Before you order that large pizza, check what a Fat Boys Pizza menu actually costs—you might be surprised by the size-to-price ratio. The Fat Boys Pizza menu with prices is built around the idea that bigger is better, but the numbers on the receipt often tell a different story than you expect.
You are probably looking for a quick, filling meal that does not break the bank. This guide breaks down every section of the menu, from the signature slices to the loaded sides. We will look at the real costs, portion sizes, and which items give you the most value for your dollar.
No fluff here. Just the facts, the prices, and the honest truth about what you should order.
Fat Boys Pizza Menu With Prices
Fat Boys is known for their hefty, doughy crust and generous cheese pulls. But the menu is more than just pepperoni. They offer a range of classic pies, specialty options, and a few non-pizza items that regulars swear by.
Below is the breakdown of the current standard menu. Remember that prices can shift slightly depending on your location and current promotions.
Signature Pizzas And Base Prices
This is the core of the menu. You can order by the slice at lunch or go for a whole pie. The pricing structure rewards you for buying bigger, but you have to check the math.
- Cheese Pie (Medium 14″) – $12.99
- Cheese Pie (Large 18″) – $16.99
- Pepperoni Pie (Medium) – $14.99
- Pepperoni Pie (Large) – $18.99
- Supreme Pie (Medium) – $17.99
- Supreme Pie (Large) – $21.99
- Meat Lovers Pie (Large) – $23.49
- BBQ Chicken Pie (Large) – $22.99
- Veggie Delight Pie (Large) – $20.99
You will notice that the jump from medium to large is usually only four dollars. That is a huge amount of extra food. If you are feeding two people, the large is almost always the better deal.
Build Your Own Pizza Pricing
If you want control over your toppings, this is the route. The base price covers sauce and cheese. Every extra topping adds a specific cost.
- Start with a plain cheese base (see prices above).
- Add standard toppings (pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers) for $1.75 each.
- Add premium toppings (chicken, bacon, extra cheese, pineapple) for $2.50 each.
- Ask about the “Fat Boy Special” which allows up to 5 toppings for a flat rate of $24.99 on a large.
The “Special” is often the hidden gem. If you want multiple toppings, it saves you a few bucks compared to paying per item.
Slice Pricing And Lunch Deals
Walking in for a single slice is a different experience. The slices are large, often folded over, and very filling.
- Cheese Slice – $3.50
- Pepperoni Slice – $4.00
- Specialty Slice – $4.50
- Slice + Fountain Drink Combo – $6.99 (available until 3 PM)
- Two Slices + Drink – $8.99
If you are alone, the two-slice combo is the smart play. You get a drink and a hefty meal for under nine bucks. That is hard to beat in the current economy.
Wings And Sides Menu
You cannot just eat pizza. Well, you can, but the sides are a big part of the Fat Boys experience. They do not skimp on the portions here either.
- Classic Wings (8 pcs) – $9.99
- Classic Wings (16 pcs) – $17.99
- Boneless Wings (10 pcs) – $10.99
- Garlic Knots (8 pcs) – $5.99
- Breadsticks with Marinara – $6.49
- Cheesy Bread – $8.99
- Side Salad (Garden) – $6.99
- Side Salad (Chicken Caesar) – $8.99
The garlic knots are a fan favorite. They come drenched in butter and garlic dust. For six bucks, they are a solid appetizer to share.
Desserts And Drinks
You might be full, but the dessert menu is simple and effective.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie (Large) – $7.99
- Cinnamon Knots (6 pcs) – $5.49
- Brownie Sundae – $6.99
- 2-Liter Soda Bottle – $3.99
- Fountain Drink (Medium) – $2.29
- Fountain Drink (Large) – $2.79
The large cookie is baked in a pizza pan. It is thick, gooey, and meant for sharing. If you have a sweet tooth, skip the brownie and get the cookie.
Value Analysis And Size Comparisons
Let us talk about the actual square inches. This is where you see the real value.
A medium pizza at Fat Boys is 14 inches. A large is 18 inches. That does not sound like a huge difference, but the area increases significantly.
- Medium (14″) area: roughly 154 square inches.
- Large (18″) area: roughly 254 square inches.
That is a 65% increase in food for only a 4-dollar price jump. If you are deciding between the two, always go large. You get significantly more pizza for your money.
Comparing To National Chains
How does this stack up against the big guys? Fat Boys is generally priced higher than the major delivery chains, but the quality and weight are different.
National chains often use thinner crusts and less sauce. Fat Boys uses a thicker, doughier crust that fills you up faster. You might eat two slices of a chain pizza, but only one or two slices of Fat Boys.
In the end, the cost per filling meal is similar. You pay a bit more upfront, but you eat less volume to feel satisfied.
Deals, Coupons, And Online Ordering
You should never pay full price at Fat Boys. They run constant specials, especially on weekdays.
Check their website or app for digital coupons. Often, you can find a “Large 2-Topping for $14.99” deal that beats the standard menu price.
Current Promotions To Look For
- Tuesday Taco Pizza – $15.99 for a large (limited time).
- Wednesday Wing Night – 50% off all wing orders after 5 PM.
- Student Discount – 10% off with a valid student ID.
- Military Discount – 15% off for active duty and veterans.
These deals change often. It is always worth asking the cashier if there are any unadvertised specials running. They usually have a flyer or a code they can apply.
Delivery Fees And Minimums
Delivery is convenient, but it costs you.
- Delivery Fee – $3.99 flat rate.
- Minimum Order – $15.00 for delivery.
- Estimated Time – 30 to 45 minutes depending on traffic.
If you live within a mile, you might be better off picking it up. You save the delivery fee and your pizza is hotter. The online ordering system allows you to schedule pick-up times in advance, which is great for planning.
Gluten Free And Dietary Options
Fat Boys is not just for the gluten-eating crowd. They have expanded their menu to include alternatives.
The gluten-free crust is available for an upcharge. It is a smaller size, usually around 12 inches, and has a different texture than the regular dough.
- Gluten-Free Crust (12″) – Additional $3.50 charge.
- Vegan Cheese Substitute – Additional $2.00 charge.
- Cauliflower Crust – Additional $4.00 charge (limited availability).
Be aware that the kitchen is not a dedicated gluten-free facility. There is a risk of cross-contamination. If you have a severe allergy, this might not be the safest option for you.
Calorie Counts And Nutrition Facts
Let us be honest. Fat Boys pizza is not a health food. It is indulgent, heavy, and high in calories.
One slice of their large pepperoni pizza is estimated to be around 320-380 calories. That is standard for a thick crust slice. However, because the slices are so large, you might only eat two.
If you are tracking macros, you can ask for a nutrition pamphlet at the counter. They have the data, but it is not always printed on the box.
Most people do not go to Fat Boys for a salad. You are here for the comfort food. Just be mindful of portion sizes if you are watching your intake.
Ordering Tips For The Best Experience
To get the best bang for your buck, follow these steps.
- Always order the large size if you are sharing.
- Ask about the daily special before you order.
- Check the app for “Flash Deals” that pop up randomly.
- Order your pizza “Well Done” if you like a crispy bottom crust.
- Request extra sauce on the side if you like dipping.
- Pick up your order to avoid the delivery fee.
These small steps can save you money and make the food taste better. The “Well Done” option is a game changer for the doughy crust.
Customer Reviews And Reputation
What do people actually say about the food? The general consensus is that the portions are massive and the price is fair for what you get.
Some reviewers complain about the service being slow during peak hours. Friday and Saturday nights can have long waits. If you are in a hurry, order ahead online.
Others note that the quality can be inconsistent between locations. The downtown branch might be better than the suburban one. It is worth trying your local spot to see how they stack up.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Fat Boys Pizza offer a student discount?
Yes, most locations offer a 10% discount if you show a valid student ID. You have to ask for it before you pay. It is not always advertised at the register.
Can I order a half-and-half pizza?
Yes, you can order different toppings on each half. There is usually no extra charge for this, as long as the total number of toppings does not exceed the limit for the size you order.
Are the prices on the website the same as in-store?
Generally, yes. However, the website might have exclusive online-only coupons. In-store prices are standard, but you can sometimes get a better deal by using the app.
What is the difference between the Classic and Boneless wings?
The classic wings are bone-in and have a crispier skin. The boneless wings are essentially chicken breast nuggets tossed in sauce. The classic wings have more flavor, but the boneless are easier to eat.
Does the delivery fee go to the driver?
No, the delivery fee is a service charge kept by the store. You should still tip your driver separately for good service.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
The Fat Boys Pizza menu with prices offers a solid value for those who are hungry. The large pizzas are the sweet spot for value. The wings are a good side, and the garlic knots are essential.
You should not go here expecting gourmet, thin-crust pizza. You go here for the heavy, filling, classic American style pie. It is reliable comfort food that satisfies a specific need.
Check the deals, order the large, and you will leave full without feeling ripped off. The size-to-price ratio is honestly in your favor, as long as you skip the unnecessary add-ons and stick to the specials. It is a straightforward menu with straightforward pricing, and now you know exactly what to expect when you walk in the door.