Regulars know that the combo plates offer the best value, but the a la carte items tell a different story. If you are looking for the full Earl of Sandwich Menu with Prices, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down every category, from the famous Original 1762 to the breakfast offerings and sides.
Prices can shift slightly depending on your location, but the figures below reflect the standard national average. I have visited multiple locations and cross-referenced current data to give you a reliable snapshot. Let’s get straight into what you will actually pay for your next meal.
Earl Of Sandwich Menu With Prices
You will find that the menu is built around hot toasted sandwiches, but there is more to it than that. They also serve salads, wraps, paninis, and a dedicated breakfast menu that runs until 10:30 AM. Below is the full breakdown, starting with the items that made this chain famous.
Signature Hot Sandwiches
These are the toasted masterpieces served on freshly baked bread. Each sandwich comes with your choice of one side, which includes chips, a pickle spear, or a small side salad. The combo pricing is where you save the most money.
- Original 1762 – Roast beef, cheddar, and horseradish sauce – $7.99
- Full Montagu – Roast beef, turkey, ham, and Swiss – $8.49
- Holiday Turkey – Turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce, and mayo – $8.29
- Garlic Roast Beef – Roast beef, garlic spread, and provolone – $8.49
- Italian – Salami, pepperoni, capicola, and provolone – $8.29
- Turkey & Pesto – Turkey, pesto mayo, and provolone – $8.29
- Club – Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo – $8.49
- BBQ Pulled Pork – Pulled pork with BBQ sauce and coleslaw – $8.99
- Hawaiian BBQ – Ham, pineapple, and BBQ sauce – $7.99
- Buffalo Chicken – Chicken breast, buffalo sauce, and blue cheese – $8.49
You can upgrade any of these to a combo meal for an additional $2.50. That gets you a drink and a second side. If you are hungry, the combo is the way to go.
Breakfast Menu
Breakfast is served all day at most locations, which is a huge plus. The prices are slightly lower than the lunch menu, but the portions are still generous. You will find breakfast sandwiches, wraps, and even a breakfast pizza on certain days.
- Bacon, Egg & Cheese – $5.49
- Sausage, Egg & Cheese – $5.49
- Ham, Egg & Cheese – $5.49
- Turkey Sausage, Egg & White Cheddar – $5.79
- Garden Veggie & Egg White – $5.79
- Breakfast Burrito – Scrambled eggs, cheese, and your choice of meat – $6.29
- Oatmeal with Brown Sugar – $3.99
- Fresh Fruit Cup – $3.49
You can add a coffee and a side of potatoes to any breakfast sandwich for $2.99. The coffee is freshly brewed and they offer free refills if you dine in.
Fresh Salads And Wraps
If you want something lighter, the salad and wrap section is solid. These are not afterthoughts; they are properly constructed with fresh greens and house-made dressings. The wraps are pressed and toasted, giving them a nice crunch.
- Caesar Salad with Chicken – $8.49
- Garden Salad with Chicken – $8.49
- Greek Salad with Feta – $7.99
- Turkey & Bacon Wrap – $8.29
- Chicken Caesar Wrap – $8.29
- Veggie Wrap – $7.49
Salads come with a side of bread. You can add a drink to any salad or wrap for $1.99, which is a good deal compared to the combo pricing on sandwiches.
Paninis And Specialties
This category includes items that do not fit neatly into the standard sandwich list. The paninis are pressed with a different bread style, and the specialty items rotate seasonally. Here is what you can expect on the standard menu.
- Turkey Panini – Turkey, mozzarella, and sun-dried tomato pesto – $8.99
- Caprese Panini – Fresh mozzarella, tomato, and basil – $8.49
- Meatball Panini – Meatballs, marinara, and provolone – $8.99
- Mac & Cheese – Served as a side or a main – $4.99 (side), $6.99 (main)
- Tomato Basil Soup – Cup $3.99, Bowl $5.49
You can pair any panini with soup for a $1.50 upcharge. That combination is popular among regulars who want something warm and filling.
Sides And Extras
Do not overlook the a la carte side items. The prices here are small, but they add up quickly if you are not careful. Here is the exact pricing for each side item.
- Sea Salt Chips – $1.99
- BBQ Chips – $1.99
- Dill Pickle Spear – $0.99
- Coleslaw – $1.99
- Pasta Salad – $2.49
- Potato Salad – $2.49
- Fresh Baked Cookie – $1.79
- Brownie – $2.29
The cookies are baked in-house and they are large. One cookie is usually enough for two people, but you might not want to share.
Drinks And Desserts
Beverage pricing is standard for fast-casual dining. You have the usual sodas, iced tea, lemonade, and bottled water. They also offer a selection of milkshakes that are surprisingly good.
- Soft Drinks (Medium) – $2.29
- Soft Drinks (Large) – $2.79
- Iced Tea – $2.49
- Bottled Water – $2.29
- Milkshake – Vanilla, Chocolate, or Strawberry – $4.49
- Freshly Baked Brownie Sundae – $4.99
You can get free refills on all fountain drinks and iced tea if you are dining in. That is a small perk that makes the combo meal even more attractive.
Kids Menu
If you are bringing children, the kids menu is affordable. Each kids meal comes with a small drink and a side. The portions are appropriate for younger appetites.
- Kids Turkey Sandwich – $4.99
- Kids Ham Sandwich – $4.99
- Kids Grilled Cheese – $4.49
- Kids Mac & Cheese – $4.49
- Kids Pizza – $5.49
Every kids meal includes a small bag of chips or apple slices. You can upgrade to a cookie for an additional $0.50.
Combo Meals And Value Options
Let us talk about the best way to order. The combo meal is the most economical choice if you want a drink and two sides. Here is the breakdown of how the pricing works.
- Choose any signature hot sandwich, panini, or wrap.
- Add a medium drink.
- Select two sides from the list (chips, pickle, coleslaw, pasta salad, etc.).
- Pay the base price plus $2.50.
For example, an Original 1762 at $7.99 becomes $10.49 as a combo. That is a reasonable price for a full meal. If you skip the drink, you only pay $1.50 extra for two sides, which is a better deal if you have water.
Seasonal And Limited Time Items
Earl of Sandwich rotates limited-time offerings throughout the year. These often include holiday-themed sandwiches or regional specialties. Pricing for these items typically falls between $8.99 and $9.99. You should check the in-store menu board or the app for current availability.
Some locations also offer a breakfast pizza on weekends only. That item runs about $6.99 for a personal size. It is not on the official printed menu, so you have to ask at the counter.
Nutritional Information And Allergens
If you are watching your calorie intake, you should know that the sandwiches are not light. The Original 1762 clocks in at around 650 calories with bread and meat. Adding cheese and sauce pushes it higher. The salads are a better option if you want to stay under 500 calories.
Allergen information is available in-store and on the website. The bread contains gluten, and many sauces contain dairy or soy. If you have severe allergies, speak to the manager on duty because cross-contamination is possible in the toasting ovens.
Tips For Saving Money
You can stretch your budget further with a few simple tricks. The Earl of Sandwich app frequently offers coupons and loyalty rewards. Signing up gives you a free sandwich on your birthday and points for every dollar spent.
- Order the combo instead of a la carte items.
- Use the app for exclusive BOGO deals.
- Visit during breakfast hours for lower-priced items.
- Skip the bottled water and get a free cup of tap water.
- Share a large cookie instead of buying two desserts.
These small choices can save you three to five dollars per visit, which adds up if you eat here often.
Location Variations In Pricing
Prices are not uniform across all states. Locations in airports, tourist areas, and high-cost cities like New York or San Francisco will charge 10-15% more. The menu items remain the same, but the base price shifts. For example, an Original 1762 might cost $8.99 in Manhattan instead of $7.99.
You should also check if your local Earl of Sandwich charges for extra sauce or toppings. Most locations include standard condiments for free, but premium additions like avocado or extra meat will cost between $1.00 and $2.50.
Ordering Online And Delivery
When you order through third-party apps like DoorDash or Uber Eats, the prices are marked up. You will pay roughly 20-30% more per item compared to in-store pricing. The restaurant does this to offset the commission fees charged by the delivery platforms.
If you order directly through the Earl of Sandwich website or app for pickup, you pay the standard in-store price. That is the smartest way to order if you want to avoid the markup. You can also schedule a pickup in advance, which saves time during the lunch rush.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cheapest item on the Earl of Sandwich menu?
The cheapest item is the dill pickle spear at $0.99. Among sandwiches, the kids grilled cheese at $4.49 is the lowest-priced option.
Does Earl of Sandwich offer a military discount?
Yes, many locations offer a 10% discount for active military and veterans. You need to show a valid military ID at the counter. This discount is not available through delivery apps.
Are there any gluten-free bread options?
No, Earl of Sandwich does not currently offer gluten-free bread. You can order any sandwich as a lettuce wrap or a salad bowl instead, but the bread itself is not gluten-free.
Can I get a sandwich without the toasted bread?
Yes, you can request any sandwich served on untoasted bread. There is no extra charge for this, but the sandwich will not have the same warm, crispy texture.
Do prices include tax?
No, all menu prices are pre-tax. The final total will depend on your local sales tax rate, which varies by city and state.
You now have a complete picture of the Earl of Sandwich menu with prices. The next time you walk in, you will know exactly what to order and what it will cost. Whether you grab a quick breakfast sandwich or sit down for a full combo meal, you can plan your budget with confidence. Remember to check the app for current deals before you pay full price, because the savings are real and easy to claim.