Casey’s Carry-out Pizza Menu with Prices is one of the first things you will see when you walk into any Casey’s General Store. The exact keyword Casey’s Carry-out Pizza Menu with Prices is easy to find online, but the actual in-store board can be a little confusing if you are in a hurry. You have a few basic choices, and the price changes based on the size and the number of toppings you pick.
Casey’s is famous for their breakfast pizza, but the carry-out menu is a different beast. It focuses on traditional round pizzas, not the sheet pan style. You can order a small, medium, or large. The pricing is straight forward, but the specialty options like the Taco Pizza or the BBQ Chicken will cost you more than a standard pepperoni.
Let’s break down the current menu and prices so you know exactly what to expect when you call or order online. We will cover the base cheese, the one-topping price, and the premium specialty pies.
Casey’s Carry-out Pizza Menu With Prices
Casey’s uses a tiered pricing system for their carry-out pizzas. The base price is for a plain cheese pizza. After that, you add a charge for each topping you want. The specialty pizzas are pre-set with multiple toppings, so they sit at the highest price point. Remember that prices can vary slightly by location because franchise owners set their own final numbers.
Here is the standard price structure you will see at most corporate locations. We are using the national average, but you might see a difference of fifty cents to a dollar depending on your state.
- Small (10-inch) Cheese: $8.99
- Medium (12-inch) Cheese: $11.49
- Large (14-inch) Cheese: $13.99
- Small (10-inch) One Topping: $9.99
- Medium (12-inch) One Topping: $12.99
- Large (14-inch) One Topping: $15.49
Those prices are for the standard round pizza. If you want a thin crust, it is usually the same price as the hand-tossed. The deep dish is not part of the carry-out round menu. That is a separate item. You should always check the app for the most accurate local pricing.
Additional Topping Costs
Once you go past one topping, the price goes up incrementally. The cost per additional topping is not huge, but it adds up fast if you want a supreme. Here is the typical charge for adding extra items beyond the first one.
- Small: $1.00 per extra topping
- Medium: $1.25 per extra topping
- Large: $1.50 per extra topping
So, if you order a large pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms, you are looking at the base cheese price of $13.99 plus the first topping cost. Wait, the math is a little different. The one-topping price is already set. You pay the one-topping price, then add the cost for the second and third toppings.
For a large, that means you pay $15.49 for the first topping, then add $1.50 for the second, and another $1.50 for the third. Your total would be $18.49 before tax. That is a fair price for a large pizza with three toppings.
Specialty Pizza Price List
Casey’s has a few signature specialty pizzas that you cannot customize without changing the price. These are the ones that come with a specific set of ingredients already on them. The specialty pizzas are more expensive because they use premium meats and sauces.
Here are the standard specialty options and their average prices.
- BBQ Chicken Pizza: Small $12.99, Medium $15.99, Large $18.99
- Taco Pizza: Small $12.49, Medium $15.49, Large $18.49
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza: Small $12.99, Medium $15.99, Large $18.99
- Supreme Pizza: Small $12.49, Medium $15.49, Large $18.49
- Meat Lovers Pizza: Small $12.99, Medium $15.99, Large $18.99
The Taco Pizza is a fan favorite. It comes with refried beans, taco seasoned beef, and a special sauce. You add the cold toppings like lettuce and tomatoes after it comes out of the oven. The price reflects the extra prep work.
You can also build your own version of these specialty pizzas by selecting all the individual toppings. That will usually cost you more than just ordering the specialty. It is always cheaper to pick the pre-set option if you want those specific ingredients.
Breakfast Pizza Pricing
While this article is about carry-out pizza, you cannot ignore the breakfast pizza. It is available all day at most locations. The carry-out menu includes it, and the pricing is similar to the specialty round pizzas. However, the breakfast pizza is a sheet pizza, not a round one.
The breakfast pizza is cut into squares. It has a gravy or cheese sauce base, scrambled eggs, and your choice of sausage, bacon, or both. The price is usually based on a quarter sheet, half sheet, or full sheet.
- Quarter Sheet (Serves 2-3): $10.99
- Half Sheet (Serves 4-6): $17.99
- Full Sheet (Serves 8-10): $25.99
These breakfast sheet prices are for the classic sausage or bacon version. If you want the “Loaded” version with extra cheese and both meats, you will pay about two dollars more per size. The carry-out menu usually lists these separately.
How To Order To Save Money
If you are watching your budget, you need to be smart about how you order. The per-pie pricing model means you get a better deal when you buy a larger pizza. A large cheese at $13.99 is a much better value per square inch than a small at $8.99.
Here are a few tips to get the most out of your order without overspending.
- Stick to one or two toppings: The jump from two toppings to three toppings on a large adds $1.50. It does not sound like much, but it adds up.
- Check the daily specials: Casey’s often runs a Monday special on large one-topping pizzas. You can sometimes get them for $11.99.
- Use the app for coupons: The Casey’s app has exclusive digital coupons that you cannot use in the store. You can often find a deal for 20% off your entire carry-out order.
- Consider the lunch combo: Some locations offer a personal pizza and a drink for around $7.99 during lunch hours. This is not on the regular menu, so you have to ask.
You should also ask about the “Mix and Match” deals. Sometimes Casey’s lets you combine a carry-out pizza with a six-pack of soda for a discount. These promotions change frequently, so it is best to ask the cashier directly.
Comparing Sizes And Value
It is easy to think that buying two small pizzas is better than one large. That is rarely true. A large 14-inch pizza gives you about 154 square inches of pizza. A small 10-inch gives you about 78 square inches. Two smalls give you 156 square inches.
However, two small one-topping pizzas will cost you $19.98. One large one-topping pizza is only $15.49. You get almost the same amount of food for $4.50 less. Always go for the larger size if you are feeding more than one person.
The medium is the worst value on the menu. It is only two inches bigger than the small, but the price jump is often more than two dollars. You are better off spending the extra dollar to go from a medium to a large. The large is the sweet spot for value.
Customization And Premium Toppings
Casey’s has standard toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms. They also have premium toppings that cost extra. These are things like grilled chicken, bacon, and feta cheese. The premium toppings are not included in the standard per-topping price.
If you want grilled chicken on your pizza, you will pay an additional $2.00 to $2.50 on top of the regular topping price. This is true for any size. The same goes for the alfredo sauce base. If you swap the red sauce for alfredo, there is usually a $1.00 upcharge.
You can also ask for extra cheese. That is considered a premium topping. It will cost you about $1.75 on a small, $2.00 on a medium, and $2.50 on a large. It is worth it because Casey’s uses a good mozzarella blend, but you should know the cost upfront.
Gluten Free And Alternative Crusts
Casey’s does offer a gluten-free crust for their carry-out pizzas. It is a small 10-inch crust only. The gluten-free option adds about $3.00 to the base price of the pizza. So a gluten-free cheese pizza will run you around $11.99.
The gluten-free crust is a thin, pre-made crust. It is not the same as their hand-tossed dough. It gets crispy, but it is a bit more fragile. You cannot get a gluten-free large pizza. The small is the only option available at most stores.
They also have a thin crust option for the regular sizes. This is not gluten-free, but it is a different dough. The thin crust does not cost extra. It is the same price as the hand-tossed. You just have to specify that you want it when you order.
Online Ordering And Pickup Process
Ordering your carry-out pizza online is the easiest way to see the exact prices for your location. The website and app will show you the current menu with the correct tax and any available coupons. You can pay online or at the store.
When you arrive, you do not have to wait in the regular checkout line. There is usually a designated pickup area near the counter. You tell the cashier your name, and they grab your order from the warmer. It is fast and efficient.
You can also call the store directly. The phone number is listed on the Casey’s website. Calling is helpful if you want to ask about specific specials that are not listed online. The staff is usually friendly and can tell you the exact price over the phone.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Casey’s Have A Lunch Special For Carry-out Pizza?
Yes, many locations offer a personal pizza lunch combo. It usually includes a small one-topping pizza and a drink for around $7.99. This deal is only available from 11 AM to 2 PM on weekdays. You should ask your local store if they participate.
Is The Casey’s Breakfast Pizza Cheaper Than The Regular Pizza?
No, the breakfast pizza is actually more expensive per square inch. A quarter sheet costs about $10.99 and only serves two people. A large round pizza costs $13.99 and serves three to four people. The breakfast pizza is a treat, not a budget option.
Can I Use A Coupon On The Specialty Pizzas?
Most of the time, no. The specialty pizzas are excluded from the standard percentage-off coupons. However, sometimes Casey’s runs a specific promotion on the Taco Pizza. You have to check the app to see the current exclusions.
Why Is The Price Different On The App Than In The Store?
The app sometimes shows a higher price because it includes the estimated tax. The in-store price is pre-tax. Also, the app might have dynamic pricing based on demand. If it is a busy Friday night, the app price could be slightly higher.
Does Casey’s Price Match Their Competitors?
No, Casey’s does not price match other pizza chains. Their pricing is set by the franchise owner. They compete on quality and the convenience of being inside a gas station, not on being the cheapest option in town.
You should always double check the final price when you pick up your order. Casey’s has a good reputation for accuracy, but mistakes can happen. Look at the receipt before you leave the counter. If the price is higher than what the menu board said, ask the cashier to explain the difference.
The menu board prices are the base prices. They do not include the local sales tax. They also do not include any delivery fees if you are using a third party app. The carry-out price is the cheapest way to get Casey’s pizza, since you are not paying for delivery.
In summary, the Casey’s carry-out pizza menu is straightforward. You have three sizes and a handful of specialty options. The prices are competitive with other regional chains. A large one-topping pizza for around fifteen dollars is a solid deal, especially considering the quality of the ingredients.
Just remember to check the app for digital coupons before you order. That is where you will find the best discounts. And if you are feeding a crowd, skip the smalls and mediums. Go straight for the large to get the best value for your money.