Cherry Street Tavern pairs cold drafts with pub classics, and a quick look at the Cherry Street Tavern Menu with Prices shows why locals keep coming back. The menu stays small on purpose, so the kitchen can focus on doing a few things right.
Below you’ll find the full price breakdown, plus tips on what to order and how to save a few bucks on your visit.
What You Need To Know Before You Go
Cherry Street Tavern is a casual spot. No dress code, no reservations for small groups, and no surprises on the bill.
- Open daily from 11 a.m. to midnight
- Kitchen closes at 10 p.m. on weekdays
- Cards accepted, but the ATM near the door gets used a lot
- Happy hour runs 3 to 6 p.m. Monday through Friday
Prices below are current as of this write-up. They can shift with the seasons, so double check the board behind the bar if something looks off.
Cherry Street Tavern Menu With Prices
Here is the core menu, grouped the same way it appears in house.
Starters And Shareables
- Loaded Nachos — $11.50
- Fried Pickles — $7.25
- Wings (8 count) — $12.00
- Pretzel Sticks with Beer Cheese — $8.75
- Chili Cheese Fries — $9.50
Burgers And Sandwiches
- Classic Cheeseburger — $12.75
- Bacon BBQ Burger — $14.25
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich — $12.00
- Philly Cheesesteak — $13.50
- Fish Sandwich — $12.95
All sandwiches come with fries or chips. Onion rings cost $2 more.
Pub Classics And Entrees
- Fish and Chips — $15.50
- Shepherds Pie — $14.00
- Chicken Tenders Basket — $11.75
- Steak Night Special (Fridays only) — $19.95
Drinks And Drafts
- Domestic Draft (pint) — $5.00
- Craft Draft (pint) — $7.50
- Bottle Beer — $4.50
- House Wine (glass) — $7.00
- Well Cocktails — $8.00
- Soda and Iced Tea — $2.75
Desserts
- Cheesecake Slice — $6.50
- Brownie Sundae — $7.00
How To Order Without Overspending
You don’t need a big budget to eat well here. A few small moves keep the tab low.
- Go during happy hour. Drafts drop by $1.50 and most starters are half price.
- Split the nachos. One order feeds three people easy.
- Pick the daily special. It changes each day and usually costs under $13.
- Skip the add-ons. Extra cheese and bacon add up fast.
- Order water with your meal, then grab one draft after.
Tuesday is burger night, and the classic cheeseburger drops to $9.99. That is the best deal on the whole menu.
What Regulars Usually Order
If it’s your first time, keep it simple. The fish and chips and the bacon BBQ burger are the two most ordered plates.
For drinks, the local craft draft rotates every few weeks. Ask the bartender what’s fresh. They will pour you a sample if you ask nice.
Best Times To Visit
- Weekday lunch: quiet, fast service
- Friday after 7 p.m.: loud and packed, expect a wait
- Sunday afternoon: good for groups and game days
Final Word On Value
For a neighborhood tavern, the pricing sits right in the middle. You won’t find cheaper drafts nearby, and the food portions are fair for what you pay.
Plan for about $25 per person if you get a meal and two drinks. Go during happy hour and you can cut that closer to $15. Either way, you leave full and your wallet stays intact.