Craft burger concepts often carry premium prices, and Burgatory’s menu shows how house-made patties justify their cost. If you’re searching for the Burgatory Bar Menu with Prices, you’ve likely heard about their famous “build your own” burger system. This guide breaks down the full menu, what each item costs, and how to get the best value on your visit.
Burgatory is a Pittsburgh-born chain that treats burgers like a science experiment. They grind fresh meat daily, make their own buns, and even blend their own ketchup. The bar side of the menu is just as serious, with a huge selection of craft beers and custom cocktails.
Below, you’ll find the current pricing structure for every section of the menu. Keep in mind that prices can shift slightly by location, but these figures reflect the standard rates as of this year.
Burgatory Bar Menu With Prices
The full menu splits into two main experiences: the food menu and the bar program. You can order from both at the same table, and the kitchen stays open late on weekends. Here is the complete breakdown of what you will pay.
Signature Burgers And Their Costs
The signature burgers are pre-designed creations. They are not customizable, but they come with specific toppings that the kitchen recommends. Each burger includes one side of your choice.
- The “Burr-gatory” (Double Smash) – $16.99
- The “Dirty South” (Fried Chicken & Bacon) – $15.49
- The “El Diablo” (Spicy Chorizo & Pepper Jack) – $16.49
- The “Blarney” (Corned Beef & Swiss) – $15.99
- The “Bison Burger” (Lean & Juicy) – $17.99
- The “Veggie Burger” (House-made Black Bean) – $13.99
- The “Turkey Burger” (Herbed & Grilled) – $14.49
You can add an extra patty to any of these for $3.50. If you want to swap the side for a salad, that costs an additional $1.99.
Build Your Own Burger Pricing
This is the core of the Burgatory experience. You start with a base and then add layers. The pricing structure is simple and transparent.
First, pick your patty type. The price changes depending on the meat you choose.
- Classic Beef (Angus) – $11.99
- Smash Beef (Thin & Crispy) – $12.49
- Chicken Breast – $11.49
- Turkey Patty – $12.99
- Bison Patty – $14.99
- Veggie Patty – $10.99
Next, choose your bun. The standard brioche is included. Specialty buns like pretzel or gluten-free cost extra.
- Brioche (Standard) – Included
- Pretzel Bun – $1.00
- Gluten-Free Bun – $1.50
- Lettuce Wrap – Free
Finally, pick your cheese and toppings. The first two toppings are free. After that, each additional topping costs $0.75.
Cheese options include cheddar, American, Swiss, blue cheese, and pepper jack. All are included in the base price if you choose one. If you want two cheeses, that is an extra $1.25.
Bar Snacks And Starters
If you are not ready for a full burger, the starter menu has solid options. These are meant for sharing, but they work fine as a light meal.
- Burgatory Wings (6 pieces) – $9.99
- Burgatory Wings (12 pieces) – $17.99
- Pretzel Sticks with Beer Cheese – $8.49
- Fried Pickles with Ranch – $7.99
- Nachos with House Chips – $10.99
- Chili Cheese Fries – $8.99
- Onion Rings (Hand-Battered) – $6.99
The wings come in five different sauces. You can mix two sauces on the same plate for no additional charge. The nachos are loaded with cheddar, jalapenos, and pico de gallo.
Sandwiches And Entrees
Not everyone wants a burger. The menu includes a few non-burger options that are just as filling.
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich – $13.49
- Fish Sandwich (Beer-Battered Cod) – $14.99
- Philly Cheesesteak – $14.49
- House Salad with Grilled Chicken – $12.99
- Cobb Salad with Bacon – $13.49
The Philly uses shaved ribeye and provolone on a hoagie roll. The fish sandwich comes with tartar sauce and shredded lettuce. Salads are large enough to be a main course.
Kids Menu Pricing
If you are dining with children, the kids menu offers smaller portions at lower prices. Each kids meal comes with a drink and a small side.
- Kids Burger (Beef or Chicken) – $7.99
- Kids Grilled Cheese – $5.99
- Kids Chicken Tenders (3 pieces) – $6.99
- Kids Mac and Cheese – $5.49
All kids meals are served on a plastic tray with a coloring page. The drink options include milk, juice, or soda.
Milkshakes And Desserts
Burgatory is famous for its “adult” milkshakes. These are thick, hand-spun shakes that come with alcohol or without. The non-alcoholic versions are still rich and filling.
- Classic Vanilla or Chocolate Shake – $6.49
- Cookies and Cream Shake – $7.49
- Peanut Butter Cup Shake – $7.99
- Adult Shake (with Bourbon or Rum) – $9.99
- Brownie Sundae – $6.99
The adult shakes are a signature item. They are blended with ice cream and your choice of liquor. The most popular is the “Bourbon Caramel” shake.
Beer And Cocktail Prices
The bar menu is extensive. You will find local craft beers on tap as well as national favorites. The cocktail list changes seasonally, but the core drinks stay consistent.
Beer prices depend on the type and size. Here is the general structure.
- Domestic Draft (16 oz) – $5.50
- Craft Draft (16 oz) – $7.00 to $8.50
- Bottled Beer (12 oz) – $4.99 to $6.99
- Premium Import (12 oz) – $7.49
Cocktails range from $9.00 to $13.00. The “Burgatory Old Fashioned” is $12.50 and uses barrel-aged bitters. Wine by the glass starts at $7.00 for house selections.
If you want a beer flight, you can choose four 5-ounce pours for $10.99. This is a good way to sample local brews without committing to a full pint.
Happy Hour Specials And Deals
Happy hour runs Monday through Friday from 3 PM to 6 PM. The deals are only available at the bar area, not at regular tables.
- $2 off all draft beers
- $5 house wines
- $6 select appetizers
- $7 signature cocktails
The happy hour appetizer list is shorter than the regular menu. You will usually find wings, pretzel sticks, and fried pickles at the discounted price. The bar seats fill up fast, so arrive early if you want a spot.
How To Order To Save Money
You can control your final bill by making smart choices. Here are a few practical tips for keeping costs down.
- Skip the specialty buns. The brioche is already good.
- Limit your toppings to two. That keeps the base price low.
- Order water instead of soda. Drinks add up quickly.
- Share a milkshake. They are very large.
- Check the daily specials board. Some locations offer a “Burger of the Day” for a reduced price.
The “Burger of the Day” is often $2 to $3 cheaper than the regular signature burgers. It changes daily, so you never know what you will get. This is the best option for budget-conscious diners.
Location Differences In Pricing
Burgatory has locations in Pennsylvania, Ohio, and West Virginia. The prices we listed are averages. Urban locations like Pittsburgh or Cleveland may charge slightly more.
Suburban locations often have lower overhead costs. You might save $0.50 to $1.00 on a burger if you visit a location outside the city center. Airport locations are the most expensive, so avoid those if you have time before your flight.
Tax is not included in the listed prices. You should also plan for a 18% to 20% tip if you dine in. The service is generally fast, but the restaurant is often busy during peak hours.
Nutritional Information And Allergens
Burgatory provides a full allergen menu upon request. The kitchen handles nuts, gluten, and dairy in the same space. If you have severe allergies, you should inform your server before ordering.
The classic beef burger with one cheese and two toppings has approximately 850 calories. That includes the bun but not the side. If you add fries, expect another 400 calories. The veggie burger is lower at around 600 calories, but it is not vegan because it contains eggs and cheese.
Gluten-free buns are available, but the fries are cooked in a shared fryer. That means they are not safe for celiac patients. The kitchen staff is knowledgeable, so ask them directly about your specific dietary needs.
What Time Is The Kitchen Open?
The kitchen hours are slightly shorter than the bar hours. On weekdays, the kitchen closes at 10 PM. On Friday and Saturday, it stays open until 11 PM. The bar itself stays open until midnight or later.
If you arrive within 30 minutes of kitchen closing, you can still order. However, the kitchen may be out of certain items. The milkshake machine is often turned off 15 minutes before closing for cleaning.
Late-night happy hour runs from 10 PM to close on Fridays and Saturdays. This offers the same discounts as the afternoon happy hour. It is a popular option for people leaving concerts or sporting events.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Burgatory have a secret menu?
Yes, but it is not official. Ask for the “Burgatory Burger” which adds a fried egg and bacon jam to any patty. It costs about $2 more than the base price.
Can you order just a patty without the bun?
Yes, you can order any burger protein as a lettuce wrap for no extra charge. You can also order a plain patty with no toppings, which costs the same as the base burger.
Are the adult milkshakes worth the price?
They are large and strong. One shake is enough for two people to share. The alcohol content is generous, so the $9.99 price is reasonable compared to a regular cocktail.
Does Burgatory offer military or student discounts?
Some locations offer a 10% military discount with valid ID. Student discounts are not standard, but the Pittsburgh location near the university sometimes runs specials during the school year.
Can I order takeout from the bar menu?
Yes, the full menu is available for takeout. Alcohol cannot be included in takeout orders due to state laws. Milkshakes are available for takeout, but they may melt if you drive far.
The Burgatory bar menu with prices is straightforward once you understand the build-your-own system. You can get a filling meal for around $15 per person if you stick to the basics. The quality of the meat and the freshness of the toppings justify the cost compared to fast-food chains.
If you are a first-time visitor, start with the “Burr-gatory” signature burger. It shows off the house blend of beef and the special sauce. Pair it with a local craft beer on tap and you will see why this chain has such a loyal following.
Remember to check the location-specific menu before you go. Prices and specials can vary. The online menu is updated regularly, so you can always confirm the exact numbers before you arrive.