bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich on a bagel is around 650 calories. If you are watching sodium, note that the everything bagel has about 380 mg of sodium before you add any filling.
For a lighter option, consider the egg white sandwich on a plain bagel with no cheese. That comes in around 420 calories and 12 grams of fat. You can also request your bagel scooped out, which removes about 100 calories worth of bread.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cheapest item on the Manhattan Bagel Company menu?
The cheapest item is a plain bagel at about $1.09. A single schmear of cream cheese is $0.99, so you can get a bagel with cream cheese for just over $2.00.
Does Manhattan Bagel Company offer a student discount?
Many locations offer a 10% discount to students, but it is not a corporate policy. You need to ask at the register and show a valid student ID. Franchise owners decide whether to participate.
Can I order Manhattan Bagel Company online with prices shown?
Yes, the official website and third-party delivery apps show the full menu with current prices. Note that delivery apps often add a 15% to 20% markup compared to in-store prices.
Are there any gluten-free bagel options?
Select locations offer gluten-free bagels for around $2.49 each. They are pre-packaged and toasted separately. Call ahead to confirm availability because not every franchise carries them.
What is the price difference between a combo and à la carte breakfast?
A bacon, egg, and cheese combo costs about $7.99. Ordering the same sandwich à la carte costs around $6.49. The combo adds coffee and a side for $1.50 more, which is a better value if you want those items.
Final Thoughts On Pricing
Manhattan Bagel Company pricing is competitive with other bagel chains, but slightly higher than a basic deli. The quality of the bagels justifies the cost for most customers. They are boiled before baking, which gives them that chewy texture that is hard to find at grocery stores.
Your best strategy is to decide whether you want the full combo experience or just a quick bagel. If you are in a hurry, grab a bagel with schmear and a coffee. If you have time to sit, the combo meal is the better value. Either way, you now know the prices before you walk in, so there will be no surprises at the register.
Remember that prices can vary slightly between locations due to franchise ownership and local cost of living. The figures in this guide reflect the average across multiple stores. Always check the menu board or the app for the exact pricing at your local shop.