Pizza lovers checking Fresh Pie Pizza prices will find options ranging from single slices to family-sized pies. This guide breaks down the full Fresh Pie Pizza Menu with Prices so you can plan your order and your budget before you walk in or call for delivery.
Fresh Pie keeps things simple. The menu focuses on classic pizzas, a few specialty pies, sides, and drinks. Prices vary a bit by location, but the ranges below give you a solid idea of what to expect.
Fresh Pie Pizza Menu With Prices
Below is a typical price list. Tax and delivery fees are not included. Some shops charge a little more in big citys, so treat these numbers as a guide.
Classic Pizzas
- Cheese Slice – $3.50
- Pepperoni Slice – $4.00
- Small Cheese Pizza (10 inch) – $9.99
- Medium Cheese Pizza (14 inch) – $13.99
- Large Cheese Pizza (18 inch) – $16.99
- Medium Pepperoni Pizza – $15.49
- Large Pepperoni Pizza – $18.49
Specialty Pies
These cost more becuase of the extra toppings. Most stores let you swap one ingredient at no charge.
- Meat Lovers (medium) – $18.99
- Meat Lovers (large) – $22.99
- Veggie Garden (medium) – $17.99
- Veggie Garden (large) – $21.49
- BBQ Chicken (medium) – $18.49
- BBQ Chicken (large) – $22.49
- White Garlic Pie (large) – $19.99
Sides And Extras
- Garlic Knots (6 pieces) – $4.99
- Cheesy Breadsticks – $6.49
- Chicken Wings (8 pieces) – $9.99
- Caesar Salad – $6.99
- Garden Salad – $5.99
- Marinara Cup – $0.75
- Ranch Cup – $0.75
Drinks And Desserts
- Fountain Soda (20 oz) – $2.29
- Bottled Water – $1.99
- Canned Soda – $1.79
- Cinnamon Twists – $4.49
- Chocolate Chip Cookie – $1.99
How To Order And Save Money
You do not need to pay full price every time. A few small habits cut your bill fast.
- Check the daily special. Many shops drop slice prices by 50 cents during lunch hours.
- Buy the large pie. A large cheese is often just $3 more then a medium, and it feeds two more people.
- Skip single slices for groups. If you are feeding four people, two large pies beat eight slices on price.
- Ask about combo deals. A large pizza plus wings and a soda usually saves you around $4.
- Join the rewards program. Most Fresh Pie locations give you a free pie after ten orders.
What Affects The Final Price
Your total depends on more than the menu board. Keep these factors in mind.
Location
City stores charge more than suburban ones. Rent and wages drive that gap. Expect a $1 to $2 difference on large pies.
Toppings
Each extra topping adds about $1.50 to $2.00 on a medium or large pie. Three toppings can push a $14 pizza past $19.
Delivery And Fees
Delivery runs $3 to $5 in most areas. Some stores also add a small service fee on card payments.
Crust Options
Thin crust is free. Stuffed crust or gluten-free crust adds $2 to $3 depending on the store.
Tips Before You Order
- Call ahead on weekends. Wait times can hit 45 minutes.
- Confirm prices by phone. Online menus sometimes lag behind in-store updates.
- Ask for the family deal if you have five or more people.
- Check your receipt. Wrong topping charges are easy to miss.
Fresh Pie Pizza prices stay reasonable compared to most chains. A single slice starts near $3.50, while a large specialty pie tops out around $23. Use the list above, watch for lunch specials, and you can feed a family without spending to much.