At Caseys Pizza and Sub Shop, the pricing structure differs greatly between their New York-style slices and their loaded sub sandwiches. When you look at the Caseys Pizza and Sub Shop Menu with Prices, you will notice that the cost of a meal depends heavily on portion size and the specific ingredients you choose. This local favorite has built a reputation for serving generous portions without breaking your wallet.
Whether you are stopping in for a quick lunch or feeding the whole family, knowing what to expect before you order is helpful. You want to know exactly what you are paying for, and you want to make sure the food is worth it. This guide breaks down the entire menu, item by item, so you can plan your next visit with confidence.
Why The Menu Pricing Matters To You
Nobody likes surprises when the bill arrives. You are probably looking for a place that offers solid value for your hard-earned money. Casey’s has managed to keep their prices competitive with other local pizzerias, but they also offer some unique options that you won’t find everywhere else.
The key is to understand how they structure their charges. For instance, they charge extra for certain toppings, and they have different price points for dine-in versus take-out on some specials. You should always check the current board at the counter, but this guide gives you a solid baseline for budgeting.
Understanding The Slice Versus The Whole Pie
If you are eating alone, a single slice is usually the most economical choice. However, if you are sharing, buying a whole pie is often a better deal per square inch. You have to do a little math in your head, but the savings are usually worth it when you have two or more people eating.
They also run a lunch special on weekdays that includes a slice and a drink. That combo price is usually lower than buying those items separately. Keep an eye out for that if you are on a tight schedule and a tighter budget.
Caseys Pizza And Sub Shop Menu With Prices
Here is the full breakdown of the standard menu items you can expect to find. Please remember that prices can change based on supply costs, but these figures reflect the most recent standard pricing structure. Always ask the cashier if you see a discrepancy, because local specials might apply.
New York Style Pizzas
The pizza is the star of the show here. They use a thin crust that gets crispy on the bottom but stays foldable in the middle. You can order by the slice, which is large and floppy, or you can order a full pie for the table.
- Plain Cheese Slice – $3.25
- Pepperoni Slice – $3.75
- Supreme Slice – $4.25
- Cheese Pie (16″) – $16.99
- Pepperoni Pie (16″) – $19.49
- Supreme Pie (16″) – $22.99
- White Pie (16″) – $18.99
You can add extra toppings to any whole pie for a fee. Standard toppings like mushrooms, onions, or green peppers cost about $1.50 each. Premium toppings like bacon or extra cheese will run you closer to $2.25 per topping. They also offer a gluten-free crust for an additional $3.00 upcharge on any pie size.
Specialty Pizza Options
Beyond the basics, they have a few house specialties that are worth trying. The “Meat Lovers” is loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon. The “Veggie Delight” comes with spinach, tomatoes, black olives, and artichoke hearts. These specialty pies are pre-priced and usually cost around $24.99 for a large.
You can also ask for a “Half and Half” pizza if you cannot decide. They will split the pie right down the middle with two different sets of toppings. This does not cost extra, which is a nice perk for indecisive eaters.
Loaded Sub Sandwiches
Their subs are served on a fresh-baked Italian roll that is soft on the inside and crusty on the outside. You have the option to get them “hot” or “cold.” Hot subs are toasted in the oven with cheese melted on top. Cold subs are stacked high with deli meat and fresh veggies.
- Meatball Sub (8″) – $8.99
- Meatball Sub (12″) – $11.49
- Chicken Parm Sub (8″) – $9.49
- Chicken Parm Sub (12″) – $12.29
- Italian Cold Cut (8″) – $8.49
- Italian Cold Cut (12″) – $10.99
- Turkey and Cheese (8″) – $8.99
- Turkey and Cheese (12″) – $11.49
Every sub comes with lettuce, tomato, onion, and your choice of oil and vinegar or mayonnaise. They also have a hot pepper relish that you can ask for on the side. It adds a nice kick without overpowering the other flavors.
Build Your Own Sub
If you do not see what you want on the menu, you can build your own. You pick the bread, the protein, and the cheese. The base price for an 8-inch sub is $7.99, and a 12-inch is $10.49. Then you add premium meats or cheeses for an extra cost.
Roast beef, pastrami, or buffalo chicken will add about $1.50 to the base price. Adding bacon or avocado will cost you an extra $1.00. They have a wide selection of cheeses including provolone, swiss, and american, all of which are included in the base price.
Sides And Appetizers
No meal is complete without a side. They offer the standard fare that you would expect from a pizza shop. These items are great for sharing, or for making a meal out of several smaller bites.
- Garlic Knots (6 pieces) – $4.99
- Garlic Knots (12 pieces) – $8.49
- French Fries – $3.49
- Seasoned Wedges – $3.99
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces) – $6.99
- Chicken Wings (6 pieces) – $7.99
- Chicken Wings (12 pieces) – $13.99
The garlic knots are brushed with a garlic butter sauce and sprinkled with parmesan. They come with a side of marinara for dipping. The wings are available in mild, medium, hot, or BBQ sauce. You can also get them “naked” if you prefer to sauce them yourself at home.
Salads And Fresh Options
If you are trying to eat a bit lighter, they have several salad options. These are not just afterthoughts; they are actually quite large and filling. You can add chicken to any salad for a small upcharge.
- House Salad – $6.49
- Caesar Salad – $6.99
- Antipasto Salad – $8.99
- Grilled Chicken Salad – $9.49
All salads come with your choice of dressing on the side. They have ranch, blue cheese, Italian, balsamic vinaigrette, and thousand island. The antipasto salad is loaded with ham, salami, provolone, and pepperoncini. It is a meal in itself.
Desserts And Drinks
They have a few sweet treats to finish off your meal. These are simple desserts, but they hit the spot. You can also grab a fountain drink or a bottled soda to wash everything down.
- Canoli (1 piece) – $3.49
- Tiramisu – $4.99
- NY Cheesecake – $4.49
- Fountain Drink – $2.29
- Bottled Water – $1.99
- 2-Liter Soda – $3.49
The canoli is filled fresh to order, so the shell stays crispy. The tiramisu is made in-house and has a strong coffee flavor. If you are dining in, they offer free refills on fountain drinks, which is a great deal.
Daily Specials And Combo Deals
To get the best value, you should visit on specific days of the week. They run daily specials that can save you a significant amount of money. These specials are usually advertised on their social media pages, but here is the general schedule.
Tuesday is typically “Taco Tuesday” where they offer a taco pizza for a discounted rate. Wednesday is “Wing Wednesday” with half-price wings after 4 PM. Thursday is “Sub Night” where you can get a free drink with the purchase of any 12-inch sub.
Lunch Specials For The Work Crowd
During the weekdays from 11 AM to 2 PM, they offer a specific lunch menu. This is designed to get you in and out quickly. You get a smaller portion, but the price is right.
- Two Slices and a Soda – $7.99
- Small Sub and Chips – $8.49
- Personal Pizza and Salad – $9.99
These lunch combos are the most popular items on the menu during the midday rush. If you arrive after 1:30 PM, they might run out of the personal pizza dough, so get there early if you want that specific deal.
How To Order For A Group Or Party
If you are feeding a crowd, you should call ahead. They offer party trays and catering options that are not listed on the regular menu. You can get a “Party Sub” that is three feet long, which is perfect for a game day gathering.
For large orders, they usually require 24 hours notice. This ensures they have enough fresh dough and ingredients on hand. You can also order sheet pizzas, which are rectangular and feed about 20 people. These are great for office parties or school events.
Pricing For Party Trays
Party trays are priced by the tray, not by the pound. A standard party sub (3 feet) costs around $49.99. A sheet pizza (18″ x 26″) costs about $54.99 depending on the toppings. You can mix and match toppings on a sheet pizza, but they charge per topping type.
They also offer a “Meat and Cheese” tray for $39.99, which includes assorted deli meats, cheeses, and rolls. This is a good option if you want people to build their own sandwiches. All party orders come with disposable serving utensils and napkins.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions that customers ask about the menu and pricing. This should help clear up any confusion before you place your order.
Does Casey’s Pizza Offer A Student Discount?
Yes, they offer a 10% discount to students with a valid school ID. This applies to dine-in and take-out orders, but it cannot be combined with any other special or coupon.
Are There Any Hidden Fees For Delivery?
They do charge a delivery fee of $2.99 for orders under $20. If your order is over $20, the delivery fee is waived. The delivery area is limited to about a 5-mile radius from the shop.
Can I Order Gluten-free Subs?
They do have a gluten-free sub roll available, but it is only offered in the 8-inch size. There is a $2.50 upcharge for this option. They also have gluten-free pizza crust available for a similar price.
Do They Have A Rewards Program?
Yes, they have a punch card system. For every $10 you spend, you get a stamp. Once you collect 10 stamps, you get $10 off your next order. You have to ask for the card at the register before you pay.
Is The Price On The Menu Inclusive Of Tax?
No, the prices listed on the menu do not include sales tax. The tax is added at the register when you check out. This is standard practice for most restaurants in the area.
Final Thoughts On Your Visit
You now have a clear picture of what to expect when you walk through the door. The menu is straightforward, and the staff is usually happy to answer questions if you are unsure about something. The portions are large, so you might want to share or plan for leftovers.
If you are watching your budget, stick to the lunch specials or the daily deals. If you are celebrating something, splurging on a specialty pizza or a party tray is a good way to go. The food is consistent, and the service is generally fast, even during peak hours.
Remember that the prices listed here are a guide, not a guarantee. Supply chain issues can cause prices to fluctuate. It is always a good idea to confirm the final price before you commit to a large order. This way, there are no surprises when you go to pay.
Go ahead and give them a try. You will likely find that the quality of the food matches the reasonable prices. It is a solid choice for a casual meal, whether you are a local resident or just passing through town. The combination of good pizza and hearty subs makes it a versatile spot for any appetite.