Magnolia Bakery’s famous banana pudding costs more per serving than their cupcakes, a pricing detail worth noting before you queue up. If you’re looking for the full Magnolia Bakery Menu with Prices, you’ve come to the right place. This guide breaks down every item, from their iconic desserts to their breakfast options, so you know exactly what to expect when you step up to the counter.
Magnolia Bakery isn’t just a bakery; it’s a New York City institution. Since 1996, they’ve been serving up nostalgic, old-fashioned treats that have captured hearts worldwide. But before you go, you need to know what things cost. Let’s get into the details.
Magnolia Bakery Menu With Prices
We’ve compiled the most up-to-date pricing information from their official locations. Keep in mind that prices can vary slightly depending on the city and specific location you visit. This breakdown reflects the standard pricing you’ll find at their NYC and major US locations.
Signature Banana Pudding
This is the item that put them on the map. The banana pudding is made fresh daily with layers of vanilla wafers, fresh bananas, and their signature vanilla pudding.
- Small (4 oz) – $4.95
- Regular (8 oz) – $6.75
- Large (16 oz) – $12.50
- Party Size (32 oz) – $22.00
You can also add extra toppings to your pudding. Whipped cream is free, but extra bananas will cost you an additional $1.50. The pudding is available in original, chocolate, and seasonal flavors like pumpkin during the fall.
Classic Cupcakes
Their cupcakes are famous for their thick, swirled frosting. They come in a variety of flavors that rotate seasonally.
- Classic Vanilla – $3.95
- Chocolate – $3.95
- Red Velvet – $4.25
- Carrot Cake – $4.25
- Seasonal Specials – $4.50
You can buy cupcakes by the half-dozen or dozen for a slight discount. A half-dozen will run you around $22.50, while a full dozen comes to approximately $44.00. They also offer custom cupcake towers for events, which start at $65.00.
Layer Cakes And Whole Cakes
If you’re celebrating something special, Magnolia Bakery has you covered with their full-size cakes.
- 6-inch Layer Cake (serves 6-8) – $32.00
- 8-inch Layer Cake (serves 10-12) – $42.00
- 10-inch Layer Cake (serves 14-16) – $55.00
- Banana Pudding Cake – $48.00
Their signature layer cakes come in flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet. You can also request custom decorations for an additional fee. A simple message on top will cost $5.00 extra, while more elaborate designs start at $15.00.
Cookies And Brownies
For those who prefer something a bit simpler, their cookie selection is always fresh.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie – $2.75
- Oatmeal Raisin Cookie – $2.75
- Peanut Butter Cookie – $2.95
- Snickerdoodle – $2.75
- Brownie – $3.50
- Blondie – $3.50
Cookies are sold individually or in boxes of six for $15.00. The brownies are dense and fudgy, made with high-quality chocolate. They also offer a seasonal sugar cookie that changes throughout the year.
Pies And Cheesecakes
Magnolia Bakery isn’t just about cupcakes and pudding. They also have a solid selection of pies.
- Apple Pie (whole) – $28.00
- Pecan Pie (whole) – $32.00
- Pumpkin Pie (whole) – $26.00
- Cheesecake (whole) – $35.00
- Cheesecake (slice) – $6.50
Pies are available seasonally. Apple and pecan are year-round, while pumpkin is typically available from October through December. The cheesecake is New York-style, dense and creamy, and it comes with a graham cracker crust.
Breakfast Items
Many people don’t realize that Magnolia Bakery serves breakfast items in the morning. They open early and have a limited but tasty selection.
- Croissant – $3.50
- Chocolate Croissant – $4.00
- Blueberry Muffin – $3.75
- Banana Nut Bread (slice) – $3.95
- Cinnamon Roll – $4.25
- Bagel with Cream Cheese – $3.25
Breakfast items are available until 11:00 AM or until they sell out. The cinnamon rolls are particularly popular and often gone by mid-morning. They also offer a breakfast sandwich on a croissant for $6.50, which includes egg and cheese.
Beverages
You’ll need something to wash down all that sugar. Their drink menu is straightforward.
- Drip Coffee (12 oz) – $2.75
- Drip Coffee (16 oz) – $3.25
- Espresso – $2.95
- Cappuccino – $4.25
- Latte (12 oz) – $4.50
- Latte (16 oz) – $5.00
- Hot Chocolate – $3.95
- Iced Coffee (16 oz) – $3.75
- Bottled Water – $2.00
- Fresh Orange Juice – $4.50
They also offer a selection of specialty sodas and Italian sodas. A vanilla Italian soda will cost you $3.95. During the holiday season, they bring back their peppermint hot chocolate for $4.50.
Gluten-Free And Vegan Options
Magnolia Bakery has made an effort to be more inclusive with their menu. They offer a few gluten-free options that are clearly labeled.
- Gluten-Free Chocolate Cupcake – $4.75
- Gluten-Free Vanilla Cupcake – $4.75
- Gluten-Free Banana Pudding (8 oz) – $7.50
- Vegan Chocolate Cookie – $3.25
- Vegan Banana Bread (slice) – $4.25
These items are prepared in a separate area to avoid cross-contamination, but they do share the same kitchen. If you have a severe gluten allergy, you should mention it to the staff when ordering.
Seasonal And Limited Edition Items
Magnolia Bakery likes to keep things interesting with rotating seasonal offerings. Here’s what you can typically expect throughout the year.
Spring
- Lemon Cupcake – $4.50
- Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake – $4.50
- Key Lime Pie – $30.00 (whole)
Summer
- Blueberry Cheesecake Cupcake – $4.50
- Peach Cobbler Pudding – $7.00
- Raspberry White Chocolate Cookie – $3.25
Fall
- Pumpkin Cupcake – $4.50
- Maple Pecan Cookie – $3.25
- Caramel Apple Pie – $32.00 (whole)
Winter
- Peppermint Bark Cupcake – $4.50
- Gingerbread Cookie – $3.25
- Eggnog Pudding – $7.00
These seasonal items are popular and tend to sell out quickly. If you have your heart set on a particular seasonal flavor, its best to go early in the day or call ahead to check availability.
Ordering Tips And Tricks
To make your visit as smooth as possible, here are some practical tips.
- Go early. The lines can get long, especially on weekends. Arriving before 10 AM usually means a shorter wait.
- Know your order before you reach the counter. The staff moves fast and appreciates customers who are ready.
- Cash is still accepted, but cards are faster. They take all major credit cards.
- If you’re buying for a group, order a whole cake or party-size pudding. It’s more cost-effective than buying individual items.
- Check their social media for daily specials. They sometimes offer discounts on less busy days.
- Consider ordering online for pickup. This skips the line entirely and is available at most locations.
Location-Based Price Variations
Its important to note that prices are not uniform across all locations. The Magnolia Bakery in Dubai or London will have different pricing than the one in New York. Even within the US, the Los Angeles and Chicago locations may have slight price adjustments to account for local costs.
For example, the banana pudding at the West Village location in NYC is priced as listed above. But at their airport kiosks, you might pay a premium of 10-15%. If you’re visiting a franchise location, expect prices to be set by the local operator.
Value And Portion Sizes
Are these prices fair? Let’s break it down. The cupcakes are generous in size, and the frosting is thick and rich. One cupcake is easily enough for two people to share if you’re not looking for a big sugar hit.
The banana pudding is where you get the most value. The small size is actually quite filling, and the party size is enough for a large gathering. When you compare the price per ounce, the larger sizes are always a better deal.
Here’s a quick cost comparison:
- Two cupcakes cost more than one small pudding
- Four cookies cost more than a slice of cheesecake
- A whole pie is cheaper than buying eight individual slices
If you’re on a budget, the cookies are the most affordable treat. But if you want the signature experience, the banana pudding is worth the splurge.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most popular item on the Magnolia Bakery menu?
The banana pudding is by far their most famous item. It’s what most people come for, and it’s the item they’re known for worldwide.
Are there any items on the Magnolia Bakery menu that are under $3?
Yes, you can get a plain cookie for $2.75 or a bottle of water for $2.00. The drip coffee is also under $3 at $2.75 for a small.
Does Magnolia Bakery offer any discounts for large orders?
Yes, they offer bulk pricing on cupcakes when you buy by the half-dozen or dozen. Party-size puddings also offer better value per ounce than smaller sizes.
Can I order Magnolia Bakery items online?
Absolutely. They have an online ordering system through their website. You can order for pickup at most locations, and they also offer shipping for select items like their cupcake kits.
Are the prices on the Magnolia Bakery menu with prices the same at every location?
No, prices can vary slightly by location. Airport locations and international franchises typically have higher prices than their standard NYC locations.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
Magnolia Bakery offers a solid range of desserts at reasonable prices for the quality you receive. The portions are generous, and the ingredients are high-quality. While it’s not the cheapest bakery in town, you’re paying for a consistent, nostalgic experience that has stood the test of time.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick cookie or splurging on a whole layer cake for a birthday, you now have a clear picture of what everything costs. The banana pudding is the star of the show, but dont overlook their other offerings. The cheesecake and pies are equally impressive, just less talked about.
Next time you’re near a Magnolia Bakery, you can walk in with confidence, knowing exactly what to order and what it will cost. No surprises, just good dessert. And if you’re trying to decide between the pudding and a cupcake, go with the pudding. It’s the reason they’re famous, and it lives up to the hype.