The best meals start with a menu that makes sense for both your taste buds and your wallet. If you are looking for fresh catches, crispy fried platters, or buttery shrimp without the guesswork, you need a clear price guide. That is exactly why we put together this breakdown of Captain Steve’s Seafood Menu with Prices, so you know what to expect before you even sit down.
You do not want to show up hungry and have to do math in your head. This guide gives you the real numbers, the portion sizes, and the best value picks. Let us walk through the entire menu so you can order with confidence and no surprises at the register.
Captain Steve’s Seafood Menu With Prices
Captain Steve’s is known for simple, honest seafood. The menu is not overly fancy, but it is packed with classics that keep locals coming back. Below is the full price list for the most popular items, organized by category so you can find what you need fast.
Appetizers And Starters
You might want to share a starter or grab something quick while you wait for your main dish. Here are the usual options and their current prices.
- Fried Calamari – $9.99 (served with marinara and lemon wedge)
- Shrimp Cocktail (6 pieces) – $10.49
- Captain’s Crab Dip – $11.99 (comes with toasted bread points)
- Clam Chowder (cup) – $4.99
- Clam Chowder (bowl) – $6.49
- Steamed Mussels (1 lb) – $12.99
- Garlic Bread with Cheese – $5.49
- Onion Rings (basket) – $6.99
If you are really hungry, the crab dip is the best bang for your buck. It is thick, creamy, and has real lump crab meat, not just filling.
Fried Seafood Platters
This is the heart of the menu. Every platter comes with your choice of two sides, usually fries, coleslaw, hush puppies, or a baked potato. The prices below reflect the standard dinner portion.
- Fish and Chips (2 pieces) – $13.99
- Fish and Chips (3 pieces) – $16.49
- Shrimp Platter (12 shrimp) – $15.99
- Shrimp Platter (18 shrimp) – $19.99
- Oyster Platter (12 oysters) – $16.99
- Scallop Platter (10 scallops) – $18.49
- Captain’s Combo (fish, shrimp, and scallop) – $21.99
- Seafood Sampler (fish, shrimp, oyster, and clam strips) – $24.99
For a first timer, the Captain’s Combo is a safe bet. You get a little bit of everything and it is not too greasy. The batter is light and crispy, not heavy like some places.
Grilled And Broiled Options
Not everyone wants fried food. If you are watching your calories or just prefer a cleaner taste, the grill section has some good choices. These come with the same sides as the fried platters.
- Grilled Salmon Fillet – $17.99
- Broiled Flounder – $16.49
- Grilled Shrimp Skewer (10 shrimp) – $15.99
- Blackened Mahi Mahi – $18.99
- Grilled Seafood Combo (salmon and shrimp) – $22.49
The grilled salmon is usually cooked perfectly, flaky on the inside with a slight char on the outside. Ask for extra lemon if you like a tangy finish.
Captain’s Signature Dishes
These are the house specials that you will not find on every seafood joint menu. They take a bit longer to prepare, but the flavor is worth the wait.
- Shrimp Alfredo Pasta – $16.99
- Crab Stuffed Flounder – $21.49
- Seafood Gumbo (bowl) – $8.99
- Shrimp Po’ Boy Sandwich – $12.99
- Lobster Roll (served cold with butter) – $19.99
- Captain’s Jambalaya – $17.49
The crab stuffed flounder is the most popular signature dish. It comes with a generous scoop of crab filling and is baked, not fried, which keeps it moist.
Baskets And Sandwiches
If you want a lighter lunch or a smaller portion, the baskets are a good middle ground. They come with fries and a small coleslaw.
- Fish Sandwich Basket – $10.99
- Shrimp Basket (10 shrimp) – $11.99
- Clam Strip Basket – $12.49
- Chicken Tender Basket (for non-seafood eaters) – $9.49
- Crab Cake Sandwich – $13.99
The crab cake sandwich is a hidden gem. It is mostly crab meat with just enough breadcrumb to hold it together, and it is served on a toasted brioche bun.
Kids Menu
Bringing the little ones? The kids menu is simple and affordable. Each meal comes with a small drink and a side of fries or apple slices.
- Kids Fish Sticks (3 pieces) – $6.99
- Kids Popcorn Shrimp – $7.49
- Kids Grilled Cheese – $5.99
- Kids Chicken Tenders (2 pieces) – $6.49
Portions are decent for children under 10. If your kid is a big eater, you might want to order an extra side of fries for $2.49.
Sides And Extras
Sometimes you just need a little extra on the side. Here are the ala carte options and their prices.
- French Fries – $3.49
- Coleslaw – $2.99
- Hush Puppies (4 pieces) – $3.99
- Baked Potato with Butter – $3.49
- Steamed Vegetables – $4.29
- Side Salad – $4.99
- Extra Tartar Sauce – $0.75
- Extra Cocktail Sauce – $0.75
Do not forget to ask for extra lemon wedges, they are free but you have to request them.
Desserts And Drinks
You might be full, but there is always room for something sweet. The dessert menu is short but satisfying.
- Key Lime Pie – $5.99
- Chocolate Lava Cake – $6.49
- Cheesecake (seasonal flavor) – $6.99
- Soft Drinks (refillable) – $2.99
- Sweet Tea – $2.99
- Fresh Brewed Iced Tea – $2.99
The key lime pie is tart and creamy, a great way to end a heavy meal. If you are sharing, order one slice and two forks, they will bring extra plates.
Daily Specials And Deals
Captain Steve’s runs a few weekly specials that are not always on the printed menu. It is worth asking your server what is available.
- Monday: Half-Price Appetizers (dine-in only, after 3 PM)
- Wednesday: Fish and Chips for $10.99
- Friday: All-You-Can-Eat Fried Shrimp – $24.99
- Sunday: Early Bird Special (4 PM to 6 PM) – 20% off any platter
These deals change seasonally, so do not be upset if they are not running when you visit. The Friday shrimp special is usually the busiest night, so arrive early or expect a wait.
Pricing Notes And Tips
Prices listed here are accurate as of the last menu update, but they can change without notice. Here are a few tips to keep your bill reasonable.
- Always ask if the market price applies to any fish. Some catches like grouper or snapper are priced daily.
- Split a platter with a friend. The portions are generous and you can ask for an extra plate for free.
- Skip the bottled water and order tap water. It saves you $3 and tastes the same.
- Check the board near the register for any unadvertised specials.
- If you are dining with a group of 4 or more, ask about the family feast option, it is not on the menu but they often offer it.
One thing to watch out for is the substitution policy. If you swap a side, they might charge an extra $1.50. It is not a big deal, but good to know before you ask.
What Is Worth The Money
If you are on a budget, the fish sandwich basket at $10.99 is the best value. It is a full piece of fish, not a thin patty, and the fries are plentiful. For a bigger appetite, the Captain’s Combo at $21.99 gives you three proteins and two sides, which is enough for two light eaters.
The most overpriced item is probably the lobster roll. At $19.99, it is good but not great, and you can get a better one at a dedicated lobster shack. Stick to the fried platters or the grilled salmon for the best quality-to-price ratio.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people have about the menu and pricing.
Does Captain Steve’s offer a senior discount?
Yes, they offer a 10% discount for guests over 65. You just need to ask your server before you pay, it is not automatically applied.
Are there any gluten-free options on the menu?
Yes, the grilled items are gluten-free if you ask for no croutons on the salad. The fries are cooked in a shared fryer, so there is a risk of cross-contamination. Let your server know if you have a serious allergy.
Can I order takeout or delivery?
Takeout is available and you can call ahead to place your order. Delivery is available through third-party apps like DoorDash and Uber Eats, but the prices on those apps are slightly higher due to service fees.
Is there a dress code?
No, it is a casual family restaurant. You will see people in flip-flops and others in business casual. Come as you are.
Do they have a happy hour?
Yes, from 3 PM to 6 PM on weekdays, appetizers are 25% off and select drinks are $1 off. It is a good time to try the calamari or crab dip without spending too much.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
Captain Steve’s offers a solid seafood experience at fair prices. The fried items are the stars, but the grilled options hold their own. You will not find any fancy molecular gastronomy here, just good, honest food that fills you up.
Remember to check the daily specials board and ask your server about any market price fish. The menu is straightforward, but a little insider knowledge goes a long way. Whether you are a local or just passing through, this price guide should help you order like a regular.
So next time you are near the coast and hungry for seafood, you know exactly what to expect. Bring your appetite, skip the appetizer if you want the combo platter, and save room for the key lime pie. Your wallet and your stomach will both thank you.
One last tip: the parking lot fills up fast on weekends. If you see a spot near the back, take it. You can always walk a few extra steps, and the food is worth the small trek.
Enjoy your meal and do not forget to leave a little tip for the hardworking staff. They are the ones who make sure your shrimp is hot and your drink is always full.